Posted on 04/15/2013 7:37:22 AM PDT by Hilda
Excerpt, first three paragraphs:
Anti-taping laws hurt democracy by shielding the powers that be from accountability, writes provocateur James
Break in, bribe, seduce and lie; anything to break through that palace guard and get the story, said investigative reporter Robert Scheer, according to a article by Abbie Hoffman in a decades-old edition of Mother Jones magazine. Sometimes Ive broken through the palace guards, and other times the palace guards have nearly broken me. What didnt jail me made me stronger and smarter. Ive become all too familiar with civil and criminal statutes that are bad for democracy because they insolate those vested in a public trust from democratic accountability.
Those embroiled in fraud rarely make unprovoked admissions of licentious behavior, which is precisely why covert tactics are effective in exposing the truth. Yet the problem lies in the consequences of applying Scheers rule. If I were on the left, pushing the legal limits of recordings by secretly taping meetings of the National Rifle Association, Id be a cause célèbre and win awards for journalistic excellence. Because my passion so far has been exposing government-funded sacred cows and disrupting statist narratives, I am an apostate. Therein the tragedy lies; a free press is supposed to defend the rights of journalists with whom they disagree. Its not just ignoble for the mainstream to ignore my First Amendment crises when theyve arisen; journalists who reflexively call for my prosecution put themselves outside their own values, assuming that support for the First Amendment is one of them. They must now confront these values head-on as surreptitious recordings spark a mainstream renaissance, opening the floodgates to a veritable constitutional crisis over privacy, consent, and the ability to protect anonymous whistleblowers.
Mother Jones magazines Washington bureau chief, David Corn, recently won a Polk journalism award after publishing a series of clandestine recordings. Writing later about how he came into possession of the tape, Corn noted that the recording raised a question of possible criminal prosecution in Florida, a two-party-consent state. His lawyers advised Scott Prouty (the bartender who captured then candidate Romneys now famous 47 percent comments), his anonymous source at the time, to shut up and keep your head low. This week, Corn stands to win another journalism award from Ithaca College for outstanding achievement in independent media, a week after a recording was released that captured a private conversation in Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnells Kentucky campaign office. Corns latest story could trigger felony eavesdropping charges. The FBI is investigating, and an official in the group Progress Kentucky has subsequently resigned, saying he does not condone any allegations of illegal activity that might have taken place. The murky nature of the Kentucky law makes it unclear whether its legal to record a barely audible conversation, according to NBC News. Sadly, rather than being viewed from the onset as a freedom-of-press issue, these debates split neatly down party lines, contingent upon whos being investigated.
Right. In a situation where ONE of the participants in a conversation has to know it is being recorded, the EAVESDROPPER doesn't have a card in the game.
Stand outside a lawyer's office or a private room in a court house and tape attorney-client conversations (or tape them off a cellphone call as the libs in Florida did) and you will be guilty of a crime.
The flip side is that they can’t invoke the same law against conservatives. Well, they can, and will, but if the left is asserting these laws are bogus, well, we might as well take advantage of the license.
I don't wonder though. I know the media is full of lying scumbags who misrepresent close to 100% of what goes to print. Not always intentionally, mind you, but the press is emphatically NOT a reflection of reality.
so what did James O’Keefe think about Nixon. Oh wait, he wasn’t born until ten years after. He still lives with his parents!
Basically, when you tell someone it’s no longer secret.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.