Skip to comments.Orly Taitz - Motion to Transfer Carter Case to Judge Lamberth in Washington DC
Posted on 12/26/2009 4:27:01 AM PST by Man50D
AGJ comment: we spilt the Motion up into the key parts so our readers could quickly see what Orly is asking Judge Carter to agree to.
AGJ comment: The US Attorneys representing Obama said Carter could not hear the case BECAUSE of Jurisdiction. They maintained that only a court in Washington DC could hear the case because Obama resided in Washington. Orly agreed! Wow!
AGJ comment: Bottom line, Orly made a brilliant move. By agreeing to what Obamas Attorneys argued for they cannot now go back on their request. Orly in effect called their bluff. Now the case should rightfully move to Washington DC. If Judge Carter tries to deny the Motion he will lose complete credibility with the court and be subject to appeal If Carter rules in favor of the Motion it is an important win for our side Obama is still in the hot seat and Orly deserves a lot of credit for hanging in there In our humble opinion.
One Response to Orly Taitz - Motion to Transfer Carter Case to Judge Lamberth in Washington DC
1. French Canadian Says: December 26th, 2009 at 3:34 am
Go Orly, go! This is one tenacious woman!
Victory belongs to the most persevering. Napoleon Bonaparte.
Fear... yeah that's good, Lets all be afraid... just like Patrick Henry and the signers of the Declaration of Independence. /sarc
I've been here at Free Republic since 1997 ... I've noticed a definite change... now we're overrun by "Fearful" posters who love to complain but haven't the cojones to fight for principle or even their liberty.
Hey.. why don't YOU go for it... Dentist! /sarc
BIG TALK is so cheap... Quitters always are full of big talk.
Hmmm another one... yeah, just sit down and so nothing. "Useless" causes are always considered a waste of time by the human breed of sheep. Yeah... our Liberty is being dismantled completely... "Oh woe is me. /sarc
Pending replies from actual lawyers I will offer that this will likely go nowhere.
From memory, Orly's ability to file additional motions was cut off five days before the Oct 5 hearing, and the case was dismissed “with prejudice” meaning don't even try to file another motion with the court on this case...go directly to an appeal or to another court.
Orly's case was dismissed for lack of jurisdiction, including failure to state a claim that the court can remedy and failure to complete service timely (before inauguration). All of this would still be true in DC except for the quo warranto part.
Orly is misleading the bench intentionally or unintentionally when she claims that the defense argued that DC was the correct jurisdiction for this case. DOJ argured that DC was the correct venue for quo warranto, but argued that quo warranto didn't apply to the POTUS.
Judge Carter disagreed in his ruling and said that DC actually was the correct venue for quo warranto for the POTUS, which made D’Onofrio’s day.
To me this means that Orly's motion here is pointless and her correct action is to re-file from scratch in DC for quo warranto with only the candidates who were on the ballot with Obama as plaintiffs and without including any of the other issues that are still on appeal by Kreep in CA. For Orly to try to get DC Circuit to re-litigate the non-quo warranto part of the case with all of the military plaintifs all over on a transfer would appear to be blatant forum shopping.
I'm asking serious questions and you're going drama queen. Is this your first day? Have you been following the Orly saga? "Quitters"?
I admit there is a bit of the theatrical in Orly vs obama. The plucky, winsome Russian dentist/lawyer fighting for the Constitution against obama and the evil Chicago Machine, but the reality is quite serious.
No one wants to know the real obama story more than I do, where ever he was born or who is parents really are and the many details of his scholastic trail. Despite the demonrat's effort to mischaracterize it as folly, I see it as very serious and it doesn't distract me from the other serious obama/demonrat schemes underway. I can multitask. This is serious enough all by itself to not give up on it. But...Orly? Have you ever thought that we've already seen her best game?
BTW, has it yet occurred to you that the current oval office sitter is using an alias while holding office? His last legal, known name was Barry Soetoro ... and he has several social security numbers in his current alias. Which one would you like to address?
Lets assume, or in my case, believe and agree that obama is hiding something or a whole lot of somethings, so our need to know is great and even Constitutional, but his keeping himself out of the courts is a paramount personal priority.
Given Orly's performance in and out of the courtroom to date, who is she helping more? Her clients and our cause or obama and his? Can't help being a bit suspicious.
In this case I'd suggest that Orly break down and read a legal textbook some time. There is no case to transfer to Judge Lambeth or any other judge. There was a case, Taits argued it, and she lost. Asking for a change in venue after you have lost your case is a bit late. Her next destination is an appeals court, not asking Carter to void his decision and sent the case elsewhere.
Ping to Orly’s latest comical endeavor.
This Non-Sequitur person you are corresponding with has ABSOLUTELY NO REGARD for TRUTH or INTEGRITY ! He has NO LIFE and spends the majority of his free time sending these comments in a diabolical effort to discourage the faithful.
He is ubdoubtedly the UGLIEST troll on FR, just so you know...best thing to do it IGNORE him, as foolishly persitent as he is !
In spite of all the nonsensical filings by Taitz since that date, all of which have been rejected, it's still dead, dead, dead.
She can file an appeal, but she doesn't want to, since that's so dull, and won't get her any headlines, media face time, blog posts or money in her Paypal account.
There's nothing to be transferred to DC, except for a dead corpse.
Anyone who believes otherwise is as delusional as Taitz.
Ping to an Orly Taitz whack-a-mole thread. Orly is so much fun!
Orly’s just jealous because Donofrio and Pidgeon have a legitimate client (with standing) and are getting face time and serious consideration on the legal/bankruptcy blogs. She can’t stand not to be the center of attention.
If it weren't for Orly and Kreep, D’Onofrio wouldn't have gotten his confirmation from Judge Carter (refuting DOJ) that the POTUS is subject to quo warranto in the DC Circuit!
Taitz and Kreep’s case in CA was most assuredly _not_ a pointless exercise for this reason alone. Also the DOJ quo warranto defense of Obama (claiming it did not apply) was flushed out. Thank you Orly for that!
Orly strikes me as being bipolar with delusions, but these folks can change the world with their fearlessness even if they personally fail. No one has done more to put the issue of potential holes in Obama’s eligibility before the public.
Because she's an inexperienced lawyer, she's on Barry's side? Other, more experienced lawyer's have gotten no further than she has...to date. Are they all on Barry's side because they have fared no better...to date? Remember, it took a bit more than two years before Watergate forced Nixon to resign. I support all who are attempting to expose the usurper.
People all up in arms about his birth certificate"
Exposing a usurper is never a useless cause.
His father was a foreign national who passed his foreign citizenship on to his son. Assuming Barry was born in HI (yet to be proven), he was born a dual national. A citizen, at birth, of two countries. There's no way the framers intent for the NBC requirement for the Commander in Chief was to allow (post grandfather clause), a citizen of two nations...at birth, to be considered a Natural Born Citizen of these United States.
He's a usurper. He has zero Presidential authority to sign anything, or Command the armed forces to do anything.
The above links are must reading for anyone who wants to know about Orly Taitz...as far as Im concerned the whole batch is nuts
Orly's got the failure part down pat.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.