Posted on 03/21/2006 10:07:57 AM PST by JewishRighter
I am considering buying a pistol for personal, home protection. I don't expect to have any concealed carry needs/opportunities/license. I am pretty well settled on 45ACP as a benchmark for stopping power. I am also limiting my preferences to American manufacturers. I don't expect to do a lot of shooting, except for regular practice to maintain proficiency.
I've seen a lot of discussion of various weapons and I'm really asking for views on reliability, durability, user-friendliness, safety and degree of kickback for the Ruger P345PR. If anyone suggests another American made 45, please tell me why it would be preferred over the Ruger.
Thanks to anyone who can weigh in.
Hard to beat Kimber's line-up.
My daily carry is an "Eclipse Target II":
http://www.kimberamerica.com/
What are the ballistics for that configuration. Seems to me that powder would still be burning once the bullet has left the barrel. All of my wheel guns have a 5" minimum barrel lenth for better burn completion and bullet spin.
As for a scatter gun for home protection, too bulky. And I have four 12 ga for outdoor use. For home protection, I'll stick with my Sig P226.
I have heard some bad reports on the newest Ruger 45 auto. Trigger reset problems, most of all.
If you are set on the Ruger 45, why not consider searching for a used Ruger P-97 45 auto? They only stopped making that model about 2 years ago, and personally, I like it a lot better than the new one.
If you shop around, you should be able to find a used P-97 for around $275. That's what I would do.
deadly for the use cited.
I have an 870 with a pistol grip, not bulky at all.
Ruger is an excellent company. I have two .357 wheel guns. Friends have 9's and .40's. They love 'em. Personally, I like Sigs. I have a Sig P226 in the nightstand; and carry a Sig P232.
What I have learned (especially with Ruger) is not to buy the first of any new model they put out. Wait until you can get a serial number >10,000. Ruger will do their best to take care of problems that come up with any of their guns, but who needs the hassle.
Take a look at www.rugerforum.com if you haven't already.
For in-home use, consider a 12 gauge pump shotgun.
My favorite wheel gun.
I am not familiar with the newer Rugers but had a very extensive collection until recently, around 45 revolvers; 15 pistols and a total of 125 rugers + Sakos, and more. I had several carry weapons for different circumstances. The "Pocket Rocket" SP101 in .357 was my usual carry, also liked the high capacity 9mm; 45 ACP is ok but I am not a fan of that caliber, 45 Colt is another story! A point to ponder is liability, single action vs. double action, type of bullet(some are less politicly correct than others and it really does matter, penetration of round vs. stopping power.A 12 ga. with buckshot is a formidable defesive weapon, 9 .32 cal pellets ought to slow down a drug crazed bear. Pick up a few current or even back issues of some gun rags and do some reading, might find something written by Massad Ayoob, dont know if he is still writting?
Shalom, if you want stopping power delivered through an accurate and reliable pistol then go with a Kimber 1911 Custom II. Believe me, you will shocked by the inherent accuracy and dependibility. I used to shoot matches with mine and it worked flawlessly.
Shalom, if you want stopping power delivered through an accurate and reliable pistol then go with a Kimber 1911 Custom II. Believe me, you will shocked by the inherent accuracy and dependibility. I used to shoot matches with mine and it worked flawlessly.
Shalom, if you want stopping power delivered through an accurate and reliable pistol then go with a Kimber 1911 Custom II. Believe me, you will shocked by the inherent accuracy and dependibility. I used to shoot matches with mine and it worked flawlessly.
As I mentioned on another post, for close in participation I'll accept a shorter barrel in a semi with more cartridge capacity, and a scatter gun would be my absolute last choice. Bottom line, there are always tradeoffs. Just have to use the right tool for the right job.
Kind of like choosing the right golf club. ;-)
"As for a scatter gun for home protection, too bulky."
That was my feeling, too. I will make my next purchase a 12 Ga., which certainly can be useful in home protection in the right circumstances, such as when your neighbor lets that d#amn dog of his...oh, never mind.
What do you like about the P-97?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.