Posted on 01/04/2013 5:43:51 PM PST by Katechon
Whoa, wait a minute...
FPS games are PRODUCING (your word) a new generation of gang killers....
...and you can’t tell me why two major American cities have different levels of gang violence or what relationship FPS games have to that violence...
...but you expect us to agree to a ban on these games?
Really?
1) Television has nothing to do with TRAINING for the act of murder, like FPS videogames do.
How do you know that television has nothing to do with TRAINING for the act of murder, like FPS videogames do.
Because Grossman is talking about the act of killing another human being.
The training began with bullseyes, then pop-up humanoid silhouettes, then video-games.
With Televsion, you don’t do anything to influence what is happening on the TV screen. But you do with videogames.
1) Television has nothing to do with TRAINING for the act of murder, like FPS videogames do.
How do you know that television has nothing to do with TRAINING for the act of murder, like FPS videogames do.
Because Grossman is talking about the act of killing another human being.
The training began with bullseyes, then pop-up humanoid silhouettes, then video-games.
With Televsion, you don’t do anything to influence what is happening on the TV screen. But you do with videogames.
That civil war extends into the City Hall. With bosses owning the government.
I'm not sure there is a fix. Chicago may go the way of Detroit.
But other cities don't have those problems like that.
Video games aren't the problem. Communist governments are.
/johnny
If you believe the most violent city in America has its violence problem “first and foremost” because of drugs and you cannot even explain what the role of video games is, IF ANY, in that mess, why do you expect to ban a legal product?
Banning Halo 4 and legalizing crack should fix the murder capital of the USA up nicely.
That’s indeed what Grossman is saying...
FPS videogames are producing a whole generation trained to kill but without the discipline of the military/police/militia.
And I’ve not read in his articles any compararive studies between cities.
Grossman is anchoring his thesis in the genesis and evolution of militarys marksmanship training.
“With Televsion, you dont do anything to influence what is happening on the TV screen. But you do with videogames.”
Then show the evidence of your assertion. Show the tens of thousands of documented video game killers with police reports and court cases.
And the statistical millions of deaths that resulted since the 70s.
one does not need stats to know that when you play a videogame, you influence what is happening within the game. Otherwise, it would be called watching, not playing.
on the subject of evidence, there is a lot of stuff on Grossman’s website: http://www.killology.com
Then what good is a thesis with no evidence to back it?
An F in any college I know of.
Short of nukes, or getting replacement for Mrs. O'Malley's cow... meh... it can't make it any worse, except for the rape of the Constitution.
/johnny
BTW, he has none of the evidence as there IS no evidence.
Produce any proof at all. You or he will be the first in history.
LOL.
I thought Detroit had the highest murder rate.
By the way, as per statistics, Grossman brings a fascinating point: a more relevant stat is “aggravated assault”, in order to take into account the progress of medecine — since ‘murder rate’ only accounts for successful assaults.
He does provide a lot of evidence to back his thesis. I’m just being a poor advocate here.
yes, socialism and islam are the main problem — that is for sure.
but the dangerousness of socialism and islam does not exclude Grossman’s thesis.
Otherwise, a hypothosis without test and evidence is just so much flatulance, regardless of how much sense it makes to you.
I can show you proof that murders in general in the US are falling, and sales of video games are up.
/johnny
I don’t play the victim; I’m only asking you to be polite.
And Grossman ain’t stripping nobody from their God-given and Constitutionnal rights.
He’s saying that FPS videogames provide an effective training to become-killer without the necessary discipline.
What about the FACT that those FPS videogames function as MASS-MURDER TRAINING, simulator, rewiring the brain to over-come our native resistance to kill our own species?
Katechon:
#1 I suggest you BAN yourself from FPS shooter games and stick to your sissy easy-bake-oven and leave everyone else alone. Or if you must feel the need to control something....go buy a few "choose your own adventure books" so you can preview the outcomes
#2 When you state something as "FACT" saying it doesn't make it so. Cain didn't kill Abel because he played a FPS game.....he did it out of jealousy and his own personal interest. So much for native resistance to killing our own species since that's how it was in the beginning after The Fall of the human race.....I guess that's also why war is a relatively new thing only invented in the 70s......oh wait.
#3 If you favor banning FPS games - How do I fit into your equation? I've killed actual people and I'm not a big fan of video games or television. I mean you want to ban an object because it may make people think about killing. I've already actually done killing and could care less about your stupid video games. What would you have in store for me with your knee jerk reactions?
No he does not. There is no evidence that shows millions of deaths. There is no evidence that shows normal people killing as a result of playing games. If there was, you and he would post it. And you cannot post what does not exist.
This has been enlightening. It has been some time since the libs sent someone to argue a completely vapid position in an attempt to rile up the Right.
But all you did was solidify support among the ranks. Thanks for that.
So tell whoever is feeding you lines that you failed. But here’s a tip for next time. Pick a subject that truly divides. Like Golf clubs. NOTHING will set one FReeper against another faster than a Golf Club discussion. Dozens have been banned in the past, so try that next time.
I might catch hell for letting it slip, but oh well. It’s my way of apologizing for holding you to account.
” Cain didn’t kill Abel because he played a FPS game.....he did it out of jealousy and his own personal interest. So much for native resistance to killing our own species since that’s how it was in the beginning after The Fall of the human race....”
Yes, as the old rabbis are saying, Cain was the ‘son of wrath,’; they think he’s the son of satan, a precursor to Masteman (who will then become allah).
There is evil in this world, and it certainly not an effect of FPS shooting.
It’s not about war either; there are JUST wars (such as the Crusades), and evil armies need to be exterminated (such as the armies of allah).
But the point of Grossman ain’t about evil nor war. It’s about training kids to become (potential) killers without any discipline.
He says those training is used my islamic militias and gang members, among many other people.
Polite is not barging into someone else's business with your bad ideas on reducing freedom in America.
Stick your nose in, expect hostility.
Did Pol-Pot use video games for his killing gangs? Or were they just thugs and that made them effective?
/johnny
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.