Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Attack of the Nazi Trolls: A Lesson for Message Board Moderators
Richardpoe.com ^ | 10-27-03 | Richard Poe

Posted on 10/27/2003 11:53:33 AM PST by SJackson

Wednesday, August 13, 2003 at 13:41

Attack of the Nazi Trolls: A Lesson for Message Board Moderators

In a recent blog entry titled, "I've Been Red-Baited!", I wrote, "I'm not familiar with LibertyForum.org, but it appears to be an anti-Bush, anti-war message board with a distinctly anti-Jewish undertone."

A member of LibertyForum.org named Max Soldo (aka "thoughtcriminal") has responded by e-mail and provided further clarification of LibertyForum's political orientation. He writes:

This forum is a libertarian forum, and is devoted to the libertarian concept of unabashed free speech. With that principle in mind, most posters aren't libertarian as many fringe types have taken advantage of this policy (which includes a no-banning policy) to run amok...hence the preponderance of anti-Jewish posts on this forum.

All of this raises interesting questions for any message board moderator -- such as myself -- who has tried his best to allow a relatively high level of free expression. Inevitably, Nazi trolls find your forum and begin probing your defenses. If you allow them to post messages, they immediately spread the word to other Nazi trolls and soon your message board is infested.

At that point, all the normal people stop posting. It's a bit like when a fight breaks out in a bar and everyone stops talking and turns to watch the fight, transfixed. Suddenly, your message board becomes an arena for Nazi trolls and people arguing with Nazi trolls.

This is called "free speech."

I decided long ago that allowing Nazi trolls to occupy my message board and drive off everyone who does not share their idiosyncratic obsessions is a very poor method for encouraging "free speech." Therefore, I make frequent and forceful use of such allegedly un-libertarian methods as censoring and, when necessary, banning troublemakers, brownshirted or otherwise.

Apparently, the decision-makers at LibertyForum.org have adopted a different approach. As a result, their self-styled "libertarian" message board has become, by Mr. Soldo's description, a playground for non-libertarian "fringe types" to "run amok."

"It does get quite ugly at times, but that's the price one pays for sticking to one's principles," writes Mr. Soldo in a subsequent e-mail.

Well, if that's the price, I don't think I'm willing to pay it. I will add the sad fate of LibertyForum.org to my growing list of reasons for rethinking whether or not I wish to continue calling myself a "libertarian."

 


TOPICS: Culture/Society; Editorial
KEYWORDS: antisemites; antisemitism; bannedfreeperhangout; libertarian; libertarians; libertyforum; nazis; nazism; needabouncer; neonazis; religion; religousintolerance; richardpoe; trolls
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 81-100101-120121-140 ... 441-457 next last
To: tpaine; JohnGalt; John Robinson
Great idea. </sarcasm> All those who lack the guts for debate could just tune it out.
101 posted on 10/27/2003 1:28:10 PM PST by Avoiding_Sulla (You can't see where we're going when you don't look where we've been.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 80 | View Replies]

To: AppyPappy; Catspaw
<< Actually, many people there are former FReepers. >>

There are no "former" FReepers.

FReepers are not quitters.
102 posted on 10/27/2003 1:31:52 PM PST by Brian Allen ( Rebellion to tyrants is obedience to God - Thomas Jefferson)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 8 | View Replies]

To: Avoiding_Sulla
That was a good explanation of your point; it gives me a few things to consider.
103 posted on 10/27/2003 1:32:07 PM PST by JohnGalt (Attention Pseudocons: Wilsonianrepublic.com is still available)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 101 | View Replies]

To: SJackson
Oh boy & goodie gumdrops! Yet another "free speech" BBS! Have the 12 year old potty mouths discovered it yet? How about the deviated preverts? This should be good for a few laughs.
104 posted on 10/27/2003 1:33:50 PM PST by Frunabulax ("If the truth will kill them, let them die.")
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: dirtboy; MadameAxe; OWK; jmc813
In the case of Dane, I've heard it's loosely akin to fishing with hand grenades.

Dude dirtboy, if you are going to mention me by name in one of your replies(as you did in your reply #99) I would you request that you have the courage to "ping" me if you mention me by name(which it seems you do not have, IMO).

Oh BTW, I already know that I mentioned Jim, in one of my replies on this thread(with OWK), but in an earlier exchange with jmc813(where jmc813 used Jim's name and didn't ping Jim and where I pointed it out, Jim requested that he not be "pinged").

Fine with me, but I am also not Jim, and would request that if you(dirtboy) mention me by name in one of your replies, that you have the courage to "ping" me in the future.

105 posted on 10/27/2003 1:37:02 PM PST by Dane
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 99 | View Replies]

To: Dane
Kiss my pasty rump, Dane. You can wait with "baited" breath for me to worry about what you think of me. But good luck fishin' for crappie with that halitosis of yours.
106 posted on 10/27/2003 1:40:39 PM PST by dirtboy (Now in theaters - Howard Dean as Buzz Lightweight - taking the Dems to Oblivion and Beyond in 2004!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 105 | View Replies]

To: Chancellor Palpatine
Mostly, the internet publishers simply culled newspapers articles together that brought some forgotten angle to the forefront to be exposed to light.

It made for interesting reading anyway and provided a radical world view to keep the place lively.

There was even the case of some crazy guy, Leo Wanta who was saying the weirdest stuff in a Wisconsin courtroom that received national exposure on FR.

The conspiracy rantors came and went all the time but the community at large stayed together. While I appreciate your point of view--far more than you care for my crack-pot world view, right?-- if only because it's unique in its radical centrism, its not exactly the best point of view for a conservative libertarian website.

107 posted on 10/27/2003 1:41:10 PM PST by JohnGalt (Attention Pseudocons: Wilsonianrepublic.com is still available)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 100 | View Replies]

To: OWK
Didn't have a lick of trouble with the skinheads until they got kicked off this site (and Jim pointed them in our direction).

Now you're blaming Jim because your site did exactly as it promised and turned into a cesspool? I've seen maybe 3 or 4 times Jim has referenced LF and it was usually after the perp was jettisoned.

If you didn't think that was exactly what was going to happen to LF when those rules were posted, all of you were naive.

108 posted on 10/27/2003 1:41:42 PM PST by Bob J
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 33 | View Replies]

To: Bob J; OWK; MadameAxe
Now you're blaming Jim because your site did exactly as it promised and turned into a cesspool?

I guess it beats re-examining the premises of the site. Seriously, would anyone here hold an open party at their home where anyone could walk in the door? Why should a web forum be different? Freedom of association isn't just part of the 1st Amendment, it's vital for just about any human endeavor.

109 posted on 10/27/2003 1:44:10 PM PST by dirtboy (Now in theaters - Howard Dean as Buzz Lightweight - taking the Dems to Oblivion and Beyond in 2004!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 108 | View Replies]

To: dirtboy
LF is getting what they asked for. They wanted to be a free speech site and that is what they got.
110 posted on 10/27/2003 1:45:23 PM PST by AppyPappy (If You're Not A Part Of The Solution, There's Good Money To Be Made In Prolonging The Problem.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 109 | View Replies]

To: veronica
You and I inhabit a universe where people do not demonstrate their lack of vocabulary by using cusses. What's so hard to understand about your post? I have no clue...
111 posted on 10/27/2003 1:47:31 PM PST by cyborg (Kyk nou, die ding wat jy soek issie hierie sienj)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 55 | View Replies]

To: dirtboy
Kiss my pasty rump, Dane. You can wait with "baited" breath for me to worry about what you think of me. But good luck fishin' for crappie with that halitosis of yours.

Whatever dude, have fun stewing in your own bitter juices. Whatever floats your, IMO, conceited boat.

112 posted on 10/27/2003 1:48:15 PM PST by Dane
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 106 | View Replies]

To: JohnGalt
I don't understand your point re: "There's nothing un-libertarian about respecting property rights" in relation to my post. Poe suggested that he is not sure whether he is still a libertarian; my point is that his line does not make any sense if he is at the present time considering himself a libertarian.

I may have misunderstood So by exercising property rights on his own forum, he doesn't think he is a libertarian anymore? . I took you to mean that Poe had effectively abandoned libertarinism (and I don’t know if he’s a libertarian to begin with), by enforcing his right, as owner of the site, to control content.

113 posted on 10/27/2003 1:49:18 PM PST by SJackson
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 107 | View Replies]

To: Avoiding_Sulla
Avoiding_Sulla:

JohnRob is rumored to have a personalized troll button awaiting in the wings. That offers one solution. Do you think it a worthy enough idea to pass along?

Great idea, [seriously]. -- All those who lack the guts for debate could just tune it out.
- I wonder, do they realize that it is they themselves who would end up being ignored?

Actually the troll button doesn't really tuned it all out. The user of such a button only gets SOME of the slime. It is second-hand slime, as those who are willing to wade thru the muck will post excerpts of it.

You say debate is 'slime'.. I say it's the reason for the forums existence.. Telling difference of view.

The point I was making was that it tends to get a bit overabundant (such as with sycophants encouraging primals with mindless bump after bump, or by slapping each other on the back with how good the last slimer's point was and how lame was the idea of their pidgeon). It's called hijacking a thread. You've never seen it happen I suppose?

Indeed I did, -- right here, and I commented on it to S Jackson.. These nazi slimers must be controled!!! [sarcasm]

It can be done with shear volume (spam) or it can be done with the unsavory. The troll button only gives a little respite so that a more serious or purposeful group can still communicate. Kinda like adults talking above the heads of the juveniles who are trying to get unwarranted attention or who don't like what the parents have planned for them. More effective too. :^)

As I said, -- I'd really like to see it tried.

I'd bet it might have the unintended consequense of shutting up the biggest bunch of whiners on FR, --- my critics... [sarcasm]

114 posted on 10/27/2003 1:51:48 PM PST by tpaine (I'm trying to be 'Mr Nice Guy', but Arnie won, & politics as usual lost. Yo!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 101 | View Replies]

To: 11B3; OWK
Have you ever thought that maybe it was YOU that brings out the worst in otherwise normal people?

HAHAHAHAHA. That'd be the day. His ego is far too big.

115 posted on 10/27/2003 1:52:37 PM PST by Neets (I CAN'T HEAR YOU, LA LA LA LA LA LA LA LA)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 53 | View Replies]

To: dirtboy
It's like someone tuning to a jazz radio station and then complaining because they aren't playing any AC/DC.
116 posted on 10/27/2003 1:54:18 PM PST by Bob J
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 109 | View Replies]

To: SJackson
No, I took Poe to mean that he thought being a libertarian meant you cannot exercise property rights. I think he means to conjur the caricature of 'libertarian as a nudist dope smoker who doesn't want to pay any taxes.'
117 posted on 10/27/2003 1:54:56 PM PST by JohnGalt (Attention Pseudocons: Wilsonianrepublic.com is still available)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 113 | View Replies]

To: Bob J
Now you're blaming Jim because your site did exactly as it promised and turned into a cesspool? I've seen maybe 3 or 4 times Jim has referenced LF and it was usually after the perp was jettisoned.

Blame?

Nah... Jim did what Jim does best.. a little subtle manipulation, and voila.. his headache is now someone else's.

Not a problem... we'll deal with it.

Free speech is worth it.

Does it come without warts? No.

There'll always be fools.

We operate on the assumption that a fool is better rebutted than intimidated or censored.

We don't have a collection of Dales' over at LibertyForum.

No "dossiers" to whip out.. no implied threats.. no "zots".

Truth wins there, because it is true.. not because it is prescribed and enforced.

Does it take work?

Sure.

Does it subject you to outside criticism from those predisposed to smear? Yup..

But all in all... it's worth it.

118 posted on 10/27/2003 1:55:34 PM PST by OWK
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 108 | View Replies]

To: Neets
The 'ego' laughs.
119 posted on 10/27/2003 1:58:01 PM PST by tpaine (I'm trying to be 'Mr Nice Guy', but Arnie won, & politics as usual lost. Yo!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 115 | View Replies]

To: tpaine
You say debate is 'slime'.. I say it's the reason for the forums existence.. Telling difference of view.
120 posted on 10/27/2003 1:58:14 PM PST by Avoiding_Sulla (You can't see where we're going when you don't look where we've been.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 114 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 81-100101-120121-140 ... 441-457 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson