Skip to comments.Being Shoved Into Meaninglessness
Posted on 11/17/2017 6:15:02 AM PST by Kaslin
I'm an advocate of higher education and all, but so much for assuming that the development of common sense and sound judgment are part of the package.
A Pew Research Center poll found that 77 percent of Democrats with a bachelor's degree or more believe a person's gender can be different from the sex they were "assigned at birth." You'll remember that Democrats are the party of science, and Republicans the Neanderthal science-deniers.
First we have to ask ourselves why in the world it would occur to anyone of any gender at any time or any place even to conduct such a survey. It would be like surveying people to find if they believe ears are for hearing or eyes for seeing.
It would be disturbing enough if only 77 percent of Democrats with this level of education thought gender is determined biologically. But 23 percent? That's a whole new level of weird -- unless you define "weird" as being outside the mainstream. What's weird is how weird the mainstream has become -- at least on the political left. This doesn't speak well for higher education in this country, does it? Then again, you wouldn't be surprised if you had seen the core curricula of America's "great" universities -- and many of the required reading assignments in the classes.
I watched an interesting video of a young conservative from a liberal family explaining why he could dialogue with liberals and still love them because we all share common goals. It is leftists, he said, who don't even share our goals anymore, and it is very difficult to find any common ground with them.
I thought to myself when watching the video, "Yes, we do share some of the same goals: less crime, less poverty, etc., but increasingly the mainstream Democratic Party is embracing or strongly enabling certain extremist ideas. There is just no denying that the party has lurched leftward."
Reading these poll results, sadly, tends to validate my concerns, which is not something I'm happy about. How can a significant percentage of people of any respected group, much less of the higher-educated subset of that group, be so wrongheaded? People urging bipartisanship should explain how we find common ground with such stunningly different worldviews.
I'm hoping this chasm is partially due to the phrasing of the survey questions or fear of political correctness policing -- but still, it's seriously problematic.
I don't doubt, by the way, that some very small fraction of a percentage of people sense they are trapped in their bodies and feel more like the opposite biological gender. I recently talked to such a person and am sure he was sincere. He has always felt like he should have been born a female. Note that he fully acknowledges, however, that he wasn't. He doesn't dispute the biological reality.
So I have no inclination to judge such people. If they feel opposite their biological gender, they do. It's above my pay-grade to fully understand this. But I think we're dealing with something more than this. Cultural activism is at work here.
Just look at the language the Pew survey uses to address these ideas: A human being's gender is "assigned at birth." You surely don't believe this language is accidental, do you?
To have an assignment there must be an assignor. If they mean God, or even nature, I'd have no quarrel, but it's clear they are talking about human agents (doctors or other health care providers) as assignors. This suggests some arbitrariness in the determination, or at least something that is subject to question.
It is not subject to question. Absent some biological aberration we are born either male or female, and no amount of linguistic manipulation can alter that reality, even though it obviously alters some people's perception of the reality.
Yes, there is certainly an agenda at work here; with the left everything is political. There is an effort to normalize that which is not normal, which introduces uncertainty into things certain. We have not evolved, but are being pushed headlong into moral relativism and further into post-modernism and beyond, where there is no such thing as truth and reality is just a function of the individual's preference.
This is moral chaos, intellectual chaos and biological chaos. It is nihilism. If truth is no longer defined as that which corresponds with reality, we have completely untethered ourselves from our foundations of meaning and significance. Parents with any remaining affinity for traditional values must surely be concerned about what we are bequeathing our children.
I'm not citing these ominous trends to score political points, and I acknowledge they are not solely the fault of just one political party, though they are disproportionately prevalent in that party. This is a societal and cultural problem that has polluted downstream political waters.
Indeed, these developments transcend politics. At the risk of subjecting myself to anti-Christian scoffing, I believe we are in the throes of spiritual warfare, which is one reason I'm not attempting to unduly demonize people falling prey to it. I used not to believe in the devil, but that was then, and this is now. I have no other rational explanation for morality and truth routinely being turned on their very heads -- for right being considered wrong, and unreality masquerading as reality. Satan is the first and great deceiver, and many people, most of them unwittingly, are being deceived.
Pray for America. Pray for mankind.
Agreed. I look around and I just do not see a bunch of people with free will occasionally "getting it wrong" when they make their choices.
I see the devil hard at work almost everywhere. Evil is on the march.
Yes, we do share some of the same goals: less crime, less poverty, etc.,
DOes Rush know his brother is hitting the pipe Hard nowadays??
The Democrat Party has NEVER wanted less crime or Poverty, they have spent the last 50 years Increasing Poverty and Crime so they could become their daddy’s and secure their votes.
That humans don't fit into this same scenario takes nearly two decades to (un)learn. These two decades of (un)learning include 13 years in K-12, and 4+ years beyond that of liberal brainwashing. Now the liberals want to expand even that with the brainwashing to start several years before the K.
The uneducated “learned” Democrats who think gender is not biologically determined MUST apparently believe that the gene coding in every nucleus of every cell in the body, expressed as either XX or XY, has no gender specific expression throughout the body at all and has no impact on physical characteristics, and reproductive organs, chemistry such as hormones & their production & distribution and not even in the structures of the brain. And that NONE of that is supposed to have any role on the “mind”.
Why do they follow that absurdity?
They cannot admit, for political reasons, that some “choices” are bad choices made for reasons of mental issues, such, in the case of “transgenders” the mental issue of an identity dysphoria manifest in an obsession that convinces the person that the truth of their body is a lie. All the while it is the obsession that is a lie.
Yes, the transgender person deserves compassion for their obsession can be as bad as the worst possible addiction and can inflict a large decree of emotional conflict when fighting the obsession - just as withdrawal is hard for the addict. But the compassion for the “transgender” person should not be in supporting the lie the obsession tells, but in large doses of strong, compassionate professional help to destroy the obsession and it’s lie.
Yep, your sex orientation is 100% hardwired.
Its not ignorance or even stupidity here but pure old fashioned FEAR of the mob. As with most totalitarian mobs, to vary from the party line collective is to court trouble. I recall a story on brainwashing in Soviet Union where the interrogator would hold up a red card to the prisoner and demand it be called green the purpose not being the truth, but submission. The purpose is the prisoner must obediently declare as TRUE what they know is FALSE or face punishment. The PeeCee Fascists dont care if anyone really believes theres a gazillion genders or any other lie they promote just that ALL obediently declared it fact. Then you are broken and under their control! Also... such PeeCee “truth” is always subject to change... so you may be forced to proclaim the exact opposite of what was “truth” yesterday... today, without questioning! Such is brainwashing! Totalitarian control is to never allow anyone to relax... always under siege! Orwell knew it well!
Addendum: Prime Directive: to be a “good” (misnamed) “progressive” you must often proclaim as TRUE what you know is FALSE.
At conception, not at birth. Are they really teaching children that doctors and nurses assign sex in the hospital?
What, do they see what the world needs more of, male or female and the assignment is made? What about the Chinese, are they assigned that way? Cuz they have way too many males in their populations.
Parents should mount a class action law suit, not only on this subject but the entire school education system. The bottom line problem with our education system is the parents, not demanding excellence and suing!
It's very Orwellian.
What a Paradox
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.