Posted on 01/11/2006 4:34:45 PM PST by Pikamax
By DAVID STOUT
WASHINGTON, Jan. 11 - Judge Samuel A. Alito Jr., President Bush's nominee for the Supreme Court, sat through another day of high praise from Republicans and sharp skepticism from Democrats today as he cautiously laid out his judicial philosophy - too cautiously in the view of Democrats, who pressed him for his stance on abortion law.
(Excerpt) Read more at nytimes.com ...
"I think the Framers would be stunned by the idea that the Bill of Rights is to be interpreted by taking a poll of the countries of the world," Judge Alito said. "The purpose of the Bill of Rights was to give Americans rights that were recognized practically nowhere else in the world at the time. The Framers did not want Americans to have the rights of people in France or the rights of people in Russia or any of the other countries on the continent of Europe at the time; they wanted them to have the rights of Americans."
The nominee was, at least implicitly, finding fault with the Supreme Court's ruling on March 1 that outlawed the execution of killers who were under 18 at the time of their crimes. That opinion, decided by a 5-4 majority, relied in part on the trend of international opinion against the death penalty, especially for youthful offenders.
But Judge Alito said he saw "a host of practical problems" if American jurists are to look overseas.
"You have to decide which countries you're going to survey," he said. "And then it's often difficult to understand exactly what you are to make of foreign court decisions. All countries don't set up their court systems the same way." Foreign courts may have greater authority, or have policy-making roles, he said.
His testimony today echoed his response to a question on Wednesday, when he said: "We have our own law. We have our own traditions. We have our own precedents. And we should look to that in interpreting our Constitution."
The New York Times is spinning its wheels on this one. I can't see how anyone reading this column could be more opposed to Alito than they were before reading it. They really can't find much to say against him.
I notice they don't even mention the Princeton business.
Effin A Alito!
Now Sam, the next time Kennedy implies that you are a bigot, ask him to step outside to discuss it and then knock that fat drunken load right on his ass.
Judge Alito is not a bigot since he has too much class to point out the fact that Turd Kennedy is a murderer.
Judge Alito, WHEN you are confirmed would you please make your first order of bsiness to schedule a little "chat" with Justice Kennedy? I'd suggest Breyer, Ginsburg, Souter and Stevens but doubt they'd listen. Kennedy is more wishy washy which is why the left loves him.
Best advice Alito can get is that he not find himself alone in a room with Breyer, Ginsburg, Souter and Stevens.
If Alito were to walk into such a room he would lower the average age by 30 years & raise the average IQ by 30 points.
"I think the Framers would be stunned by the idea that the Bill of Rights is to be interpreted by taking a poll of the countries of the world," Judge Alito said. "The purpose of the Bill of Rights was to give Americans rights that were recognized practically nowhere else in the world at the time. The Framers did not want Americans to have the rights of people in France or the rights of people in Russia or any of the other countries on the continent of Europe at the time; they wanted them to have the rights of Americans."
Standing up, applauding! Thank you, Judge Alito!
Ever notice how the libs like to refer to "European law" but would never refer to Saudi law?
With Alito, I think the Dims have had enough, but the media just won't let them toss in the towel. It must be very unpleasant to be a democrat Senator or Senate staffer tonight. It's almost enough to make me feel a bit sorry for them. Almost.
You can't quite feel their pain?
It's just a matter of time and you'll have Ginsburg coming around to the Saudi point of view.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.