The most important boring idea in the universe

Big Think ^ | 8 Jul, 2021 | ADAM FRANK

[left that other site]

This simple statement is the key to science:

If it (a theory) disagrees with experiment, then it’s WRONG.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EYPapE-3FRw

[DoodleBob]

I’m not arguing that we should stop using math and, say, use astrology. I AM saying that equating the uncertainty of ______ (science, economics, agricultural mechanization benefits, robotic efficiency gains, etc.) with the certainty of math, is a yuge part of the problem.

[left that other site]

Indeed.

A perfect illustration is the story of the humble egg:

1. Eggs are GOOD for you. They are full of protein.

2. Eggs are BAD for you. They are full of cholesterol.

3. Eggs are GOOD for you. They have no carbs.

4. Eggs are BAD for you, they are full of FAT.

5. Fat is BAD for you. Eat more Pasta. Just not made with Eggs.

6. Pasta is BAD for you. Too many carbs. Fat can be good for you, as long as it’s not cholesterol.

7. Not ALL cholesterol is Bad for you. HDL is bad, LDL is Good.

8. I have no idea what the current verdict of “settled science” is saying regarding Eggs. However, my S-I-L who worships “Science” has a flock of Chickens and sells delicious fresh eggs for $4.00 a dozen.

[BipolarBob]

. I AM saying that equating the uncertainty of ______ (science, economics, agricultural mechanization benefits, robotic efficiency gains, etc.) with the certainty of math, is a yuge part of the problem.

Any uncertainties will be accounted for over time and corrected leading to a more clear and complete understanding of the universe. To refuse to go forward is Luddite thinking. Math is essential to progress but this Harvard chap can gloat over his understanding of Critical Race Theory as if he has accomplished something.

[TalBlack]

The Church regarded science and the scientific method as the means by which the secrets of God might be known. But of course Islam was all scienced up too…you know because diversity.

[FamiliarFace]

Thanks for your post and the link. I went back and read all of that, having missed it before. Great stuff there!