Posted on 05/24/2010 4:55:16 PM PDT by Man50D
Your Honor,
Part of the complaint in this action is a FOIA request. Mr. Obama, defendant in this case, via US attorney’s office sought dismissal of a FOIA request due to the fact that the refusal of information request by the Social Security administration was not final. Your Honor initially agreed, stating that the response from the Social Security administration was not final. Until now Taitz could not obtain a response from SSN, stating that it is a final decision.
Yesterday Taitz received a letter from Jonathan R. Cantor, Executive Director of Office of Privacy and Disclosure of the Social Security Administration dated and signed May 18, 2010. (Exhibit 1 Letter and envelope) As a stroke of providence the letter states “This is our final decision in this matter. If you still believe the decision is incorrect, however, the law permits you to seek review in a district court of the United States”.
As such an impediment was lifted, and the Plaintiff respectfully requests this Honorable court to grant her motion for reconsideration, so that the matter can be heard on the merits.
Legal Argument
In regards to the content of the response from the Social Security Administration, it relies on the finding of Department of Justice v. Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, 489 U.S. 749 (1989).
It concedes following points:
1. Under 5U.S.C. §552(b)(6) exemption from the FOIA Taitz can obtain Obama’s application for the Social Security without Obama’s consent, if other conditions are fulfilled.
2. Social security or court cannot consider the identity of the requester- therefore the court cannot deny Taitz request due to her lack of standing or lack of particularized injury
3. Social Security or courts cannot consider the purpose for which the person requests the information.
4. Social security administration is obligated to provide information, if there is a public interest in knowing how SSA administers the Social Security Act.
5. The only objection to Taitz request by the SSA, is their claim that “disclosure of records containing personal information about President Obama would not shed light on how the agency performs its statutory duties”. This is the reason SSA provides as justification for their refusal to provide the information in question.
6. Taitz appeals this decision on following grounds:
7. Official on line records of Selective service confirm that Barack Obama has been using SS number 042-68-4425.
8. Information requested does not represent personal information of Mr. Obama, but rather personal information of another individual born in 1890, who would have been 120 years old, who is most probably deceased, but whose death was either never reported to the Social Security Administration or was deleted from the records of the Social Security Administration prior or around 1986, and the number was unlawfully assumed by Mr. Obama. According to previously submitted sworn affidavit of recently retired senior deportation officer with the department of Homeland Security Mr. John Sampson, this Social Security number was issued to another individual in the state of Connecticut between 1976-1977, while Obama never resided there.
9. One of the printouts provided by Mr. Sampson show Mr. Obama’s origin in Equatorial Guiney, which is different from the official information stating his origin to be Hawaii and Kenya.
10. According to previously submitted sworn affidavit from Susan Daniels, licensed private investigator, certified by the Department of Homeland Security, this Social Security number was issued in the state of Connecticut between 1976-1977, to an individual born in 1890. As Mr. Obama never resided in CT and was not born in 1890, Ms. Daniels concludes that this is not his SS number. Ms. Daniels provided a follow up report, showing that according to multiple national databases there are numerous Social Security numbers connected to name Barack Obama and Michelle Obama, none of which were issued in Hawaii.
11. According to memoirs by Mr. Obama, such as Dreams From My Father Mr. Obama started working in Baskin Robbins store in Honolulu HI around 1975-1976, he needed SS number to obtain employment, and he would have had to obtain a SS number from HI, not CT.
12. According to a previously submitted sworn Affidavit by retired elite Scotland Yard officer of anti organized crime and anti communist proliferation units Mr. Neil Sankey, there are multiple records in National databases, showing Obama using multiple Social Security numbers, which are either numbers of deceased individuals or numbers never assigned, none of which were issued in HI.
13. According to the sworn declaration by forensic export Sandra Ramsey-Lines, Obama’s short version certification of live birth provided to the public cannot be considered as genuine without forensic examination of the original birth certificate, which Obama refuses to unseal. Lack of valid original birth certificate with the name of the doctor and the name of the hospital and signatures, could attest to the foreign birth and could explain the need to seek SS numbers of deceased individuals and numbers never assigned.
14. Madeleine Payne Dunham, Obama’s maternal grandmother, used to volunteer in Oahu circuit court probate department, where she was able to obtain SS numbers of deceased in individuals. Additionally, both Ms. Payne and Obama’s mother Ann Dunham(Obama, Soetoro) worked as loan officers and had an opportunity to view SS numbers of others.
15. As the public has a right to know how SSA performs its statutory duties, the public has a right to know how Obama obtained these SS numbers, and see the original application for SS number 042-68-4425, as well as other numbers used by Obama according to National databases.
16. Without such disclosure the public will have no trust and confidence that SSA properly performs its statutory duties, specifically in light of the fact that an individual occupying the highest office in the land, could get there using Social Security numbers of others.
17. Public has a right to know, what happens to estates of individuals, who are deceased, and whose death was never reported.
18. The public has a right to know if this breach of SSA is limited to Obama, or whether it is widespread.
m. Taitz would venture to submit to the court, that there was never a more justified need for a disclosure, as there is in this case, with a SSN wrongfully assumed and used by a President and Commander in Chief.
1. Taitz will be willing to consent to have initial discovery under seal and in camera.
1. Taitz is requesting discovery to be done expeditiously, as she is continuously subjected to death threats Exhibit 2, which would not stop, as long as this mystery exists and there is an incentive for some to intimidate attorneys seeking answers. Taitz has a family and three children, which makes this matter more urgent.
. . . . Hate to ping back to the thread, but check out this link, - incredible:
http://www.westernjournalism.com/?page_id=3326
The above page has a list of BO’s SS#’s from the investigation as well as SS numbers and address of parents. It’s quite a collection.
[Thank you, Natural Born 54.]
I believe I read that the CT # was
issued to a man who was born in 1890.
Just strikes me that this commie crew had
a fullsome identity theft ring, back when
it was very easy to do it.
Please debunk this!
link to the affidavit;
I know political trickery has been going on for 150 years or so. What is the possibility that the Clintoons set this whole thing up back in the primaries?
This is a really bad dream, If all this is true then we are responsible for bringing justice.
God help us!
“I think it will take the BALLOT BOX to take Obama down. And I think the courts will tell Taitz where to stuff her complaint.”
Unfortunately it might be another kind of box.
bump
Never replying to an after-birther damages their performance based pay check.
“Just strikes me that this commie crew had
a fullsome identity theft ring, back when
it was very easy to do it.”
I was thinking that Bill Ayers, or one of his gangster friends “schooled” Obama on how to do this.
This will all eventually hit the fan. Barry will be impeached.
Does anyone know if this is a common practice of the CIA in forming a pseudo-identity or of the FBI in the witness protection program?
Has anyone counted the total number of SS nos. issued to this branch of the Dunham family? LOL
Not with Orly running the show.
LOL true
Orly Taitz and the Birthers. The best thing Obama has going for him right now.
No wonder he pays you guys.
You have a very good point about Orly Taitz. But she HAS been treated like dirt and her children threatened so I cut her some slack.
Some cases have evidence so damning, like this one, who the attorney is doesn’t matter all that much.
Besides, I hear she has other attorney helping, who’ve donated their expertise.
So she says. If Orly Taitz told me the sun rose in the east and set in the west I'd head for San Diego to watch the sunrise over the Pacific.
Some cases have evidence so damning, like this one, who the attorney is doesn’t matter all that much.
Which is why the suit was dismissed and the attorney's sanctioned, because it was such a strong case.
Besides, I hear she has other attorney helping, who’ve donated their expertise.
She could have Perry Mason on her legal team and it still wouldn't save her.
Oh, I mistook you for someone who wanted to rid us of a usurper, you know, a patriotic person rather than the boot-licking troll you really are N-S. My mistake!
He was in high school. That would have been his freshman (’75 = 14 years old) or sophomore years (’76 = 15 years old). Perfect time to start a first job.
He learned at his grandparents' and mama's knees. They were stealing IDs before he was a twinkle in some man's eye. He perfected it later with Ayers and Dorhn. The mailman who delivered to Tom Ayers' address for years remembered he met Hussein on their sidewalk back in the mid '80s. Bernadette Dorhn was living there as well and she was into collecting IDs. You know, partners in crime back in the '80s before they became merely neighborhood acquaintances prior to the election.
EXACTLY!
Good! I am a member of Dr. Taitz’s fan page at face book. You can find out a lot there. OH, I bet if he worked at an ice cream store it was in Kenya and the ice cream kept melting.
I pegged you for a nutcase right off the bat. The moment you started kissing Orly's tuchus.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.