America: Hot Dog Toppings Open Thread

pjmedia ^ | Stephen Kruiser

[virgil283]

"We should all take a break from politics to argue about food preferences once in a while. ........ Tonight’s culinary question involves favorite hot dog toppings. I’m pretty big tent when it comes to this....."

[elcid1970]

“Ketchup on a hotdog is worse than low esteem. It’s downright disgusting. :-)”

Almost the exact words of Inspector Harry Callahan. The name of that Dirty Harry film escapes me.

Anyway, top it with mustard (almost any kind), relish & onions. Castleberry’s chili topping is an option.

Hebrew National kosher dogs preferred.

[jurroppi1]

I’m right there with you. Typically I will use less ketchup than mustard, but I have always liked both on hot dogs. Relish sometimes as well.

If we talk Bratwurst, that’s a different game, then it depends on the brat.

[Little Bill]

Now we are getting to the Heart of the food dilemma, fried clams. How could any right thinking New Englander eat batter dipped fried Clams?

I have lived in New England most of my life and have never eaten a batter dipped fried clam, never. I think that batter dipped clams were thought up by the same clowns who invented Manhattan clam chowder.

[0.E.O]

Show me a man who puts ketchup on a hot dog and I’ll show you a complete barbarian. A fully dressed dog has mustard, relish, onions, sliced tomato, kosher pickle, and celery salt. Peppers are optional, but OK.

[verga]

Every year for Christmas my in laws give us a gallon of Chivetta’s and 5 lbs of Sahlens hot dogs.
I have friends that send us the Cleavland Browns brown mustard from time to time as well. Not a fan of the Browns, but I do love the mustard.

[CrazyIvan]

“Ketchup doe not belong on a hot dog.”

I’d argue that it doesn’t belong anywhere.

[sopwith]

ketchup only

[sopwith]

ketchup only

[sopwith]

ketchup only

[sopwith]

ketchup only

[sopwith]

ketchup only

[advertising guy]

you outta try the jalapenos.....!!!

[OneWingedShark]

ketchup only

Bleh.

[Tijeras_Slim]

"Nobody, I mean NOBODY puts ketchup on a hot dog."

[sopwith]

ketchup only

[sopwith]

ketchup only

[sopwith]

ketchup only

[machogirl]

Someday, I am going to take my boys there, and we will order the “Big Unit”. What the heck, I’ll take my girls too.

[Revolting cat!]

[sopwith]

ketchup only