Posted on 04/18/2024 1:12:16 PM PDT by Twotone
When federal agents appear at the door, the most prudent response is to say, “Talk to my lawyer.” Just ask Zack Bonfilio.
Local law enforcement and the FBI are using a new tactic: the “knock and talk.” Pairs of agents are appearing on Americans’ doorsteps unannounced, uninvited, and invariably without a warrant, with the aim of gaining access. For what exactly? Information. Visual surveillance. Property searches. And the Fourth Amendment’s protections against warrantless searches? Authorities don’t seem terribly concerned.
According to the Rutherford Institute, “knock and talk” actions are initiated at private citizens’ homes without warning, often in the early morning or late evening. “A ‘knock and talk’ most often arises from anonymous, unsubstantiated, or hearsay information police possess that alleges illegal activity may be occurring at a particular home.”
These surprise visits are now frequently being executed based upon nothing more than anonymous “tips” received by the FBI and other agencies, often because of social media posts.
Zack Bonfilio of San Antonio, Texas, was on the receiving end of such a visit around 10:30 on the morning of February 29. Two FBI agents wanted to ask him questions about his social media activity.
Bonfilio, known online as “The Misfit Patriot,” wasn’t home when the special agents rang his doorbell, but he was able to respond to them remotely from his workplace. Once the agents identified themselves and showed their badges, Bonfilio gave Special Agent Tristan Hyland his phone number.
Immediately after taking Agent Hyland’s call, Bonfilio was told by the FBI agent that the visit concerned his social media activity. Bonfilio asked if this was about any specific social media post. “No,” Hyland replied. “We looked at your social media and found nothing illegal. We are just here to just check off a box. It’s procedure.”
Bonfilio instructed the agents to speak with his attorney. He then explained that his attorney contacted the FBI “five seconds after I got off the phone with them.” Bonfilio told Blaze Media his attorney has attempted to reach Hyland for six weeks, without success.
Yet on April 2 at 11:45 a.m., Hyland left a voice message on Bonfilio’s phone, which he provided to Blaze Media. “I was calling just to follow up on our conversation we had a few weeks ago,” the agent said. “Just wondering if you were able to reach out to your attorney yet? I haven’t heard anything from you or them, so I would like to get something on the books.”
Bonfilio confirmed that his attorney has made additional attempts to reach Hyland but that she had yet to hear back from Hyland as of publication.
Bonfilio says he doesn’t know what the FBI wants with him. He denies ever posting any threatening or inflammatory language. He conjectures the only post that might have elicited a “tip” to the FBI was a series of comments on X (formerly Twitter) he made in response to the self-immolation of pro-Palestinian protester Aaron Bushnell.
Bushnell, who on February 25 set himself on fire outside the gate of the Israeli embassy in Washington, D.C., set off a viral online reaction. Bonfilio shared screenshots of a few of his responses, which have since been removed. Those include statements and replies made by Bonfilio, including:
This man is a murderer. He didn’t “give” his life for anything. He took his own life, he killed himself. He murdered the man he was to push a political agenda in support of people who chant “death to America.” He was quite literally a domestic terrorist.
Do not even think of feeling bad for him. He got what he wanted, he’s a martyr for a mob of terrorist sympathizers and a hero to Hamas. He’s no different than a suicide bomber.
I stand by what I said earlier and have no more sympathy or excuses for crazy when it comes to supporting terrorism. If you’ve had 100 concussions and start chanting from the river to the sea, you can set yourself on fire too for all I care.
In reply to another X user who’d characterized Bushnell as a “hero” to the Palestinian cause, Bonfilio wrote: “I nominate you to light yourself on fire to show you are as brave as Aaron, since you think he's such a hero. You people are f***in retarded.”
Bonfilio said that while those statements contained no threats of violence, they were as “aggressive” as anything he’s ever posted on social media. He noted that the FBI’s visit came only a couple of days after he posted his comments about Bushnell.
Humorously, while awaiting a response to the doorbell ring, the two FBI agents can be seen looking down at Bonfilio’s doormat, which reads, “COME BACK WITH A WARRANT.” One of the agents remarked, “That’s pretty funny.”
Former FBI special agent turned whistleblower Kyle Seraphin said “knock and talk” visits are typically generated from tips received through the agency’s “e-Guardian system,” and the visits are usually performed by low-level, young, or more inexperienced agents.
“Unfortunately, FBI agents are not allowed to engage in critical thinking and determine, based on the nature of the threat, whether or not it’s a First Amendment-protected activity or whether that person needs to be interviewed,” Seraphin said.
The trouble with “box-checking” visits, Seraphin explained, is that the agents are “not empowered to ... close the lead out.” There are no logical investigative steps for agents to follow because they’re investigating constitutionally protected activity.
“And that’s the real problem with having a non-thinking FBI,” he said.
Seraphin said Bonfilio responded to the FBI’s queries properly. “The right answer is always to not answer any questions” he said. The only prudent response of any private citizen to an attempted “knock and talk” visit should be to direct the questions to an attorney.
Blaze Media contacted FBI Special Agent Hyland directly for a comment. A spokesman for the FBI’s San Antonio field office declined to comment on Bonfilio’s case.
Minor point of order: Knock and talk is not a new tactic. That said, these panty sniffers should always be shown the way out of town.
The most appropriate response is no response at all. Open your door to strangers at your own peril.
Best thing it to tell the FBI I have nothing to say, contact my lawyer and get the heck off my property like now.
I guess a “knock and talk” is better than their standard Modus Operandi:
Flash Bang SWAT raid at 6:00am
Do not talk to the police. And especially do not talk to the FBI. Lying to the FBI is a federal crime. People have done serious jail time for that.
But suppose you are always honest, and would never, ever lie. No matter. Anything you can say can be twisted twenty different ways.
Be nice. Be polite. But do not talk to them.
Don’t Talk to the Police
19,246,682 views Mar 20, 2012
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d-7o9xYp7eE
Regent Law Professor James Duane gives viewers startling reasons why they should always exercise their 5th Amendment rights when questioned by government officials.
There are good reasons this has over 19 million views. If you haven’t watched this, you should.
Besides “You don’t have a warrant? Then I’m not interested in talking to you without an attorney present”, you should get names/cards, pictures / video of their presence, and report them to your local Sheriff’s Department or PD via 911. “I have two gentlemen presenting themselves as FBI agents, I just want a record of this.”
Mr. Baker says the best thing to do is direct them to your lawyer. But why do I have to pay a lawyer to tell the FBI to MYOB or come back with a warrant.
The doormat (see video) should’ve done the trick. I might invest in one of those.
But Feebs lying to Citizens is expected and rewarded.
Every Feeb, and for that matter every cop of any sort, must be presumed a liar until proven otherwise.
and if you are in a wheelchair, you’ll likely get shot
knock & walk.
This guy’s tweets were totally innocuous and the FBI’s response was nothing short of harassment. The FBI must have too much extra time on their hands if they are responding to stuff like this.
And make sure that you aren’t a mother holding her baby in the presence of the FBI. The FBI hates baby holding mothers almost as much as they hate dogs and the Constitution.
They were just salesmen, offering Mr Bonfilio the chance to win an all inclusive vacation at the Gray Bar Resort.
“...No matter. Anything you can say can be twisted twenty different ways.”
I remember G. Gordon Liddy saying (on his radio show) “if they come to my house, they better have their heads completely encased in Kevlar.”
He was talking about the Secret Service, but still.
I don’t have a Blaze subscription and it won’t let me in.
What does the doormat say?
Seems like sometimes an intimidation tactic by the anonymous “tipster”...a gentler form of swatting.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.