Posted on 06/29/2015 10:58:41 AM PDT by Slings and Arrows
a song can be anything...except boring.
Agreed 100%.
There is a formula that creates a need for the listener to hear what is coming next. A build up that teases a conclusion is coming but may get delayed, layered again until you run out of “OUTS” and then explode while simultaneously reinforcing the original back beat that got the whole thing started.
Just a thought
Raw vocals are the best instrument.
Always unique.
Again, interesting. I generally see a song as an exercise in storytelling. (Not that the two are mutually exclusive.)
Could you please suggest a song or songs constructed in the manner you describe?
Thanks again!
El-BUMP-O
You’re welcome.
Wow.
My tastes and yours may be on different planes.
I’m not a pure metal thrasher guy. I’m more into lyrics combined with the composition that rocks. More of a punk thrasher if you will. I’m old.
When I listen, I try to pick out every aspect of the whole sound and how they are intertwined. Shifting my focus from the words to the back beat to the leads that come in and out. The transitions and how it all fits together.
From a purely technical aspect, I would suggest King Crimson’s 3 albums that included Adrian Belew.
Discipline
Beat
Three of a perfect pair
Nevermind, or mind the words, that’s up to you.
Belew is a genius that in addition to putting out his own “studio” work, he was a major influence on bands from the Talking Heads, NIN, Tool and others.
It’s difficult to point to one or more songs because I don’t know what your thinking, what sound YOU are going for.
Eddie Vedder ?
NIN ?
STP ?
Tool ?
Metallica ?
You can thrash all day and I love it or you can put your words at the fore front. There is a huge huge difference.
The best LIVE album ever, IMHO is Deep Purple’s “Made in Japan”.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=39vhEHUOBRU
Next up is the Kinks, “One for the road”
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bFC4WFytP0o&list=PLEC2199390C8A68A4
Then Pink Floyd.
But that’s just me.
On the really really raw side ?
You can hardly get more sound from a 3 piece band than this;
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QHapDS2fcFE
Slit your wrists best album?
Blind Melon, hands down.
Want to have some fun?
No band is more fun than the B-52’s, and they are/were actually very very technical.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jxTBYkI6wmc
Not likely your taste so I’ll step back and leave you with this remake.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ml6LmIB-hvA
I can think of songs that match the criteria that you describe - I was asking your opinion because tastes in music can be pretty subjective.
I’m really not going for any particular sound per se - I try things and see if they work, and if I like them I use them. I consider myself a songwriter rather than a performer, though - I aim to have other people play my songs, and if that ever happens they will no doubt have their own interpretations.
Thank you for the links. Oh, and the B-52’s song you linked? I had the album it was on when it first came out. On vinyl. I’m old too. ;^)
That one indeed rocked. Or better put smoked.?
I don't know if that's the best 'live' album, but it's up there for that genre, and live.
Edgar Winter Group, live, in person --- that was heavy duty. The recordings --- don't do them justice. Technical excellence.
Saw them in Dallas once, a long time ago. Memorable, and at the time I didn't like EWG recordings nearly as much as that Made in Japan album. We played the wheels off of that one.
Saw Nazareth in Dallas at the same venue as EGW (but not at the same time).
Didn't care for them in recordings all that much either, but they too in person, would really get with it. But still not quite in the same league as Edgar Winter, and the musicians he had traveling them back in those days...
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
