Posted on 05/07/2006 9:53:58 AM PDT by Chi-townChief
A "blogstorm" is thundering across liberal Web sites. Many liberals are furious at the White House press corps for virtually ignoring Stephen Colbert's keynote speech at the press corp's own White House Correspondents' Dinner last Saturday. To non-liberals, this may seem like an isolated complaint. To liberals, it further justifies their belief that the media, particularly TV news, is a big stinking cabal of conservatives.
The truth is many in the media wrote about Bush's stand-up routine at the dinner as if they had just watched the coming of a comic genius, but they didn't report much on Colbert's funnier, harsher jokes. This may have been a case of the press corps following a standard motto: to the winner goes the spoils, and Bush got more laughs (out of copy written for him) than Colbert did.
How did Bush tickle reporters? He made fun of the fact that he can barely speak English (he is quite simply the worst communicator of all U.S. presidents), that our vice president is a heartless face-shooter, and that Bush is basically an idiot.
Ha ha, our "war president" knows he's a village idiot? To members of the White House press corps, that's some real funny stuff. To non-insiders, this looked like another example of good old boys and gals slapping each other on the back.
Colbert's routine was more remarkable for its unique and creative brazenness. He joked that Bush's presidency is like the Hindenburg; that Bush's wiretappers were monitoring this very event, and that the White House press corps, sitting in front of Colbert, gave Bush a free pass, scandal after scandal, until recently (when his polls numbers dropped).
How's this for a newsworthy lead? It was perhaps the first time in Bush's tenure that the president was forced to sit and listen to any American cite the litany of criminal and corruption allegations that have piled up against his administration. And mouth-tense Bush and first lady Laura Bush fled as soon as possible afterward.
From whom were they fleeing? A star comedian pretending to be a Fox News-like blowhard doing a sort of performance art that America hasn't witnessed nationally since the days of Andy Kaufman. Even if Colbert's bit had been reported as a train wreck, that would have sufficed. Instead, shocking lines like the following were barely covered by any traditional organ except industry magazine Editor & Publisher: "I stand by" Bush, Colbert cracked, "because he stands for things. Not only for things, he stands on things. Things like aircraft carriers and rubble, and recently flooded city squares. And that sends a strong message that no matter what happens to America, she will always rebound with the most powerfully staged photo ops in the world."
For TV reporters in particular to quote that gruesome line would be an agreement with Colbert, that they helped Bush mix politics with corruption from the ashes of 9/11 ("aircraft carriers and rubble"), and failed to see through Bush's politicization of the drowning of an American city after a hurricane ("recently flooded city squares").
But ignoring a newsworthy keynote speech -- at an event the press corps itself set up -- doesn't go unnoticed anymore. Internet stables for liberals, like the behemoth dailykos.com, began rumbling as soon as the correspondents' dinner was reported in the mainstream press, with scant word of Colbert's combustive address.
This is trouble for the media. It has been losing customers to bloggers and Web sites for years. This won't help. The media's implosion of silence could be one of the final reasons many liberals use to not turn on TV news. It's not like they feel a vested interest in the industry anyway, since it has been bought and parceled by conservatives.
There is Rupert Murdoch's Fox News, that Pravda of GOP propaganda and breeding ground for Bush appointees. There are the networks' Sunday news shows that give more face time to Republicans. There are cable news channels like MSNBC, where Republicans have programmed the shows and hired on-air Republicans and conservatives-lite, from Tucker Carlson to Joe Scarborough and Chris Matthews. Some TV watchdogs even chronicle these conservative media daily, backed up by transcripts and video clips from TV news shows, in the expansive Web site, MediaMatters.com.
On cable, only CNN still plays the journalism-school middle ground most of the time, questioning liberals, moderates and conservatives with equal skepticism and respect. Clearly, in terms of advertising revenue, CNN alone cares to attract the disposable income of American viewers of all political stripes.
To liberals, this must be somewhat puzzling, since the rest of the conservative media primarily sides with a president whose approval ratings stand at 32 percent, a whisker better than Nixon's before he resigned in disgrace.
Liberals find true solace on TV only in the fake news of Comedy Central's "The Colbert Report" and "The Daily Show," a place where Jon Stewart merely has to show actual clips of Bush speaking, or Condi Rice, or Cheney, or Donald Rumsfeld to elicit laughter at their hubris. If NBC News let in audiences during its broadcasts, those people might also laugh at the president.
But the TV news corps, the unthinking and unblinking herd of pack journalists, prefer to laugh with the president, and kiss many viewers goodbye.
mailto:delfman@suntimes.com
That's a nasty article. Typical leftist hate-filled drivel.
When you read an article with a statement like this:
"On cable, only CNN still plays the journalism-school middle ground most of the time, questioning liberals, moderates and conservatives with equal skepticism and respect."
Then you know the author doesn't have a clue about reality.
Go watch and see what Michelle Malkin had to say about the cover-up: http://hotair.com/
The libs are truly a pathetic lot. They even take the fun out of political satire.
Colbert's timing was off. His lead-ins to the jokes were too long to be effective. His delivery of the punchlines was staggered and jumpy.
His ending skit with Helen Thomas was initially humorous, but it rambled on much to long and lost its humor.
Colbert needs to go back to clown college. In comedy, timing is everything. Colbert's timing was way off.
This guy thinks Chris Matthews is a conservative? He's mad because some Bush-hater didn't get the same coverage as the President?
Thanks for posting an example of the deranged left.
Huh? What's this guy been smoking?
This guy actually thinks the media is conservative... truly laughable.
He puts Chris Mathews down as part of the conservative media.... that is truly ignorant.
It's obvious like every other tv "critic" I've read, Elfman is a deranged, flaming liberal. Now honestly, any person who, like Elfman, is supposed to be knowlegeable about tv and believes it to be controlled by conservatives is thoroughly incompetent as well a barking moonbat.
Doug Elfman says: woof woof
Sounds like it's straight out of Kos, doesn't it?
I'm sure Mr.Elfman watches him while he's hmmmm, pleasing himself.
Is that guy an illegal alien? He should get together with this guy:
http://tinyurl.com/djaok
Elfman sounds like a real space cadet. He's living in a fantasy world. "Television critic!" Wow! ROTFL!!! Must be one of those jobs most Americans don't want to do. His being alive is really making the world a better place. A real Tube Boob.
I don't understand your post.
Thats an understatement. But it makes lefties laugh, so the alphabet media keeps cranking it out. It's actually hard to find a decent comedian these days. They all seem to be reading the same tired script. It turns my stomach.
Trust your gut instinct - Colbert is a sour political comedian and Elfman is just as sour - both have a fatal case of BBS. (Bush Bashing Syndrome)
Colbert wasn't funny. As a "humorist" he should be happy he wasn't the story.
I think Elf-man suffers from small man disease.
Colbert is a John Stewart wannbe, only less funny.
Elfman is a TV critic, IOW he is a no talent hack who spend his life criticizing others. I've scrapped stuff off the the bottom of my shoe, that had a higher IQ !
More AIDs dementia from Miss Elfman.
....Colbert's funnier, harsher jokes.....
I watched both performances. Colbert fell flat on his ass. The audience did not laugh and had embarrased looks. There were calls for the hook in the location from which I watched.
The man flat out blew a great opportunity.
'Star comedian?' Holding up a picture of Eric Cartman would have been funnier than this jackass.
LOL!
I was thinking the exact same thing!
Did you see this guy at the dinner? What was it like?
Colbert sucked big time, perhaps that's why he was mostly ignored. He was the worse I've seen at the WHCD. You know where this guy is coming from when he says CNN is balanced, lol.
In past years it seems the president always gets more of the attention, anyway, and this year the president was funnier than I've ever seen.
I wasn't there; just saw newsclips.
TO ME, he just rattled off some jokes like he was reading headlines
for the bottom-of-the hour news on radio.
Except he was slower and even less funny.
I thought maybe it was just me, but eh laughter from the audience seemed
sort of thin (but that could just be bad microphone arrangement).
I've seen his show a few times. He can be funny there...but not
funny enough to get me to tune in regularly.
(And I do go for the news commentator type of comedy format...for most
years I have tried to catch the intro and news portion of SNL...those are
the parts of the show usually guaranteed to get me chuckling.)
I agree the Helen Thomas skit could have been really funny but he totally wrecked it.
His initial joke about suvs sucked.
I didn't see it, and clearly Colbert has hurt his career by doing it, but for the record, I like Colbert's half hour -- Like Jon Stewart only much BETTER, AND, I always thought -- with a conservative edge.
He IS a practicing Roman Catholic, and makes no bones about it, but sees the problems that church has too -- "The Pope may be infallible," he said once, "But that does mean he never makes mistakes."
I think that's a funny line.
Colbert's humor works well in a controlled, Tele-Promptered, Canned Laughter enviornment.
Considering that nearly all of his "jokes" TANKED before a silent audience. I can kind of imagine the MSM's hesitation in airing Colbert's miserably un-funny diatribe.
Jack.
Hey, uh, Elfman? You're the frigging TELEVISION CRITIC. Leave your damned politics out of your column and just tell me what new shows suck, OK?
}:-)4
Wow, Doctor. I think you have hit the nail squarely on the head.
>>
. . . only CNN still plays the journalism-school middle ground . . .
<<
Ha. Ha ha ha.
Ha ha. Ha ha ha, ha.
HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA!!!
I agree. I have no trouble listening to Pres. Bush. As far as I am concerned, he speaks English articulately. This writer is just flapping his gums. I wish the moderator would put up a "Barf Alert" to these kind of liberal rampages.
>>
. . . a president whose approval ratings stand at 32 percent, a whisker better than Nixon's before he resigned in disgrace.
<<
And a full ten points better than Harry Truman, the democRAT who, based on bad intelligence, lied to the country and murdered hundreds of thousands of innocent Japanese CIVILIANS with the only nuclear weapons ever used in combat.
TRUMAN LIED AND INNOCENTS DIED! IMPEACH TRUMAN!
-To non-insiders, this looked like another example of good old boys and gals slapping each other on the back.-
Well, DUH. It's a White House press dinner. It's all ABOUT insiders. Is he jealous because he didn't get an invite? Poor widdwle weftie.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.