Posted on 04/28/2009 2:48:46 PM PDT by reaganaut1
The departure of Arlen Specter looks very bad for the GOP. You never want to lose anyone. But could Senate Republicans have stopped it? No, not once it became clear that he was going to be trounced in his primary. Specter's problem is not the party in the sense of its leadership or direction, but rather with the Republican voters in Pennsylvania.
Arlen Specter switched from Democrat to Republican in 1965 so that he could win an election. He is now doing the reverse for precisely the same reason.
If we take Arlen Specter's word for why he is leaving, we have to accept the idea that the stimulus vote represented some kind of huge turning point for him. In fact, Specter's apostasy on that vote was less remarkable than several others — for example, his vote on the Employee Free Choice Act, or his courageous refusal to vote either "yes" or "no" on Bill Clinton's impeachment. The reason the stimulus vote matters is that it matters to voters and has become an issue in the primary — which again, is the only reason Specter is leaving the Republican Party.
If we take Specter's word, then the GOP has become intolerant of moderate politicians like himself. On this score, Specter appears to have a severe case of amnesia. Exactly five years ago, the national Republican Party swooped into Pennsylvania and saved him from certain defeat at the hands of Rep. Pat Toomey (R). Valuable presidential time was sacrificed on his behalf. Also sacrificed for Arlen Specter was the reputation of his conservative colleague, Rick Santorum (R), who never recovered. From that moment forward, he lost his core constituency, and was easily defeated two years later by a pro-life Democrat.
Without essential help from the party that is so intolerant of people like him, Arlen Specter would already be a former senator today. It is not the party but the voters in Pennsylvania who have stopped tolerating Specter.
If we take Specter's word, then conservatives act in bad faith when they become involved in the political process and try to elect the candidates of their choice. Conservatives should disengage from the political process and stop challenging people like Arlen Specter. They should not organize — whether through groups like the Club for Growth or otherwise — nor should they participate in the political process, nor donate to nor vote for candidates they prefer.
Specter noted this afternoon that the Club worked against several moderates, including Sen. Lincoln Chafee (R, R.I.), who won his primary but lost his general election in 2006. Chafee did not even vote for President Bush in 2004, but like Specter he received a great deal of money and help from the Republican Party in his primary.
Reps. Joe Schwarz (R, Mich.) and Wayne Gilchrest (R, Md.) are two moderate victims of the Club for Growth whom Specter mentioned today. They were not being sore losers, but rather acted in good faith when they lost their respective primaries to conservatives and then turned around and endorsed the Democratic nominee in the general election. (Note that when he lost to Specter in 2004, Pat Toomey endorsed him immediately.) Conservatives must be team players in the GOP, but if moderates behave differently, we blame the conservatives who challenge them for subsequent disunity and defeat.
What is funny is that without any action so far by the Club for Growth, social conservatives, or anyone else, Republican voters in Pennsylvania have been lining up to end Specter's career, as the polls demonstrate. That is why Specter does not want to be judged by them. It is the only reason he has left the party.
“switched from Democrat to Republican in 1965”
No he did not, he simply held a role that got him power and went back to his root and carrying the honest name of what he is.
The scam on the people of PA, like Bernie Madoff is finally over.
This is what happens when a party loses it foundational principles and sells out to win. We can all learn from this.
I didn’t know Specter had been a Democrat. What an opportunist! Anyone who defends his move back to the Dem party as anything other than political expediency is shilling for the Dems.
Excellent article and one that shows just how big tent conservatives really are, but what are Toomey’s chances with AS in as a Dem?
Why? We don't need spinless traitors like him any more. I hope his career takes a nose dive and he disappears into the infamy it deserves.
sw
The departure of Arlen Specter looks very bad for the GOP
Bull. The GOP is looking better without him. I wish the rest of the CINOs would take a hike as well.
How do we get term limits in place? I know the idiots in congress would never bring it up.
“This is what happens when a party loses it foundational principles and sells out to win. We can all learn from this.”
I award you “Post of the Day”!
LLS
Most politicians are. I wonder what they offered him? Cheap whores posses more honer than Specter.
..”Exactly five years ago, the national Republican Party swooped into Pennsylvania and saved him from certain defeat at the hands of Rep. Pat Toomey (R). Valuable presidential time was sacrificed on his behalf. Also sacrificed for Arlen Specter was the reputation of his conservative colleague, Rick Santorum (R), who never recovered. From that moment forward, he lost his core constituency, and was easily defeated two years later by a pro-life Democrat.”
The opportunist control freak, Mitch McConnell(RINO) gets the credit for that blunder.
An excellent and succinct article.
Contact the turd Lindsey Graham here: http://lgraham.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?FuseAction=contact.emailsenatorgraham
Use this as your address if you are not from SC
2125 Charlie Hall Blvd.
Charleston, SC 29414
Time to ex-Specter-ate!
I doubt he will win even as a Dem. He’s now 80 and the folks are ready for something NEW.
I wonder if he threatened Bush with a party switch in order to get Bush’s support last election?
I'm tired of Conservatives taking it in the chin all the time. We are like the dumb bastard who shows up to a gun fight with a knife. We will we learn that this is war.
Good riddance to one of the GOP’s problems. It already is in better standing and has a brighter future.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.