Posted on 01/27/2008 4:43:17 AM PST by PJ-Comix
Since McCain and his surrogates insist on making this a big issue, let's engage them. They are dissembling about what Romney said. I have provided quotes below. We have now heard from Woolsey, who is repeating the disinformation. And we have now viewed the video-tape, which clears Romney of the allegation, i.e., he did not call for a specific time to withdraw our troops. Now, if this is the big bombshell the McCain campaign is using in the days before the Florida vote (albeit people are casting votes throughout via absentee ballots), it's pretty disgraceful stuff. Even the Associated Press has figure it. See below:
Republicans McCain, Romney spar over Iraq war ahead of Florida presidential primary (UPDATED)
By LIZ SIDOTI Associated Press Writer
SARASOTA, Fla. (AP) _ JohnMcCain accused MittRomney Saturday of wanting to set a timetable for withdrawing U.S. troops from Iraq, drawing an immediate protest from his Republican presidential rival, who said: ''That's simply wrong and it's dishonest, and he should apologize.''
McCain countered: ''I think the apology is owed to the young men and women serving this nation in uniform, that we will not let them down in hard times or good. That is who the apology is owed to.''
The Arizona senator stood before a crowd in Sun City, Fla., and said he was quoting Romney as favoring a ''timetable for withdrawal.'' However, quotes circulated by McCain's campaign didn't show Romney making that comment.
''Clearly, the impression was that he was ready to set a date for withdrawal. You can't read it any other way,'' McCain explained.
The exchange highlighted the growing intensity of the race in Florida in the final weekend before Tuesday's primary, a campaign that previously had been a fairly civil debate over economic records and leadership credentials.
By raising Iraq, McCain sought to shift the campaign in Florida back to his strength, national security, and away from Romney's, the economy. Aides portrayed McCain's Iraq comments as part of a broader effort in the coming days to question Romney's leadership, foreign policy experience and judgment.
Speaking in Fort Myers, Fla., McCain said of Iraq: ''If we surrender and wave a white flag, like Senator Clinton wants to do, and withdraw, as GovernorRomney wanted to do, then there will be chaos, genocide, and the cost of American blood and treasure would be dramatically higher.''
Minutes earlier, the Arizona senator took a slap at Romney without naming him during a question-and-answer session with Floridians, saying: ''Now, one of my opponents wanted to set a date for withdrawal that would have meant disaster.''
Asked about the comment in Land O' Lakes, Fla., Romney bristled.
''That's dishonest, to say that I have a specific date. That's simply wrong,'' he said. ''That is not the case. I've never said that.''
The former Massachusetts governor added: ''I know he's trying desperately to change the topic from the economy and trying to get back to Iraq, but to say something that's not accurate is simply wrong _ and he knows better.''
During the campaign stop later in Sun City, McCain clipped three words from a quotation of Romney's last April, saying the former Massachusetts believed the country should set a ''timetable for withdrawal.''
In an interview with ABC News last April, Romney never uttered those words but said: ''There's no question that the president and (Iraqi) Prime Minister al-Maliki have to have a series of timetables and milestones that they speak about. But those shouldn't be for public pronouncement. You don't want the enemy to understand how long they have to wait in the weeds until you're going to be gone.''
Romney aides labeled McCain's charge ''stunningly false'' in an e-mail to campaign reporters.
In addition to saying that President Bush and Iraqi leaders should have private timetables and benchmarks with which to gauge progress on the war and determine troop levels, Romney has also said he agrees with Gen. David Petraeus, the top U.S. commander in Iraq, that U.S. troops could move to more of an oversight role in 2008.
McCain, for his part, has been a staunch supporter of the Iraq war and advocated more troops on the ground for years before Bush embraced that position last year and ramped up the number of U.S. forces in Iraq. The buildup helped curb violence in Iraq, and McCain has not been shy about claiming credit for the strategy's success.
The escalating tit-for-tat between McCain and Romney underscores the closeness of the race and the stakes for both. Recent polls show the two locked in a tight fight for the lead in a state that offers the winner a hefty 57 delegates to the GOP's nominating convention next summer and a shot of energy heading into a virtual national primary on Feb. 5.
A former venture capitalist and business consultant, Romney has spent the past week arguing that he is the Republican best able to right a troubled economy given his 25-year record in the private sector.
McCain, in turn, has sought to beat back Romney on the issue by arguing that a president needs to be ready to lead and qualified on both national security and economics, and he offers both _ despite having previously acknowledged that the economy is not his strongest suit.
Elsewhere, two candidates trailing McCain and Romney in polls sought to gain ground.
In Sarasota, RudyGiuliani argued that he is a perfect combination of the two _ encompassing McCain's foreign policy strength and Romney's economic know-how. ''I've had experience in both areas and results in both areas,'' the former New York mayor said after drawing a few hundred people to a restaurant on a town square.
Mike Huckabee toured a 1,600-acre, family-owned farm in Lake Whales and talked with local citrus growers about challenges facing them: hurricanes, crop diseases and the cost of labor. He also sampled barbecue and posed for pictures with supporters at the Lakeland Pig Fest.
UPDATE: As I think about McCain's effort to now use the battle of Iraq this way - to inaccurately characterize Romney's statement re Iraq, to refuse to correct himself despite the evidence showing his characterization is false, and now to say —in response to Romney demanding an apology — ''I think the apology is owed to the young men and women serving this nation in uniform, that we will not let them down in hard times or good. That is who the apology is owed to'' — is to use Iraq and the soldiers as the Left does. Jim Woolsey has already been sucked into this. I hope others won't be.
McCain trying to draw attention from the economy, where he is admittedly weak, to the war where he has more strength is pretty shrewd. However, if the economy was doing as well as the war we would be on the road to recovery. It makes little sense to elect someone who understands a war we are beginning to win and no understanding of an economy that could be in the early stages of a tailspin.
Left alone on its current course the war is going to be on an upward course. We need someone now who can do for the economy what has been done for the war.
If a candidate uses his opponent’s record it’s that record, not the candidate, that determines if the campaign is negative. It was McCain who got it wrong on immigration, McCain who got it wrong on campaign financing, McCain who got it wrong on handling captured terrorists, McCain who got it wrong on the Gang of 14, etc.
Point all this out is a negative reflection on McCain, not the one who points it out. Presented correctly it should be possible to keep the listeners from confusing the difference between doing something negative and pointing out the one who did it!
McNasty. McLoon. McLame.
It’s almost as fun morphing that name as it is Huckaboober.
FRiend, the truth is, we have our backs against the wall... With each passing day, we run into a huge headwind, of liberal media, lies from McCain, religious bigots, and hate from radical loons on the right... Just look at FR and the scum that constantly spews lies about him... What a disgrace... I’m still hopeful, but not as optimistic as as I was a week ago...
McCain: Self righteous little prick.
Desperate times for McCain call for desperate measures.
unfortunately, most people have attention spans of a flea and get their news from soundbites. We can't rely on them deciphering the truth on their own
Absolutely. Self-righteous and vindictive. He hates us all, very much. And he will get even with us if he is elected.
I like your DeNiro immitation!
I agree... I like your tagline.. Thank you for your service
What would it be like to have these two, McCain and Hillary run against eachother in the general? Who could out do who with lies and distortion's of the truth and then accuse the other of what they themselves are guilty of? Don't put it past the American people to pick two shallow, mean liars to run the nation.
Then why bother to post? Just to say you don’t care? We don’t care that you don’t care
Lying SOB McCain and his surrogates must be stopped before they trash the 1st amendment to shutdown all political speech to counter this kind of nonsense
Speaking for my son, currently on patrol in Bagdhad this morning, I can tell you, Mr. McCain, to take your lies and shove them where the sun don't shine.
Yes. And, since the Economy is currently more important to voters than Iraq, Romney should match and raise him (Executive Experience) by simply saying in response, "Senator McCain is trying to move the discussion away from the Economy because he has no Executive experience or experience in business and has no clue regarding how to deal with our economic problems. [Same argument that will be applied to Senator Hillary.]
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.