Posted on 10/17/2012 8:20:54 AM PDT by Ernest_at_the_Beach
In my estimation, last nights debate was a draw. Both men did what they needed to do for the debate, but neither had enough of a breakout performance to make much of a difference in the race. Id expect to see very little impact to the Mitt-mentum that developed after the first debate, for reasons which Ill address in a moment.
That wasnt the conclusion reached by Frank Luntz focus group of former Barack Obama voters, and now undecideds, in Nevada. That panel overwhelmingly chose Mitt Romney as the winner, with observations about Romneys presidential mien and Obamas defensiveness and lack of vision for a second term. But one woman, whom (as Luntz jokes) bears a strong resemblance to Ruth Bader Ginsburg, neatly sums up the status of many undecideds, as well as Obamas big problem with these debates:
**************************
I was not undecided between Obama and Romney. I was undecided between Romney and not voting.
Thats the problem for any incumbent President in the final days of the election. They get almost four years to make the case for another term. If voters are still undecided with three weeks left to go, the best an incumbent can hope to do is convince them not to vote at all. That has been the explicit campaign strategy of Team Obama since Romney wrapped up the nomination in May to make him so toxic that the protest vote against Obama stays home.
Unfortunately, that strategy collapsed after the first debate, and its collapse made the strategy obvious enough to be offensive. Last night, Obama finally decided to show some passion about wanting a second term, but he still hasnt explained why he wants it or what hell do with it, even during last nights debate. The only case he offered was that he wasnt Mitt Romney, the same argument that Obama used before the first debate. And he spent most of the evening speaking with an oddly high-pitched tone, as if he was offended that he even needed to go that far.
Obama gave those undecideds no reason last night to vote for him or to stay home on Election Day. Thats why nothing that happened in the debate will change the trajectory of the race.
Meanwhile, if youre unimpressed with a Fox focus group, you can always balance that out with MSNBCs focus group of undecideds from last night. Final score there: Obama 1, Romney 1, with the other six abstaining from a choice until after the next debate:
****************************************************
Thats not exactly a ringing endorsement for an Obama victory claim.
Update: My Townhall brother Guy Benson says I should rewatch the MSNBC focus group:
Hey Ed, saw your post (I have one going up on the focus groups later, too) .Id gently nudge you toward re-watching MSNBCs. I think 1-1 and 6 undeclared is very generous to Obama. Two people explicitly said theyre going Romney, and another said shes leaning towards him now. One girl said Obama, the others didnt commit, but even the African American remained unsold on O. Just wanted to point that out!
Id watch it again, but it seems to be down on the YouTube site for some reason. I relied more on the tally from the moderator of the group, but Guy may well be correct.
Good news from NBC elections social media tracker shows a drop in support for Obama since debate. Unscientific but has mirrored trends so far this race. Currently Romney leads by 6 in announced support while Mitt has slightly positive posts from others and Obama is 60-40 negative.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.