Posted on 03/17/2004 7:52:47 AM PST by axel f
Texan argues for concealed carry Lone Star lawmaker lost both parents in restaurant rampage
By John Hanna - Associated Press Writer
Tuesday, March 16, 2004
Topeka - A Texas legislator whose parents died in a 1991 shooting spree in a cafeteria urged a Kansas Senate committee to endorse a bill that would allow Kansans to carry concealed weapons.
The Federal and State Affairs Committee is reviewing a House-passed measure that would require the state to issue concealed-carry permits to any Kansan who qualifies and pays a $150 application fee. People would qualify if they were 21 and American citizens, had undergone eight hours of gun training and did not suffer from a mental illness or drug and alcohol addiction.
Texas state Rep. Suzanna Hupp told the committee she wished she'd had her gun with her when she and her parents dined at a Luby's restaurant in Killeen, Texas, in October 1991. She'd left her gun in her car, something she realized only after a man rammed his truck into the building, got out and started shooting.
She said she was not carrying the gun in her purse because she didn't want to break the law and lose her chiropractor's license. She acknowledged that if she had her gun, she might not have hit the assailant but added she would have at least changed the situation. Twenty-three people died, including her parents.
"I'm angry, as you can tell," she said. "I was mad at hell at my legislators, because I felt they had legislated me out of my right to protect myself."
Hupp, a Republican, first won her seat in the Texas House in 1996, having already become a vocal gun rights advocate.
Texas enacted a concealed-carry law in 1995, and only Kansas, Illinois, Nebraska and Wisconsin do not have such a statute, though nine states put some restrictions on residents' ability to receive a permit.
"If you can imagine -- sitting there, like a fish in a barrel, waiting for it to be your turn," Hupp said.
The committee planned to hear from opponents of the bill today. In the past, they have argued that enacting a concealed-carry law would lead to an increase in gun-related violence.
But Rep. L. Candy Ruff, a primary sponsor of the bill, said in other states, 1 percent or fewer residents typically seek concealed-carry permits. "We are talking about law-abiding citizens," she said.
"They are not the type of people who are involved in road rage," said Ruff, D-Leavenworth.
The Legislature approved a concealed-carry bill in 1997, but then-Gov. Bill Graves vetoed it. Gov. Kathleen Sebelius has said she supports concealed carry only for retired law enforcement officers and probably would not sign a broader bill.
Earlier this month, the House approved the bill, 78-45. Supporters were six votes short of a two-thirds majority, which is required to override a gubernatorial veto.
This year's bill contains a list of places where it would remain illegal to carry concealed guns, including courthouses, jails, prisons, polling places, bars, taverns, the Statehouse and the Kansas State Fair.
Sen. John Vratil, a Federal and State Affairs Committee member, said he would like to see churches added to the list. He also said he wonders why the right to carry concealed weapons would be limited to U.S. citizens.
"I think we've got a form of discrimination here," said Vratil, R-Leawood.
Not that any churches have ever been shot up by nutcases. /sarcasm
Most of the times I get around to reading legislative deliberations, I come to the conclusion that being elected to political office is like joining the anti-mensa society.
It's limited to citizens because the Second Amendment refers to "the right of the People to keep and bear", meaning the body of citizenry. No alien has the "right" to own a firearm in the U.S.
The NBC TV show West Wing, in reruns on the local ABC affiliate (shows from a couple of years ago) slimed Texas's concealed-carry laws with an episode in which someone stood up in a Texas church and opened fire, whereupon someone else with a CCW license also stood up and opened fire at the bad guy -- but missed and killed a 9-year-old girl (Democratic pity party: someone has to die!).
It hasn't happened, but Worst Wing's writers had a high old time putting President Bartlett up on his high horse, slapping down his Texan VP on the subject. It's the gun-grabbers' dream scenario: "more harm to let them carry". Mind you, the scenario was identical to the Charles Hennard and Larry Ashcroft shootings in Texas; Suzanna Gratia Hupp was testifying about the Hennard incident in Killeen. Larry Ashcroft, whose name usually doesn't escape my keyboard or my lips, was a Phineas Priest, a kind of right-wing assassin, who went after the Baptists because the Southern Baptist Convention had "compromised" its segregationist theology of 50 years ago. He shot up a Sunday-school meeting, then killed himself with a curse on his lips.
When his big moment arrived, he made his play only to find himself surrounded by armed off-duty cops.
I have no idea how true that story is, I have no first hand knowledge.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.