Skip to comments.
Need Freeper help: PCs vs. Mac
Posted on 02/02/2004 9:34:22 AM PST by Maceman
OK Freepers --
My 80-year old Mom needs a new computer, and has asked me for advice on whether to get a PC or a Mac. (Her old computer, which she got in 1999, is a Gateway PC running Windows 98.)
I am a Windows person. I have been very pleased with the Windows XP Professional OS that came with my computer, which I bought in 2001. If my mom gets a Mac, I will not be able to help her with troubleshooting as I have in the past.
On the other hand, her neighbor is a Mac-person, is available to help her with trouble shooting, and has been aggressively lobbying for her to get a Mac.
My Mom is very smart, and has learned the PC environment well. She is not a power user, but she knows how to reinstall Windows and can do a lot of other cool stuff.
But she is confused by the conflicting input she is getting from me and her neighbor.
Cost is definitely a consideration here.
So I put it to my fellow Freepers -- should my Mom's next desktop be a Mac or a Windows XP PC? (Please let's not complicate things with Linux).
TOPICS: Your Opinion/Questions
KEYWORDS:
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20, 21-40, 41-60, 61-80, 81-100 next last
To: Maceman
The
eMac is quite inexpensive (under $1000, I believe). Here's why I'd go Mac:
- VIRUSES! (Or lack thereof)
- Mac OS X is the best consumer OS, bar none. It recognizes peripherals like no other, and usually requires no additional drivers.
- Did I mention viruses?
41
posted on
02/02/2004 9:56:37 AM PST
by
gonewt
To: TheBigB
I agree.
It's not like we're arguing over GM vs. Ford. I mean, we all know the GM's are superior... That and the imports are aluminum foil steel and lawn mower engines.
But I'm not one to start a brawl...
Comment #43 Removed by Moderator
To: Maceman
I have a Mac, PC, and Linux box here at the U of U. PCs are great for Office apps, but the Macs are the best for graphics. If you can afford a G5 with the OSX.3 Panther, get it. If not, then go with a Dell/Gateway special. If you're just doing basic stuff, there's no need to spend extra money. One good thing for non-computer pros is your chance of getting a virus with a Mac is pretty small.
To: TheBigB
Panasonic sucks.</g>
To: Maceman
If she's not a computer person, get her a PC and she'll probably become one. Get her a Mac and it's doubtful.
To: Maceman
We have both. Lately, the macs haven't been as dependable as they were.
PC's screw up all the time,too, but I can always fix them.
To: Richard Kimball
Oy. Now look what I started. :^)
48
posted on
02/02/2004 10:00:23 AM PST
by
TheBigB
(My opinions aren't formed with your approval in mind.)
To: sarasota
We have a winner! Get her an iBook. PC advocates always amaze me with their advice on avoiding trouble by going Windows. It's like the joke about owning the same axe for thirty years... except for three new heads and two new handles.
49
posted on
02/02/2004 10:00:30 AM PST
by
Woahhs
To: Maceman
Get an old television and tape a photograph of a Windows desktop on it, and then slowly lower the dosage on all her medication while expousing things like "user friendliness" and "overall cost of ownership".
50
posted on
02/02/2004 10:01:22 AM PST
by
SpaceBar
To: Maceman
If she gets a Mac, sooner or later she'll end up at the airport in a long saffron robe, along with the other Macmoonies.
It's a cult, you know.
51
posted on
02/02/2004 10:01:49 AM PST
by
Hank Rearden
(Dick Gephardt. Before he dicks you.)
To: BadAndy
Mac users are usually found on the DU site. Real conservatives use PCs. {:-] Ever hear of Rush Limbaugh?
52
posted on
02/02/2004 10:12:32 AM PST
by
Woahhs
To: Maceman
At 80, who is she more comfortable with--you or the neighbor? Who will she call on first when she has a problem--you or the neighbor? Who will come to her rescue first--you or the neighbor? Since she's already familiar with the PC and windows, stay with what's she is used to? At 80, familiarity is lot more important than you think.
53
posted on
02/02/2004 10:12:34 AM PST
by
lilylangtree
(Olde English takes a long time to say, and we never say anything unless it takes a long time to say)
To: Maceman
My Mom is very smart, and has learned the PC environment well. You just answered your own question. Get her a nice Dell, and kindly tell her neighbor to STICK A SOCK IN IT. Windows XP works just like 98, except it's better -more stable, and even EASIER to use. And you get set it up so it looks alot like Win98 if you want. There will be little to know learning curve for her, and it can run ALL THE SOFTWARE she currently uses and is familiar with. Remember, you're not just buying a new platform when you get a MAC, but a whole bunch of new software to go with it. Don't forget that little bit of info as you do your cost/benefit calculations. It was that reason ALONE that kept me in the world of PC's, and stopped me from switching to the Dark Side. I've got several thousand's of dollars worth of software, and some of these titles I use frequently have no Mac equivalent.
I use both PC's and MAC's, and I GREATLY PREFER the Windows/Intel/AMD platform. It's not even a contest.
Sure, MAC's don't get all all the lovely worms & virus's that the PC's do...but why would anyone want to write a virus for a platform only being used by five or six people?
Enough said. Go get her a Dell for $700. She'll love it.
54
posted on
02/02/2004 10:13:24 AM PST
by
Ronzo
(GOD alone is enough.)
To: Maceman
In this case, I would most definitely go with a PC, I work on both on a daily basis, Although MACs are more powerful with OS X, they have become relatively difficult to get used to if you are a windows user. Go to Dell.com, get her a refurbished model, you can get a 256 ram 2.4ghrz desktop for around $450. You can't even look at a MAc these days without spending that much.
55
posted on
02/02/2004 10:16:46 AM PST
by
Conservomax
(shill: One who poses as a satisfied customer or an enthusiastic gambler to dupe bystanders into part)
To: Maceman
The mac I had at home was serving me more as a big paper weight, so I gave it to my parents. They love it.
56
posted on
02/02/2004 10:18:35 AM PST
by
new cruelty
(Better the devil you know than the devil don't)
To: Maceman
I definitely recommend a Mac for your mom. It is absolutely the best choice for her - and most other typical computer users.
I know some senior citizens who use Macs - and it has been a good machine for all of them. One of them migrated from PC to an iMac a few weeks ago after he had shoulder surgery. He got Apple's wireless keyboard and mouse because it was easier to work with the limited mobility in his arm. He likes that fact that the Mac user interface is less cluttered and easier to use. He uses his Mac mainly to manage his investment portfolio.
I know another who also has limited mobility due to a stroke. He's been using Macs quite successfully for a couple of years to surf the Internet, take digital photos, etc. He now has a Mac G5 with a 23-inch Studio Display.
My mom is a Mac user too. She is doing much more stuff on her Mac than she ever did on her PC - digital photography, burning audio CDs, listen to streaming radio stations, etc. I got her an iSight camera for Christmas so we can do video chats. She loves it.
57
posted on
02/02/2004 10:18:50 AM PST
by
HAL9000
To: Hank Rearden
If she gets a Mac, sooner or later she'll end up at the airport in a long saffron robe, along with the other Macmoonies. It's a cult, you know. Who needs tinfoil when you have an iPod?
58
posted on
02/02/2004 10:21:15 AM PST
by
Woahhs
To: Maceman
Forget all this PC/Mac crap foisted on you by tool-worshippers. Get her a second-hand Cray. Not only is it blindingly fast but it acts as a secondary source of heat for her home and also a stylish circular sofa.
To: Woahhs; All
Ever hear of Rush Limbaugh?Ever hear of George 'Dubya' Bush???
60
posted on
02/02/2004 10:30:08 AM PST
by
Lael
(http://fourthturning.com)
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20, 21-40, 41-60, 61-80, 81-100 next last
Disclaimer:
Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual
posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its
management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the
exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson