Posted on 04/23/2010 1:25:04 PM PDT by NYer
ROME, April 22, 2010 (LifeSiteNews.com) - "There are cases of sexual abuse that are coming to light every day against a great number of the members of the Catholic clergy. Unfortunately, we are perhaps not talking so much about individual cases but rather a collective moral crisis that the cultural history of humanity may never have known at such a frightful and concerning level. Numerous priests and religious have confessed to the crime. There is no doubt that the thousands of cases that have come to be known to the authorities represent only a small fraction of the true number, since many molesters have been covered and hidden by the hierarchy."
Although the above quote could have appeared in any number of editorials in recent weeks, the statement was made by Nazi propaganda chief Joseph Goebbels in 1937, according to Italian journalist Massimo Introvigne.
In an article published recently for Avvenire, the newspaper of the Italian Catholic bishops' conference, Introvigne says that Goebbels launched a fierce smear campaign against the Catholic Church following its condemnation of the Nazi regime that same year, attempting to convince the public that the Catholic priesthood was filled with child sex abusers.
Introvigne says that Goebbels' campaign followed the same pattern seen in recent media attacks on the Church. Although it was based on a few real cases that had come to light in 1936, and far fewer that the number of cases currently being discussed from mostly the 1960s and 70s, it exaggerated their extent and attempted to revive them after they had already been resolved, in an attempt to discredit Catholics.
"The cases, which were few, but real, produced a very strong reaction from the episcopate," writes Introvigne. "On June 2, 1936, the Bishop of Münster - Blessed Clemens August von Galen (1878-1946), who was the soul of Catholic resistance to Nazism, and who was beatified in 2005 by Benedict XVI - had a declaration read at all the Sunday Masses in which he expressed 'pain and sadness' for these 'abominable crimes' that "cover our Holy Church with ignominy.'"
The German episcopate soon after published a condemnation of the perpetrators, and implemented what Introvigne called "severe measures" to prevent future crimes. The bishops privately pointed out that the Hitler Youth and the schools had a far bigger problem with child sex abuse.
However, in March of 1937, the Nazis growing conflict with the Catholic Church came to a head, with the publication of the papal letter "Mit Brennender Sorge" (With Burning Concern), which was smuggled into the Riech and read from the pulpit of every Catholic parish. In it, Pope Pius XI condemned both the behavior and the philosophy of the Nazis in unequivocal terms, and defended the Church's Jewish heritage against Hitler's racist attacks.
Goebbels responded by reviving the charges of sex abuse against Catholic priests, and created new ones, according to Introvigne, who writes that "It was the anti-Nazi encyclical of Pius XI that led to the great campaign of 1937. [German Jesuit priest Walter] Mariaux proved it publishing highly detailed instructions sent by Goebbels to the Gestapo, the political police of the Third Reich, and above all to journalists, just a few days after the publication of Mit Brennender Sorge, inviting them to 'reopen' the cases from 1936 and also older cases, constantly recalling them to public opinion."
"Goebbels also ordered the Gestapo to find witnesses willing to accuse a certain number of priests, threatening them with immediate arrest if they didn't collaborate, even if they were children," he adds.
However, Introvigne writes that Fr. Mariaux published the confidential documents he had discovered in a two volume work in Spanish and English, which detailed the Nazis' attack on the Catholic Church, thus discrediting it.
"Thanks to the courage of Canaris and his friends, and to the persistence of the Jesuit detective Mariaux, the truth was already out during the war," notes Introvigne.
"The wickedness of the campaign of Goebbels aroused more indignation than the eventual guilt of some religious. The father of all moral panics in the area of pedophile priests blew up in the hands of the Nazi propagandists who had tried to organize it."
Related Links
Goebbels and the pedophile priests operation (English version)
http://www.cesnur.org/2010/mi-goebbels_en.html
Goebbels e l'operazione preti pedofili (Italian version)
http://www.cesnur.org/2010/mi-goebbels.html
Mit Brennender Sorge (With Burning Concern), Pope Pius XI, March 14, 1937
http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/pius_xi/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-xi_enc_14031937_mit-brennender-sorge_en.html
Ping!
I don’t think all preists are pedos, nor do I think that the church condones such crimes. However, I do wonder why the church handles these situations so slowly and so terribly!?!?!? Does not make sense.
It is absolutely sick to make this implication. If the RCC had not shuffled around its pedo priests, sending them to new parishes; if the RCC had not covered up the problem for so many years; if the RCC had not made the victims feel like it was THEIR fault, then the Nazis would not have had anything to criticize.
SnakeDoc
The more things change...
I wonder if our modern day national socialist sympathizing “journalists” will learn the lesson of history? Of course not. Even if they know the history, they don’t believe that history applies to them (cf socialism will work if we just try it again with their people in charge).
No, the implication is that modern journalists are doing the same thing as the Nazi journalists, namely distorting the facts, re-hashing old cases that have long been dealt with, ignoring that the Church handles these better now, ignoring that the pedophile problem is no worse in the Church than in other organizations, etc.
But hey, hyperbole is fun, esp on a Friday, so have at it!
If that upsets you, then the following events, caught on videotape and taking place right now across the US, should really make you mad.
Another Undercover Video Shows Kentucky Abortuary Failing to Report Child Sex Abuse
And if you believe this problem is unique to the 0.3% of priests in the Catholic Church, then open your eyes to the reality of what is going on your local school district and surrounding community.
Is Sexual Abuse a Catholic Problem Only? (Spotlights Leave Many Other Things in Darkness)
Introvigne says that Goebbels' campaign followed the same pattern seen in recent media attacks on the Church. Although it was based on a few real cases that had come to light in 1936, and far fewer that the number of cases currently being discussed from mostly the 1960s and 70s, it exaggerated their extent and attempted to revive them after they had already been resolved, in an attempt to discredit Catholics.
*************************
Thanks for posting this, NYer.
Yes, it does makes sense. The Church handled these problems about as badly as most organizations do. It’s made of people, and people are flawed.
It actually does better now, too, unlike many organizations the LSM hasn’t targeted who therefor ignore the problem.
I have posted before that I think the RCC priests are by and large good men who do a lot of good.
That said, the truth is the Nazis of old and the anti-Catholics of today couldn’t be getting all this leverage out of this issue if the RC hierarchy hadn’t handled the abuse and allegations so poorly.
For too long, the Church thought it could hide its corruption and intimidate secular authorities. Now that these perversions have been exposed, housecleaning is FINALLY taking place. The high-hat wearers can no longer hide their malfeasance in the 21st century, nor are they as powerful in shutting people up.
Any Catholic who denies the above mentioned corruption and perversion is either blind or stupid, and made even more foolish when they parrot the high-hats line that they are being "persecuted." Welcome the the 21st century, padres!
WOW!
Gee, it would be a lot easier to not have its priests being accused of being pedophiles if they actually worked to get rid of the ones that were. Just a thought....
Good point!
“The implication is that if ANYONE criticizes the way the RCC handles its pedo priests, they are just like the Nazis.
It is absolutely sick to make this implication”
Exactly. Playing the Nazi card over this issue is pathetic and transparent.
But what the church did was bad too .. .shuffling around priests to different parishes, threatening the victims to keep quiet, etc.
The vast majority of priests are moral people and it only takes a few to tar everyone. Nevertheless, the not too subtle attempt to associate critics of the institutional failure of the Roman Catholic Church to do more to rid herself of these pedophiles with Nazis is more than pathetic. It is disgraceful.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.