Skip to comments.TORA BORA REVISITED: HOW WE FAILED TO GET BIN LADEN AND WHY IT MATTERS TODAY
Posted on 11/29/2009 8:55:56 AM PST by Lurkina.n.Learnin
LETTER OF TRANSMITTAL
UNITED STATES SENATE, COMMITTEE ON FOREIGN RELATIONS, Washington, DC, November 30, 2009
DEAR COLLEAGUE: This report by the Committee majority staff is part of our continuing examination of the conflict in Afghanistan. When we went to war less than a month after the attacks of September 11, the objective was to destroy Al Qaeda and kill or capture its leader, Osama bin Laden, and other senior figures in the terrorist group and the Taliban, which had hosted them. Today, more than eight years later, we find ourselves fighting an increasingly lethal insurgency in Afghanistan and neighboring Pakistan that is led by many of those same extremists. Our inability to finish the job in late 2001 has contributed to a conflict today that endangers not just our troops and those of our allies, but the stability of a volatile and vital region. This report relies on new and existing information to explore the consequences of the failure to eliminate bin Laden and other extremist leaders in the hope that we can learn from the mistakes of the past. Sincerely,
JOHN F. KERRY, Chairman
(Excerpt) Read more at foreign.senate.gov ...
Didn’t JF’nK serve in VietNam?
Isn’t the lesson of Viet Nam to not snatch Defeat from the jaws of Victory?
I’ve heard that rumor.
General Tommy Franks was right. In his book he described how the Mujahadeen used Tora Bora several times to trap Russian soldiers in a killing zone. This was the same trap. Proof? The Afghanistans themselves were recalcitrant to move on Tora Bora; waiting 12 hours for the Al Queda & Taliban there to realize the trap was known, and to pull out.
Wonder how the left would be spinning it today if we had charged into a historically known trap and lost hundreds of soldiers.
I’m just wondering does he have a report on how his treasonous activities and meetings with the communist North Vietnamese in Paris prolonged the Vietnam war...
And then how his party’s cut off of aid to our ally allowed the North Vietnamese to break the peace and destroy South Vietnam?
Taking advice from this leftist idiot is the last thing we should do.
It seems unlikely Bin Laden is the driving force behind the Taliban or Al Queda today. I’d rather have gotten him, but no reason to believe there would be no Taliban problem today if we had.
I bet a lot of fools hearing this report think we have always had the current situation in Afghanistan. Not realizing GWB took that country from the Taliban with minimal US casualties.
So then based on this report, when is Obama launching an all out, no holds barred final offensive against Al Queda in Pakistan, Iran and Somalia?
I’m thinking we should rig a parachute to a swift boat, put John Kerry in it, drop it over Tora Bora, and let him show us the proper way.
Just in time for Obama’s speech on Tuesday. It was Bush’s fault. Obama inherited the Afghan war from Bush.
Did we not help build these tunnels and escape routes, in the 70’s?
If they were known, the word Tora Bora, should be not even used today. Various types of bombs and the most effective destructive force should have been exercised during our campaign.
The debate today shouldn't be if OBL is alive or not, but in what century would life spring forth from the ground.
This is the same Cut&Run Kerry who got out of Nam after 90 days? Great military genius.
Pray for America and Our Troops
Furthermore the notion that sending/dropping in a few thousand soldiers as blocking forces would have cut off the trails off Tora Bora is laughable.
I hate John Kerry. The release is nothing more than a blame game that Obama can use as his big speech highlight. In my mind, Kerry is angling to be the next SECDEF. It makes me sick to think of that but I’m worried that Gates will step down soon and that this buffoon will be nominated. It would be in keeping with the epic fail moves already foisted upon us by this, the worst presidency in the history of the United States.
“Instead of using U.S. forces to capture Osama bin Laden
the President outsourced the job to Afghan warlords, who let bin Laden slip away.” John Kerry.
Is this what this idiot is now saying in this report?
It’s so funny in this report: that they depend on “intelligence” that tells them “Bin Laden was there” i.e. the same methods used to confirm WMD.
Imagine getting him BEFORE 9-11. It might never have been a day we’ll never forget..
“In my mind, Kerry is angling to be the next SECDEF.”
Wow! We’re so screwed.
Tora Bora should have been nuked. PERIOD. We blew it!
Oh, so Kerry has downgraded Bin Laden and the rest to "extremists". They are no longer terrorists.
Isn't it funny how the Democrats want to have it both ways? They want to be seen as gung ho about getting Bin Laden, yet they're too squeemish to use the strongest words when speaking of him.
What a joke, I just read through the report. It reads like a political novel. Guess I’m not surprised.
Because those who make an HONEST evaluation realize that 1993 was the point of "inaction"... after the original WTC bombing.
Where were you, John Kerry(we know you were in Vietnam)before/during/after 93?
Democraps are so good at revisionist history...to pacify their failures.
This is all old news! Didn’t Whoreraldo and his brother show us years ago the exact path at Tora Bora that OBL excapet on?
If they had wanted bin Laden, they would have smoked his arse back when Clinton had several opportunities to do so.
Kerry was all over that one, huh?
Nope, this is nothing more than another failed attempt to pin the blame on the Bush-”It’s Bush’s fault”-donkey and divert from Barry inept ability to perform as Commander-in-Chief.
“On July 12, Tenet went to Capitol Hill to provide a top-secret briefing for senators about the rising threat of an imminent attack. Only a handful of senators turned up in S-407, the secure conference room in the Capitol, to hear the
CIA director warn that he was extremely worried that bin Laden and Al Qaeda were preparing an attack on U.S. soil.”
Which Senators showed John?
At any rate, contrary to Kerry’s BS rhetoric on this, capturing or killing bin Laden would not make any difference as it relates to ongoing acts of Islamic oriented fundamentalist terrorism....not a damn bit of difference.
This is Obama’s “if we fail in Afghanistan it was all Bush’s fault” strategy.
Didnt Geraldo find the box Jimmy Hoffa was buried in there?
Well it has been nearly a year since the messiah took over... where is Osama?
The rats stoop lower and become more desperate as the rot of their bankrupt ideas is exposed. The Afgan campaign was a brilliant success. We rid the country of the dreaded Taliban and Al Queda in about 2 months. Our brave men and women accomplished trememdous results with relatively little resources. The evil doers were put on the run with huge disruptions to their operations.
The idea that Al Gore, John Kerry, BHO or any other rat would have found Bin Laden is laughable. A large scale invasion of Pakistan would have been necessary. The military commanders made their best judgment on Tora Bora given the intelligance and constraints at that time. Bush did not make any stupid demands on the military. He wisely listened to their recommedations. To think that the dithering BHO would have willed a different outcome is absurd. He despises the military and the causes for which our military has been used.
I thought it was a safe not a box.
That last one looks like he is waving to Barney Frank.
One was a pure hand-over the other happened when his admin would not allow us to get him when they had him cornered.
“He overlooks Clinton’s TWO chances to get him.”
But of coarse. The timing is suspect also. Just before Zero’s speech is just a coincidenc I’m sure.
So, why did Lurch vote *against* vests for US troops? And then bitch about the lack when he accepted the nomination in 2004? And then get a free pass from the so-called journalists in attendance and not in attendance?
IMHO under Objective Ginger,,,
Killed by a Louisiana Long Rifle...(B-52)...
Sure, but to be effective it must be dropped where your target is. If the target is not there when the BLU-82 arrives , it won't be destroyed.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.