There are some people incompatible with American citizenship and if you can’t purge them from the country for some strange reason, at least try to prevent them from carrying out paradise-seeking massacres of other Americans. I really don’t think the Founders would have had much of a dilemma on their hands about this. They’ve conditioned us to become paralyzed by dilemmas.
All dilemmas happen by a false premise being accepted by someone.
The Founders did not have modern methods at hand.
Muslims who support Shariah law have decided that they want to overthrow the US government - so, no admission to such and deport those who do.
If they are the few liberal secular Muslims, like some Sufis and Almadhi, the Unitarians of the Muslim world, then they can stay if they recognize the right of others to disagree and not have to be oppressed for the privilege to not be Muslim.
Guess who's been told his rhetoric is "incompatible with our values and who we are as Americans?" Our presumptive nominee.
The DHS director said three days ago that "right wingers" are every bit as dangerous as muslim terrorists.
I really don’t think the Founders would have had much of a dilemma on their hands about this.
Well, in that case you don't know any history.
Go into the corner and read The Declaration of Independence and don't take the big pointy hat off until you understand that all of the things George III did, he did without due process, while denying his subjects the rights of Englishmen.
We are all outlaws in the eyes of America. If you don't understand that yet, you've been asleep for the last seven years.