Indeed.
Posted on 03/17/2014 9:08:13 PM PDT by Swordmaker
Apple's design chief helped transform computing, phones and music. The company's secrecy and Ive's modesty mean he has never given an in-depth interview—until now.
'Hello. Thanks for Coming'
We use Jonathan Ive’s products to help us to eat, drink and sleep, to work, travel, relax, read, listen and watch, to shop, chat, date and have sex. Many of us spend more time with his screens than with our families. Some of us like his screens more than our families. For years, Ive’s natural shyness, coupled with the secrecy bordering on paranoia of his employer, Apple, has meant we have known little about the man who shapes the future, with such innovations as the iMac, the iPod, the iPhone and the iPad. But last month, he invited me to Cupertino in Silicon Valley where Apple is based, for his first in-depth interview since he became head of design almost 20 years ago.
The gods — or was it the ghost of Steve Jobs? — seemed against it. Jobs didn’t like Apple execs doing interviews. It had not rained properly in California for months but that morning the clouds rolled off the Pacific, turning the Golden Gate Bridge black. Interstate 280 South to Silicon Valley was a river of water, instead of the usual lava streaks of stop-start SUVs. But just after 10AM, an Apple tech-head appeared in an all-white meeting room on the first floor of building 4 of the firm’s antiseptic headquarters with strict instructions to find an Earl Grey tea bag.
(Excerpt) Read more at time.com ...
Why even read what he writes?
Why expect a troll to cease being a troll in the face of facts?
In all likelihood, he lives not under a bridge, but under the stairs to his mom & dad’s basement.
Not worth your time.
Thanks Swordmaker!
Well, Lentard is known for being fairly “Tardy” not of “late” but, lately as always .
Is using the word “Tardy” uncooth when speaking of the mentally challenged?
Maybe he’s not really sentient so much as a simian . One could draw that conclussion from the monkeying around he does.
I dunno, maybe he’s apeing one of them bobble heads commonly seen on one of those cheap chop job low riding el caminos.
Maybe he’s a klown. “Well, Homey don’t play dat game” and besides, I don’t think he’s ever going to grow into big boy shoes. That’s Bob’s Big Boy shoes.
Lentard shouldn’t take any offense at my commentary or observation. I merely point out that which most discern but, few would remark on, for it is beneath their dignity and the knowledge you exist an insult to the mind.
Not that I mind. You got no mind but, mind you, it is nothing
Be off with your dirty self.
Indeed.
Please feel free to post all those computer manufacturers name that are Conservative friendly. That list will consist of Zero names.
With an iPhone you have access on your 8 gig phone, to every tune you own, and you should know that.
Yet you take time to be involved in something that makes you look like a person totally ignorant of a piece of technology.
Sort of like radio, cool.
Give us a list of those things, maybe a real expert will give you a hand.
That would be terrific if I lived in a city or suburb with robust coverage. I don’t. I live in the mountains and I have a 60 mile daily commute through the desert.
I require storage. I got the wrong phone. That’s since been fixed. I got a BlackBerry Z30. 80gb, nice big screen, great OS. Everything I need. I’m good.
that might be true but they all don’t go out of their way to offend conservative customers or tell them to eff off.
What is amazing - there was a day with the owner of this board would have thumped such trolls between the eyes. Indeed - just a few years ago, Jim Robinson issued an edict for these trolls to cease or be banned...
But alas, I am not sure he has or exercises much control here any more - and several moderators (it isn’t just Apple-related threads) run rough-shod as well.
Well, I’m still pretty damned good at zotting real trolls as opposed to disagreeable boogeymen. Let me know when you spot one.
“For those who don’t know, there was just ONE suicide associated with Apple at a Foxconn/HonHai plant. That occurred in July 2009 when Sun Danyong, 25, jumped to his death after being interrogated over a missing iPhone prototype...This factory/city manufactures HP computers, Microsoft X-Boxes, Nokia phones, and Sony PlayStations - and NO APPLE PRODUCTS.” Chief Inspector Jacques Clouswordmaker from http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/chat/3134377/posts?page=260#260
According to Jacques, ONE suicide in July of 2009 elicited this response from Steve Jobs in June of 2010.
“...they’ve had, if you count the attempted suicides, 13 so far this year. And while that is still...they have four hundred thousand people in this place, so 13 out of four hundred thousand is 26 per year, so far, for four hundred thousand people or you know lets say 7 per hundred thousand people. That’s still under the US suicide rate of 11 per hundred thousand people but it’s really troubling.”
Full-length interview of Apple CEO Steve Jobs at the D8 conference with Walt Mossberg and Kara Swisher, June 7, 2010 (Steve Jobs asked about Foxconn by Kara Swisher at 19:06)
http://live.wsj.com/video/allthingd/70F7CC1D-FFBF-4BE0-BFF1-08C300E31E11.html
ONE suicide, ONE YEAR LATER has Steve Jobs claiming that there were THIRTEEN suicides in the FIRST SIX MONTHS of the FOLLOWING YEAR.
Do you realize how SELF-INCRIMINATING that is? This guy had some of the most ruthless lawyers in the world working for him. Do you think that he wasn’t intelligent enough to keep his mouth shut? You do not incriminate yourself, in public, if this had nothing to do with Apple products. Your lawyer wouldn’t even want you to cop to the ONE suicide from a year ago! Did Steve Jobs incriminate HP, or Microsoft, or Nokia, or Sony? No, he incriminated Apple. Why?
You failed to post a link to, well...anything, because your fake facts don’t add up. Steve Jobs didn’t even subscribe to your interpretation, why would anyone else?
Apple Lexicon
Enthuastic Self Incrimination: Apple’s strategy to baffle ‘em with bullfish.
from The Apple Lexicon (™) Interpreting Apple Theology Since 1994
Well, Leonard has expended lots of gaseous hot air trying to convince everyone that somehow Apple builds, owns, and operates factories in China in which an extraordinary number of worker suicides have occurred over an extremely short time. He has claimed that I have lied about the facts of this, that my statements Apple does not "build, own, or operate" these factories are false, and he claims that Steve Jobs own statements prove I am wrong. When asked about the suicides at the Hon Hai company's FoxConn Manufacturing facilities, Mr. jobs referred to the events at "their facilities" and said "they had." At no time did Steve Jobs ever refer to the problems at FoxConn as "our" or said "we are doing x" to solve the issue. Steve Jobs did not claim FoxConn's problems as Apple's problems, but they were often portrayed that way in the press. . . and then exaggerated to boot.
In fact, at the time of the suicides, Apple accounted for approximately 15% of Hon Hai's worldwide contracts. . . Assembling some of Apple's products including the iPhone4S and the new iPad.
Leonard claims I don't know what I'm talking about and my facts are not true. He's ignored the links I've provided, or claims I never provide links ignoring the hundreds or thousands of articles I've posted (and linked) to the Apple/Mac/iOS/iPhone PING list in the past ten years. . . with those very facts. Here are some more that shoot down Leonard's idiotic assertions. Note that these articles do not say that it's Apple that builds these competitor products for the other customers of Hon Hai/FoxConn. . . As Leonard would have everyone absurdly believe. *************************
Man who doesn't work for Foxconn kills self. Apple's fault?
By Philip Elmer-DeWitt May 20, 2013: 12:37 PM ET — CNN Fortune
A suicide story that broke on Saturday had fallen apart by Monday.
Anti-suicide nets on a Foxconn factory. Photo: Reuters/Jason Lee.
FORTUNE -- The Agence France Press headline that moved over the business wires Saturday morning seemed like deja vu all over again:
Three new factory suicides at Apple supplier Foxconn
Citing only a statement issued by China Labor Watch in New York, the news agency reported that the deaths occurred at a Foxconn factory in the central city of Zhengzhou and included a 30-year-old married man who died on May 14, a 23-year-old woman (April 27) and a 24-year-old man (April 24).
Although Apple (AAPL) was named in the headline, it wasn't until the fifth paragraph that AFP mentioned that Foxconn also assembles products for Sony (SNE) and Nokia (NOK).
The piece might also have named Amazon (AMZN), Google (GOOG), HP (HPQ), Dell (DELL), Nintendo and Microsoft (MSFT), among others. But it didn't.
And it wasn't until two days later, when the Wall Street Journal reported Foxconn's version of events, that we learned that two of the suicides occurred outside the company's property and were not, according to Foxconn, work-related.
As for the third victim -- the 24-year-old man who died on April 24 -- he didn't work for the company at all. He had, however, applied for a job at Foxconn. As if that makes a difference.
Although the Journal is to be commended for following up, we note that as far as it's concerned, Apple is the only company that matters -- or at least the only one worth mentioning -- when bad things happen in a Foxconn factory town.
As Macworld's Michael Kan once put it: "Foxconn builds products for many vendors, but its mud sticks to Apple."
*************************
NICHOLAS CARLSON
MAY 26, 2010, 9:58 AM — Business Insider
After 9 suicides in 5 months, and reports of brutal working conditions, Apple and Dell say they are investigating the working conditions at Foxconn, the Chinese manufacturer that builds iPads, iPhones and other gadgets.
But while it's obviously a tragedy that any one person, let alone 9, ever commits suicide, let's be clear about one thing: the suicide rate at Foxconn is not particularly high.
In fact, at 5.4 suicides per 100,000 people (400,000 people work at Foxconn), the Foxconn suicide rate is lower than it is in all 50 U.S. states.
In Wyoming, where the population is 512,757, and there are no sweatshops, 22.6 people per 100,000 commit suicide, according to the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention.
In California, the rate is 9.2 – New York, 6.9.
We are not suggesting that working conditions at Foxconn are good. We've seen too much evidence that they are horrible to say that.
It's just that these suicides are not such evidence. If anything, considering these working conditions, it is remarkable the rate of suicide at Foxconn is so low.
Here's Apple's statement on the matter, via Philip Elmer-DeWitt:
"We are saddened and upset by the recent suicides at Foxconn. Apple is deeply committed to ensuring that conditions throughout our supply chain are safe and workers are treated with respect and dignity. We are in direct contact with Foxconn senior management and we believe they are taking this matter very seriously."
Foxconn is putting up nets around its facility to catch anyone that jumps. It's also asking employees to sign a pledge that they will not kill themselves.
Foxconn manufactures iPhones and iPads, as well as assorted Dell products.
*************************
If Foxconn sneezes, does that mean Apple caught a cold?
By Philip Elmer-DeWitt May 28, 2013: 3:45 PM ET— CNN Fortune
The world's largest electronics manufacturer does have other clients.
Source: Asymco.com.
FORTUNE -- If something sounded familiar about Lorraine Luk's headline in Tuesday's Wall Street Journal -- As Apple Feels Bite, Hon Hai Looks to Diversify -- it may be because we've heard that tune a lot lately.
Just in the past three weeks, journalists have attributed to Apple's (AAPL) loss of "steam" everything from Harvard's divestiture of a few hundred Apple shares to the structure of Sharp's survival plan. (See The business wires' new verbal tic.)
To be sure, one can legitimately write that Apple has had an unusually long stretch without a product launch. Or that its profit margins have pulled back quite a bit from their historic highs. Or that its earnings fell year over year last quarter for the first time since 2003, and are likely to do it again this quarter.
But Apple's all-important iOS shipments, as the chart above shows, are still growing nicely.
So to interpret this quote from an unnamed Hon Hai executive ...
"As our production capacity has grown to such a large scale and existing major-brand customers offer limited order growth, we need to actively expand our client base to help increase our manufacturing volume."
... as referring specifically to Apple -- as Luk did in Monday's Journal -- is to ignore the fact that Hon Hai, better known as Foxconn, has other major-brand clients, and that most of them are hurting.
Take Hewlett-Packard (HPQ) and Dell (DELL), two Window's PC vendors that subcontract their assembly work to Foxconn. How's that business doing? See chart below:
Source: IDC
What about Nintendo, Sony (SNE) and Microsoft (MSFT)? Their game consoles are also assembled in Foxconn's factories:
To see this chart, visit the source article.
Source: MRG Inc.
How about Amazon's (AMZN) Kindle readers? Foxconn builds those things too:
Source: Chitika March Tablet Report
I suspect most of Foxconn's other clients would happy to switch places with a company whose sales can produce a growth chart like the one at the top of this page. So if Foxconn is feeling "pain" -- as Luk writes in her lead paragraph -- perhaps a little more reporting would turn up better reasons than the "competition ... biting into Apple's market share."
Posted in: Amazon, Apple, Dell, Foxconn, Hon Hai, HP, Microsoft, Nintendo
FoxConn's Saga: What Analysts Are Saying
By Mark LaPedus 6/15/2010 06:00 PM EDT
SAN JOSE, Calif. -- Lately, it's been a tumultuous period for Taiwan's Hon Hai Precision Industry Co. Ltd. Hon Hai, the world's largest contract electronics manufacturer (CEM), trades as Foxconn and makes electronic products for such brands as Apple, Dell, Hewlett-Packard and Sony.
As reported, Foxconn International Holdings Ltd. (FIH) recently announced it will more than double the salaries of employees at its factory in Shenzhen, China within months in response to a global outcry over recent worker suicides at the site.
Now, there are unconfirmed reports that FIH may re-locate some operations in Shenzhen to lower cost regions in China. Here's what analysts are saying about Foxconn's troubles:
Impact of salary hikes for Foxconn
Jamie Wang, an analyst with Gartner, said: ''This wage hike may increase Foxconn's operational costs and affect its profitability, but the company cannot afford further tragic suicides, and this action will improve relations with its workers in China and help to deflect potential negativity from its outsourcing clients.
''For now, Foxconn needs to concentrate on handling recent events sensitively, which will affect its cost competitiveness in the short term. However, a continuous focus on improving quality and productivity will be recognized by Foxconn's OEM customers over the long term.''
HSBC analysts Yolanda Wang and Joyce Chen said: ''Following the June 2 announcement that FIH was raising pay for its production workers by 30 percent (from RMB900 to RMB1200) effective June 1, the company announced further significant pay hikes of 67 percent (from RMB1200 to RMB2000) on June 7 for production line workers based in Shenzhen, China (effective October 1).
''In the meantime, the company is reviewing potential pay hikes for workers in other areas of China. We estimate the latest 67 percent salary and wage increases could impact FIH’s operating profit by another 66 percent.''
HSBC analysts Wanli Wang and Carrie Liu, said: ''We cut 2010/11 EPS estimates by 5 percent and 11 percent, respectively, (for FIH) to reflect the further labor cost increase. We forecast 2010 sales will rise 32 percent year-over-year. LCD TV, Apple iPad and 4G iPhone, and (notebooks) are the growth drivers. Desktop PCs and servers are likely to benefit from replacement demand. The risk to our forecasts is rising component prices.
Hon Hai (FoxConn) produces more than 50 percent of global desktop PCs.
The company should be a major beneficiary of the corporate replacement cycle. Hon Hai is the key assembler for Apple iPhone 4G. iPhone will contribute about 15 percent of Hon Hai's total sales in 2010.
Moreover, iPad continues to see strong demand globally. We believe 2H10 unit shipments will grow more than 50 percent vs 1H10. Hon Hai will ship only 2 million LCD TV units in 1H10. The other 4 million units will kick in during 2H10, with new orders mainly from Sony.''
Impact on supply chain
HSBC analysts Yolanda Wang and Joyce Chen said: ''FIH’s pay increase could have an impact on the entire manufacturing supply chain, which shares a similar labour pool, especially in the Shenzhen area.''
HSBC analysts Wanli Wang and Carrie Liu, said: ''The salary increase is a structural issue; we expect it to extend to other manufacturing companies in China. In addition to Hon Hai, Honda and TPV also recently announced plans to raise employee base salaries by 20 percent in China.''
The fallout for Foxconn
Jamie Wang, an analyst with Gartner, said: ''Recent staff suicides and attempted suicides at Foxconn facilities are reported to be related to working conditions, and from a marketing perspective, they have had a very negative impact on the company's standing. A consumer or public outcry could force some major brand owners to move their manufacturing away from Foxconn because of these tragedies, on the grounds of 'nonethical manufacturing.'
Foxconn is considered as one of the better partners, providing lower production costs, fast delivery, reliable-quality goods and very high volume capacity. Its business partners will expect the turmoil to eventually subside, and most of them may choose to stay with Foxconn. Nevertheless, OEM clients may use more electronics manufacturing service (EMS)/original design manufacturer (ODM) suppliers to split the production loads, as Foxconn reduces the working hours of its labor force.''
The fallout in China
Jamie Wang, an analyst with Gartner, said: ''Foxconn's suicide tragedies can act as a warning and a lesson to all manufacturers with huge labor forces in China, as they may encounter similar difficulty if they engage in comparable practices.
''Labor management in China is getting increasingly difficult, and all OEM/EMS/ODM companies should take the matter seriously. A shortage of workers in China means that there is a higher likelihood of more unreliable young workers and susceptible recruits being employed in the industry -- all of which pose a significant risk to companies.''
*************************
For those who still insist, like Leonard, that Apple plays games with their taxes, here is a transcript of Apple's CEO Tim Cook's sworn testimony before the US Senate from May 12, 2013:
Apple's CEO senate testimony Transcript PDF.
***********************
There are dozens of other articles and papers I've read on this subject. . . I'm not going to post more. These are sufficient to do the job.
You just claimed that you were right and Steve Jobs was wrong and then spammed your own thread with nothing that I haven’t already covered and will be covering more extensively in the coming months. Glad to see that you learned to copy and past links however.
“Steve Jobs did not claim FoxConn’s problems as Apple’s problems, but they were often portrayed that way in the press. . . and then exaggerated to boot.” Chief Inspector Jacques Clouswordmaker
They were portrayed by Steve Jobs that way. He said twice in that interview...oh, you’re on an iPad, well when you can get on a Mac check out the actual video of the actual CEO of Apple at the time and notice that twice he says, we are on this. He was on it on behalf of Microsoft? HP? Sony?
Steve Jobs is telling you that they, Apple, were on these 13 suicides in 6 months. (His number.) This odd cluster that prompted the erection of suicide nets around the entire campus.
He started his response with, “Oh sure, we’re pretty on the top of that.” We, meaning collectively? All the computer companies in the world? Or we meaning US, all the people of the world?
He repeated it just for you as he was about to explain those suicides, “So I can tell you a few things that we know. And we’re all over this.”
Dance around that all you want, it’s never going to change unless you can get the Wall Street Journal to pull that video.
Hey, since you’ve figured out how to paste, could you send the names of those conservative board members. It’s been several weeks.
Hey, Sparky, by the way, I AM awed by your ability to lie so massively about what others have actually said and your ability to get people to follow your commands. It is truly awe inspiring. You do it better than anyone I’ve ever seen at FR.
When I first saw that 4 years ago I was actually surprised that at the snap of your fingers you could summon others to do your bidding. Gotta hand it to you. You even sucked me in once.
Just once.
He accuses me of disagreeing with Steve Jobs, but he cannot comprehend that Steve Jobs is talking about "being on top" of a PR problem that WAS impacting Apple, because the press was reporting that it was an Apple problem. . . however, if you KNOW anything about the relationship between Apple and FoxConn, you know it is one of a very influential CUSTOMER and a supplier, not an owner to a subsidiary.
Apple, as did HP, sent an investigation commission to learn what was happening at the company that supplied a good deal of Apple's products. Apple also requested two independent, International labor organizations to investigate. . . Those are what is called in business, performing "due diligence:" finding out what is happening with a strategic partner. In other words, for those who a comprehension challenged, "being on top of a potential developing problem." Facts.
Apple, H-P to Examine Asian Supplier After String of Deaths at Factory
By JASON DEAN in Beijing and TING-I TSAI in Taipei
Updated May 27, 2010 12:01 a.m. ET
Amid a furor over suicides at a major supplier, Apple Inc., AAPL -0.42% Hewlett-Packard Co. AAPL -0.42% and other electronics companies said they are examining conditions at the Chinese factory and how the supplier has responded to the spate of workers' deaths.
The suicides at Hon Hai Precision Industry Co., which assembles iPads for Apple, computers for H-P and cellphones for Nokia Corp. NOK -0.82% , have put unprecedented scrutiny on the secretive company and have highlighted the changing nature of China's work force.
The tech companies' promises to investigate came before another Hon Hai worker died Wednesday in what police said was a suicide, and as the company's hard-charging chairman, Terry Gou, moved to contain the fallout.
Wednesday's incident, reported by state-run Xinhua news agency, marks the 10th time an employee at Hon Hai's sprawling Longhua complex in the southern city of Shenzhen has jumped to his or her death this year, most since April, with two more injured in failed attempts.
Given China's overall suicide rate—about 14 per 100,000 people—the deaths aren't statistically exceptional, but the quick succession is unusual.
Earlier Wednesday, the company gave a group of journalists a tour of Longhua, a walled-off complex with guarded gates and about 400,000 workers, and announced plans to outfit worker dormitories with safety nets to prevent more workers from jumping to their deaths.
"These last two months, I've been afraid to answer the phone late at night or early in the morning, because we've been unable to prevent these incidents from happening," the 59-year-old Mr. Gou told reporters at Longhua, which has dozens of factory buildings and worker dormitories. He expressed "regret" over the incidents, but defended Hon Hai's response. "We need time. But we have confidence and strong determination" to address the problem, he said.
The statements Wednesday from Apple, H-P and others were the first public comment on the suicides by customers of Hon Hai, which also goes by the trade name Foxconn. The Taiwan-based company, which employs some 820,000 workers throughout China, is the world's largest electronics contract manufacturer by revenue.
"We are saddened and upset by the recent suicides at Foxconn," Apple said, adding it had assigned a team to evaluate Hon Hai's efforts to address the suicides. Apple said it's in contact with Hon Hai management and "we believe they are taking this matter very seriously."
H-P, the world's biggest PC maker, said it "is investigating the Foxconn practices that may be associated with these tragic events." Nokia said "we have contacted Foxconn to ensure any issues are identified and addressed."
Dell Inc. said, "any reports of poor working conditions in Dell's supply chain are investigated and, if warranted, appropriate action is taken." Other Hon Hai customers, including Motorola Inc. and Nintendo Co., made similar statements.
Read more at the source. . .
As Steve Jobs said, "We", the FoxConn customers, including Apple, in fact most importantly Apple, from the BOARD OF DIRECTORS viewpoint, using the Royal and Corporate We, speaking for the board "are on top of it." That does not mean from an OWNERSHIP perspective. . . but from an interested party view. And, I repeat, Steve Jobs referred to "their" FoxConn's suicide problem, not "our" Apple's suicide problem.
“For those who don’t know, there was just ONE suicide associated with Apple at a Foxconn/HonHai plant. That occurred in July 2009 when Sun Danyong, 25, jumped to his death after being interrogated over a missing iPhone prototype...This factory/city manufactures HP computers, Microsoft X-Boxes, Nokia phones, and Sony PlayStations - and NO APPLE PRODUCTS.” Chief Inspector Jacques Clouswordmaker from http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/chat/3134377/posts?page=260#260
According to Jacques, ONE suicide in July of 2009 elicited this response from Steve Jobs in June of 2010.
“...they’ve had, if you count the attempted suicides, 13 so far this year. And while that is still...they have four hundred thousand people in this place, so 13 out of four hundred thousand is 26 per year, so far, for four hundred thousand people or you know lets say 7 per hundred thousand people. That’s still under the US suicide rate of 11 per hundred thousand people but it’s really troubling.”
Full-length interview of Apple CEO Steve Jobs at the D8 conference with Walt Mossberg and Kara Swisher, June 7, 2010 (Steve Jobs asked about Foxconn by Kara Swisher at 19:06)
http://live.wsj.com/video/allthingd/70F7CC1D-FFBF-4BE0-BFF1-08C300E31E11.html
ONE suicide, ONE YEAR LATER has Steve Jobs claiming that there were THIRTEEN suicides in the FIRST SIX MONTHS of the FOLLOWING YEAR.
Do you realize how SELF-INCRIMINATING that is? This guy had some of the most ruthless lawyers in the world working for him. Do you think that he wasn’t intelligent enough to keep his mouth shut? You do not incriminate yourself, in public, if this had nothing to do with Apple products. Your lawyer wouldn’t even want you to cop to the ONE suicide from a year ago! Did Steve Jobs incriminate HP, or Microsoft, or Nokia, or Sony? No, he incriminated Apple. Why?
You failed to post a link to, well...anything, because your fake facts don’t add up. Steve Jobs didn’t even subscribe to your interpretation, why would anyone else?
Apple Lexicon
Enthuastic Self Incrimination: Apple’s strategy to baffle ‘em with bullfish.
from The Apple Lexicon (™) Interpreting Apple Theology Since 1994
from http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/chat/3134377/posts?page=274#274
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.