Skip to comments.Liberal's Solution to Border Crisis: Let Illegals Become 'State Citizens'
Posted on 06/19/2014 8:49:54 PM PDT by 2ndDivisionVet
Breitbart Texas reported on a proposed bill in New York that would allow more than 2 million illegal immigrants to get a myriad of benefits including voting rights, the ability to run for office, Medicaid, drivers licenses, and in-state tuition by allowing them to become "state citizens." A sponsor of that bill, State Senator Gustavo Rivera (D-Bronx), told Breitbart Texas he thinks states in the Southwest should consider similar legislation to deal with the border crisis involving thousands of Central Americans entering the country illegally.
The bill was crafted "so that it can be replicated in other states," Rivera said. "If immigration reform doesn't happen at the national level, the states can take action."
If Rivera's legislation were passed in New York, an estimated 2.7 million people, all of whom are not citizens of the United States, would become "state citizens." In order to qualify, an individual would need to have no criminal history and prove they have lived in New York for three years.
In order to introduce the bill, Rivera released a press release called, "Bold New Campaign Demands Full Equality for Non-Citizens."(continued)
(Excerpt) Read more at breitbart.com ...
this just keeps on getting more off the wall by the hour.
My solution is to delcare war on Mexico, since they have on us, close the border militarlily and shoot to kill anyone crossing illegally.
Then tell the Mexican president to cease and desist or we’ll drop a small nuclear bomb in the heart of Mexico City.
You forgot: prosecute the Democrats and their weak sisters the RINOs
Einstein were right. The only thing that is infinite is human stupidity.
Look - admit right now that the border can never be fully closed. People are rather inventive when it comes to OUTA’ing obstacles. Still - closing it 99% is doable, and not at a huge cost. You are paying the army anyway - let them practice along the border.
Grab the aircraft carrier they just decommissioned, park it in the Gulf of Mexico and use it as a holding pen until you can send illegals back to their native land.
At the same time, make legal immigration a little easier and a little more relaxed. At the moment, it is a horrible mess of conflicting rules. Kill the idea of anchor babies for anyone other than legal immigrants. Maybe they have not completed all the hoops yet, but they are working on it. Any kid they have should be judged an American citizen.
Illegal? Congratulate the new parents on their way to their deportation flight.
I checked to see where State Senator Gustavo Rivera was born...
Puerto Rico so hes an American...
“People are rather inventive when it comes to OUTAing obstacles. “
Let’s ask the Israelis.
As a real immigrant I was quite content to wait until I was an American citizen...
Any kid they have should be judged an American citizen.
they already are...
the children of real immigrants are American citizens at birth...
they just cant be president...
Oh, they know. Found another 15 tunnels already this year, I think - could be more. Sure, a couple of them are straightforward smuggling routes, but that can’t be hugely reassuring.
Yep. That's because their real agenda is being exposed. They want amnesty so that they can get the voters. They literally do not care how that happens - it is utterly irrelevent to them. They want the Democrat voters they assume these people will become.
Nothing but power for the sake of power. That is the Democrats.
Um, that is no longer the case.
Natural Born Citizen means Citizen at Birth.
Every Immigration Attorney in the Country agrees with me.
Every member of Congress agrees with me.
Every Judge in the Country agrees with me.
Every State Election Officer agrees with me.
There are only two types of US Citizen:
Naturalized or Natural Born
Of course, the NY Legislator is an idiot on the Constitution, as he has no authority at the State level to enact citizenship rules.
You didn’t say American citizen parents
you said legal immigrant
there is a difference...
If the child is born after both immigrant parents become American citizens then yes she is an NBC and she can be president...
If however she was born BEFORE the immigrant parents became American citizens while she is still an American citizen born herself she is NOT an NBC and therefore cannot be president...
This should be illegal, since they as members of that state would theoretically vote on “Federal” candidates?? If not it violates the spirit of the Constitution since our 17th Amendment would have originally allowed these supposed “state citizens” vote on state legislative races, who then in session in state legislatures would have picked FEDERAL legislators to the U.S. Senate! Treasonous, all. Democrats!
Thank you Nana!
Is it formal? Things might have changed now, but a friend of mine gave birth in the US. A month or so early and unexpectedly, and the doctors and nurses were amazing. So were the church visitors who basically took her, her husband and their new arrival in hand and sorted a place to stay, baby clothes, friends. Nice people - they stay in touch and trade pictures :)
Yet because her child were born in the USA and registered there (paperwork mix up, they did ask for him to be registered at the embassy, not locally) he’s technically a US citizen now. Going to cause problems down the road for him. It were that easy to have an anchor baby.
Are “State Citizens” sort of like the Made In Montana firearms, exempt from federal laws such as NFA ‘34? Which for some reason are causing threats and conniptions from the federal government? The same government that’s pushing State Citizens?
Now I do agree with many who hold that the “under the jurisdiction there of” portion of the 14th Amendment could be tweaked by Congress to disallow Citizenship for such a child. Congress does have the power to make and change citizenship rules.
However, under current law, if the child is a citizen at birth, the child is a Natural Born Citizen and can indeed be President.
I suggest you go to the US State Department Web Page and pull up an application for US Passport. You will find links there, to all valid US Citizenship laws and the dates in which those laws applied.
“Natural Born Citizen” means “Citizen at Birth” and absolutely, positively NOTHING else.
today there was an illegal alien baby born to an illegal alien woman who just happened to be strolling through our southern border heavily in labor..
her son was born in America therefore...
so is her an American citizen ???
is he an NBC ???
can he be president even though his parents were not under the jurisdiction of but his mother was busy breaking the law and sneering at our sovereignty ???
but you probably wont have to wait that long to have an illegal alien president..
the parents of the Castro twins the mayor and the congressman are illegal aliens...
Having said that, if the child you speak of was indeed a Citizen at birth? YES, that child is eligible to be President.
Only non-citizens and Naturalized citizens are excluded.
Anything to keep a permanent and growing underclass of eligible Dhimmicrap voters.
Great idea -— let’s just send all the illegals from all the other states to New York!!!
I am now looking forward to a REFUND of tuition paid in the amount of $32,000.oo, since you are now offering it free to ILLEGAL , UNDOCUMENTED ALIENS !!
Please note - this does not include any interest on principle, as CHARITY BEGINS AT HOME , before ILLEGAL ALIENS !!
Thank you for your attention to this matter ... you BUll-$HITTER !!
.... Our American president .... Is not a friend of America!
This is what the South did by importing slaves. These state benefits are federally funded by the way.
New York would be making illegal aliens into national citizens. They don't have that power.
They already are “state citizens”. If they want to vote as bad as the commie lib ‘RATS think they do, send them back home with instructions on how to elect less evil politicians.
This is not the job of the states! Where the hell is Eric the Holder and his lawsuit boys? This is the federal government’s job that the commie libs are trying to do.
Gosh — that’s exactly what I’ve been thinking of all week!
It would seem the Supreme Court has decided NBC isn’t relevant any longer...
It would be a great experiment and would take some of the pressure off of Texas and Arizona. It will make NY the magnet for all illegal aliens. We will get to see the damage that would be done in a single state instead of risking the entire nation. That is the very purpose of Federalism.
Why were all not yet “ on the streets” marching towards Washington escapes me at the moment.
absolute power corrupts absolutely, and they are absolutely wrong if they think they can pull this off with the biggest firestorm imaginable frying them all.
either we are a Nation of LAW or we are a Nation of peasants and “masters”.
a little leaven has spoiled the whole loaf......
This may e a blessing in disguise as it MAY finally awaken the sleeping giant of American Moral Outrage..and inspire the vast majority of us to demand that the borders are policed. and the existing laws followed.
I do sometimes wonder, now. It seems lip service to the law, but in practice it is shut up and eat your gruel.
Ask what they intend to do about the massive invasion of illegal aliens into Texas, bringing crime, disease, drugs and unbelievable expense to the state to care for them.
This is sheer insanity!
HOUSTON, TexasGovernor Rick Perry (R-TX) appeared on Fox News Fox and Friends show and said Texas lacks the resources and manpower to secure the 1,200 mile Texas border... BS!
Other Texas elected officials, speaking on condition of anonymity have told Breitbart Texas that Texas does, in fact, have the resources to conduct not only a surge operation, but a prolonged border control operation that would secure the Texas border with Mexico.
Now, Perry says he will do something. I'll believe it when I see it.
DO N'T LET THE MUZZIE GET AWAY WITH HIS CLOWARD-PIVEN SCHEME! DON'T LET HIM DESTROY TEXAS.
View on www.breitbart.com http://www.breitbart.com/Breitbart-Texas/2014/06/17/Perry-on-Fox-We-don-t-have-the-resources-to-secure-the-Texas-Border http://www.governor.state.tx.us/contact/
Telephone Information and Referral Hotline [for Texas callers] : (800) 843-5789
Information and Referral and Opinion Hotline [for Austin, Texas and out-of-state callers] : (512) 463-1782
Office of the Governor Main Switchboard [office hours are 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. CST]- (512) 463-2000
Citizens Assistance Telecommunications Device If you are using a telecommunication device for the deaf (TDD)- call 711 to reach Relay Texas
Mailing Address- Office of the Governor P.O. Box 12428 Austin, Texas 78711-2428
SIGN THE PETITION!!!!!
Request for Immediate Texas Border Control
We, the undersigned, because the federal government has failed to act, call on the Texas Legislature to develop and fund a border and port of entry security plan utilizing state and local law...
On the TX members Action Board - a link to fax Perry and phone call to make to your R Reps supporting Rep Louie Gohmerts Fortify the Border Amendment.
You have to be registered at NumbersUSA....its worth joining for all of the faxes you can send to your elected officials. These are good guys, whove been fighting the good fight for YEARS.
Additionally, anyone can call Perry and anyone can ask their Rep to support Gohmert's amendment.
If people started merely protesting by merely throwing their tv in the trash and buying exclusively guns and ammo with their earnings, we would not need a march. But too many lemmings with vanity.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.