Posted on 04/15/2024 11:43:42 AM PDT by Red Badger
"Rust" armorer Hannah Gutierrez was given the maximum sentence of 18 months in prison for involuntary manslaughter in the 2021 fatal shooting of cinematographer Halyna Hutchins.
Gutierrez's attorneys asked for probation in a sentencing memorandum filed last week, citing her "complete lack of prior criminal history" and "relative youth." Prosecutors meanwhile requested a sentence of 18 months with the designation of serious violent offender due to her "extreme recklessness" while working as an armorer on the "Rust" set in New Mexico.
"You alone turned a safe weapon into a lethal weapon," Judge Mary Marlowe Sommer said.
Gutierrez said to the court, "My heart aches for the Hutchins family and friends and colleagues, as well."
"Your honor, when I took on 'Rust' I was young and I was naive. But I took my job as seriously as I knew how to, despite not having proper time, resources and staffing, I just did my best to handle it," she said. "Today I humbly ask you to consider probation. ... I beg you, please don't give me more time."
Hannah Gutierrez-Reed, the former armorer at the movie "Rust," listens to closing arguments in her trial at district court, Wednesday, March 6, 2024, in Santa Fe, N.M. Hannah Gutierrez-Reed, the former armorer at the movie "Rust," listens to closing arguments in her trial at district court, Wednesday, March 6, 2024, in Santa Fe, N.M. Luis Sánchez Saturno/Santa Fe New Mexican via AP, Pool, File Gutierrez, dressed in tan jail clothes, watched on as Hutchins' friends addressed the court before the sentence was imposed.
Hutchins' friend Jen White told the court, "I still look for her. I still expect to see her. I still wonder what adventures she's on ... then my heart drops through my feet."
"Halyna was a force," White said.
"She inspired me. And I don't think she knew that because I never got to tell her. She was one of my favorite people in the world," White said, as Gutierrez wiped away tears.
White said if Gutierrez "had properly done her job, Halyna would still be alive."
"I beg you to impose the maximum sentence," White said to the judge. "She needs to be held accountable."
"If prison time is the only way she will face any responsibility ... it should be for as long as the law allows," White said.
Director Joel Souza, who was injured in the shooting that killed Hutchins, told the judge that Hutchins "had a talent for life."
Director of photography Halyna Hutchins was killed and director Joel Souza was injured on set while filming the movie "Rust" in Santa Fe, N.M., on Oct. 21, 2021. "She was a touchstone for all who knew her. And those of us who were lucky enough to have shared in her fleeting time on this planet are better for it," he said.
Hutchins' close friend and film school classmate, Emilia Mendieta, told the judge, "Someone didn't do their job right -- a lot of someones."
"Why was a live bullet on set?" Mendieta said. "It was her job to check the guns, check the bullets and make sure that the set was safe."
"What I want is change and justice," she said. "I want those that had a hand in her death ... to face the consequences."
Hutchins' father said in a statement read in court on his behalf, "Each person responsible ... needs to carry the punishment that is equal to their guilt. Maybe, just maybe, this might prevent the same type of tragedies in the future to others, and spare other parents from such a heart-wrenching catastrophe."
The Santa Fe County jury deliberated for under three hours on March 6 before reaching a split verdict. They found her guilty of involuntary manslaughter but acquitted her of tampering with evidence in the case.
Prosecutors told jurors that Gutierrez "repeatedly" failed to maintain proper firearm safety and that her negligence led to the death of Hutchins, who was shot by actor Alec Baldwin, while the defense countered that the 26-year-old is a "convenient scapegoat" during closing arguments in the trial.
Gutierrez was remanded into custody following the verdict.
Defense attorneys filed an emergency motion for a new trial and release last month, arguing that the jury instructions could lead to a non-unanimous verdict. The judge denied the motion.
In their sentencing memorandum, her attorneys argued that Gutierrez "has endured and will continue to endure collateral consequences far harsher than most defendants ever must face."
"This conviction and press deluge will forever impact her life going forward, including with job prospects, and simply trying to lead a 'normal' life again someday," her attorneys wrote.
Gutierrez feels "incredibly saddened and heartbroken by what happened on that tragic day" on the "Rust" set, they wrote.
Her attorneys asked for a conditional discharge, wherein the court would place her on probation without entering an adjudication of guilt. The defense argued conditional discharge would be "adequate to punish the offense, but not more serious than necessary to serve the underlying sentencing goals."
In a response filed last week, prosecutors said they opposed a conditional discharge due to Gutierrez's "complete and total failure to accept responsibility for her actions." They argued that her jail calls since being incarcerated demonstrated that she "continues to deny responsibility and blame others." They said the calls also showed she has complained about the negative effects of the incident "while never expressing genuine remorse at any time."
"Stunningly, Ms. Gutierrez requested during jail calls that her legal team request that Ms. Hutchins' husband and son be contacted and asked to speak on her behalf at her sentencing," prosecutors wrote.
Prosecutors further noted that while she is eligible for a conditional discharge, she still faces another felony charge for allegedly hiding a firearm from security at a local bar.
The state asked that Gutierrez be sentenced to 18 months with a designation of serious violent offender due to her recklessness, or five years probation if the court found that a suspended or deferred sentence was appropriate.
Baldwin was practicing a cross-draw in a church on the set of the Western film on Oct. 21, 2021, when the Colt .45 revolver fired a live round, striking Hutchins and Souza.
During the two-week trial, prosecutors presented evidence they said showed Gutierrez was responsible for bringing six live rounds onto the set -- and did not discover them for 12 days before the deadly shooting by failing to perform industry-standard safety practices.
"This is not a case where Hannah Gutierrez made one mistake, and that one mistake was accidental -- putting a live round into that gun," prosecutor Kari Morrissey told jurors during her closing argument. "This case is about constant, neverending, safety failures that resulted in the death of a human being and nearly killed another."
Morrissey told jurors Gutierrez failed to maintain firearms safety on the set, "making a fatal accident willful and foreseeable."
She showed jurors stills of footage from the set of actors pointing firearms at other crew members, including a minor actor, as well as Gutierrez pointing one at her own face. She also showed photographs of what experts determined to be live rounds in holsters and containers on the set as early as Oct. 10, 2021.
Morrissey said that meant Gutierrez was not checking dummy rounds to ensure they were not live rounds -- such as by shaking them -- and that there was a game of "Russian roulette" every time an actor had a gun loaded with dummies. She also said they have "mountains of circumstantial evidence" that Gutierrez brought the live rounds onto the set.
"I'm not telling you Hannah Gutierrez intended to bring live rounds on set," Morrissey said. "I'm saying she was negligent, she was careless, she was thoughtless."
Hutchins died from loss of blood and a lethal wound to her lung, Morrissey said.
"The astonishing lack of diligence with regard to gun safety is without question a significant cause of the death of Halyna Hutchins," she said.
Defense attorney Jason Bowles said during his closing argument there was a rush to judgment and that detectives didn't conduct a thorough investigation of the shooting. Gutierrez was made a "convenient fall person," he said.
He also argued that the New Mexico Occupational Safety and Health Administration's investigation into the shooting found that the management "demonstrated plain indifference to employee safety" and was responsible for the safety on the set.
Gutierrez had additionally been charged with tampering with evidence, with prosecutors alleging she handed off a small bag of cocaine at her hotel on the day of the shooting after her interview with law enforcement. The jury found her not guilty.
Gutierrez did not testify in her own defense.
Baldwin has also been charged with involuntary manslaughter in Hutchins' death. His trial is scheduled to start in July.
His attorneys last month filed a motion to dismiss the charge, accusing prosecutors of "unethical disparagement" of the actor and "violating nearly every rule in the book" to secure a grand jury indictment.
In a response to the motion filed earlier this month, prosecutors claimed Baldwin missed concerns about Gutierrez and "compromised safety" on the set by demanding the crew and armorer work faster.
"The combination of Hannah Gutierrez's negligence and inexperience and Alec Baldwin's complete lack of concern for the safety of those around him would prove deadly for Halyna Hutchins," prosecutors stated.
Marlowe Sommer has yet to rule on the motion to dismiss the charge.
ROFLOL!!
indeed.
the point: any highly developed industry is a) highly regulated and b) has highly developed risk mitigation protocols.
ffs. we’re talking about a loaded gun “accidentally” being passed to an actor who’s going to pull the trigger.
let’s put on our thinking caps.
(and “relative youth.”)
🙄🙄🙄
They didn’t try “teen”?
It’s used all of the time
(Why were there live bullets on the premises at all?)
Because they were doing live shooting for fun, off duty.
Using a movie prop for live shooting is terribly irresponsible. It definitely had the potential to go bad.
(Not for phone calls from your cell.)
Very true.
Yeah you see such on Forensic Files
I heard that he shooting a new movie and the crew. I can hear the director now,
“Lights. Camera, It’s Alec Baldwin. DUCK!”
Her lawyer shouldn’t have told her not to say much on the jail phone.
Yeah
Alec Baldwin should at least get 18 months as he shot 2 people and killing one. It has been reported he would point the weapon at anyone randomly prior.
It is a Wild West action movie....really boring if the actors always point their guns in a safe direction and don’t pull the trigger! ;-)
The armourer (Gutierrez) should have gotten a few years (perhaps 3) and Baldwin since he was apparently messing around between takes should probably get the 18 months. The “bottom line/buck stops here” responsibility was with the armourer to make sure all guns on the set/area were loaded with blanks with no live ammo around. i.e. she has possession of all the guns on set and hands them to the actors right before the scene is “filmed”/recorded after triple-checking them for blanks. Then takes back possession of the guns after the scene is done.
He should get 18 years.......................
You miss the point entirely. Baldwin was not “filming” when the incident took place. It was, as you say, in between takes, and Baldwin was goofing around with a gun.
Yeah, but goofing around with a gun that should have been checked/cleared by the armourer. That same gun during the filming of a scene would have killed an actor instead of the cinematographer. Don’t trust the goofy actor to to do a weapon check/be weapon competent...he has pointed & pulled the trigger on prop weapons 100’s of times during film shoots...he is going to “assume blanks” 100% of the time.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.