Michael Schiavo Larry King Live

CNN Live ^ | 10-24-03 | Larry King

[ruoflaw]

Maybe your friend is just gullible but that would not explain why your friend would think it is ok to starve someone to death! (I didn't see any evidence presented did you?)

[Theodore R.]

It is so easy for the American liberal community to sit back and recommend dehydration and starvation for the less fortunate. People like Eleanor Clift and Janet Reno fit this temperament. Of course if the starvation and dehydration were for one of their fellow liberals, all hell would break lose, and the liberal hypocrisy would be so apparent than even most gullible Americans could understand it.

[Theodore R.]

Is it possible that this Sheriff Rice, a friend of George W. Greer, could be denied renomination in the next Republican primary for sheriff in Pinellas Co.? Of course, who would consider taking the sheriff on in a primary? Will that primary be in 2004 or 2006?

[ruoflaw]

I agree with you...if it was someone that they cared about, they would have it in front and center in the newspapers and on TV and on 60min. I cannot get over all the people that show up and protest the execution of a death row inmate but they think it is ok to execute Terri.

[TaxRelief]

Thank you, well explained, PC!

[pc93]

Part II

Michael Schiavo went into some detail on Larry King describing the circumstances of the injury which caused Terri to be in her present state. Michael claimed that he woke up in the middle of the night, then heard a loud thud. He went out into the hall, he said, and saw Terri lying in the hallway. She was, he said, unconscious. Michael then stated that he called Terri's brother Bobby, who lived in the same apartment complex as Terri and Michael. He then said that Bobby told him to call 911 and that he would come over. Michael claimed that he was holding Terri in his arms when Bobby arrived. The paramedics arrived a short time later and began to try to revive her. I asked the Schindlers how his account meshed with what they knew happened at the time.

Bob Schindler replied "that isn't what happened at all. What happened was that Michael called us first, and I answered the phone. He told me that Terri had collapsed and was unconscious. I told him to call 911. Then I called Bobby and told him to get over there. I said 'something's going on over there, get over there right now.'" Bob also said that Michael's claim that he was holding Terri in his arms was untrue. "When Bobby arrived at their place," Bob explained, "he found Terri lying face down in the hallway, with her feet over the threshold of the doorway, as though she had been coming out of the bedroom. Her hands were clutched around her throat, and her breathing was gurgling. Michael was sitting on the couch in the living room; he was a total basket case."

Michael also said on "Larry King Live" that Terri was bulimic prior to that night, and that her bulimia was possibly the cause of the potassium imbalance which was discovered when she was in the hospital. Bob & Mary also find this assertion incredible. Bob's reaction was "Poppycock!" Terri, they said, was quite healthy and had a healthy appetite prior to her injury. None of her friends or family ever saw any signs of any eating disorder, and there was no medical evidence of it found in her examinations.

This "potassium imbalance" is frequently touted as the explanation of what caused Terri's collapse. But it is an explanation that explains nothing. Indeed, doctors for the Schindlers testified in court, and reiterated at their news conference last Friday (October 24, 2003) that the potassium imbalance was only detected after she was brought to the hospital. This is after the paramedics had been working on her to revive her. Part of such treatment is the injection of various drugs and electrolytes to try to stimulate the heart. These injections were very likely the cause of the potassium imbalance. The potassium imbalance was an effect of her collapse and subsequent treatment, and not the cause of anything.

Terri's heart stopped for several minutes that night, and that stoppage caused the brain damage that led to her current condition. It is frequently asserted in press accounts that Terri had a "heart attack." This too is false. There was no heart attack, and again, doctors have testified to that effect. A heart attack causes the release of certain enzymes into the bloodstream. These enzymes are readily discovered in tests and are used as the "markers" of a heart attack. No such enzymes were found in Terri's bloodstream, nor any other evidence of a heart attack. Terri's heart was and is quite healthy: there was no heart attack.

So what happened to cause Terri to lose consciousness? No one is sure, because there was never a proper investigation. The Schindlers do not accept Michael's version of what happened to Terri. Also, Bob related, "it's in the medical record that when Terri was brought into the hospital she had bruises around her neck." Doctors for the Schindlers have testified that those bruises were consistent with manual strangulation. Furthermore, skull x-rays and head CT scans done about a year after her injury indicated fractures to the occipital region which have never been explained. These fractures are consistent with trauma to the head.

The theory that Terri was strangled gains plausibility when one considers that friends and siblings of Terri's testified that they were aware that Michael had abused Terri prior to the night of her injury. Bob & Mary were not aware of this themselves before Terri's injury. "I found out afterwards," Bob said, "that they [Terri's friends and brother] had been keeping that from me." But, Bob, explained, Terri's best friend, Jackie Rhoades, testified at the 1996 guardianship hearing that she knew Terri was being abused, that she frequently saw her with bruises on her arms and legs, and that Terri was afraid of Michael. Jackie further stated that Terri intended to divorce Michael, and that she and Terri were making plans to do that. Terri's brother Bobby also testified to his knowledge of Terri's abuse, and corroborated much of Jackie's testimony.

These allegations and the evidence behind them have been brought to court in the Schindlers' suits to have Michael removed as guardian, but have never been properly investigated. Judge Greer dismissed these allegations with a wave of his judicial wand, saying that "it would be interesting to know what happened," but that it was "irrelevant to this case." Judge Greer disregarded Jackie's and Bobby's testimony, saying that it was hearsay. That ruling will prove to be interesting in light of the judge's ruling regarding other secondhand testimony in this case.

On the Larry King Show, Michael also contended that he was not after Terri's settlement money. As evidence of this he said that he had offered three times to give that money to charity. Bob and Mary Schindler confirm that he did make such an offer, but only once. During the first effort to remove Terri's feeding tube, in 1998, the Schindlers received a letter from Michael's lawyer George Felos containing the offer. But that offer, they explained, was contingent on their agreement to remove Terri's feeding tube. "He said he'd give the money away if I agreed to kill my daughter," Bob explained. He added that the letter stipulated that the offer to give the money away was off the table after 10 days.

Why, I asked, did Michael make such an odd proposal? "Well, that's interesting," Bob answered. "See, the court appointed a guardian ad litem to determine Michael's fitness as guardian. His name was Richard Pierce. Pierce said that Michael had a conflict of interest as guardian because he stood to inherit the money in Terri's fund if Terri died. Pierce said that Michael couldn't be impartial in his decisions." "So," Bob continued, "that offer and the letter was Felos' attempt to remove the appearance of conflict."

Mr. Pierce, in his role as guardian ad litem, also found that Michael's testimony regarding Terri's purported wish not to live if she required artificial support was "not credible." So what happened to the perspicacious Mr. Pierce, as a result of his observing Michael's obvious conflict of interest and the flimsiness of his story regarding Terri's wishes? He was replaced as guardian ad litem by Judge Greer, at Felos' request.

Michael has repeatedly asserted that he so doggedly pursues Terri's death because he is trying to "honor her wishes", because he loves her. Michael asserts that he heard Terri voice this wish while watching a television show that involved a person in a vegetative state. I asked Bob & Mary about this "wish" of Terri's. "She never said anything like that", Mary answered. "Not to any of us." When was the first time you ever heard about this wish, I asked. "It was in 1998," Bob replied, "during the first trial" [to remove Terri's feeding tube]. "We never heard anything about that before." The reader will recall that Michael had an opportunity to explain that "wish" during the 1993 court proceedings, but for some reason did not.

But, I asked, Michael said that his story has been corroborated. And some defenders of Michael emphasize that the court found his testimony "clear and convincing". What about that? "What the court found so convincing," Bob replied, "was that Michael brought out his brother and sister-in-law, and they corroborated him. And Felos brought them out at the last minute, shortly before the trial. They weren't on the original witness list. Felos blindsided us."

I was, frankly, astonished. I'm no lawyer, but I know enough to find that somewhat irregular. Didn't your lawyer object? I asked. "Oh, yeah, Bob said. "She objected all over the place. They weren't on the witness list, and they were never deposed before the trial, but the judge allowed them in."

You'll recall that Judge Greer disallowed the testimony of Jackie Rhoades and Bobby Schindler regarding Terri's abuse, because it was hearsay. But Michael's testimony, and that of his never-deposed brother and sister-in-law, were allowed in, and found "clear and convincing". It would seem that in Judge Greer's courtroom, some kinds of hearsay are more convincing than others.

Michael has repeatedly avowed his continuing love for Terri. He did so again on "Larry King Live". Bob & Mary find his love of a rather strange variety. "If he loved her so much," Mary said, "he could start by keeping his marriage vows to her," obviously referring to Michael's live-in girlfriend, with whom he has fathered two children. Furthermore, they find his protestations of love unbelievable in light of his almost total neglect of her. "In the beginning he used to visit her a lot," Mary told me. "But after '93, he visited less and less often."

Bob related that while he was still working [he is now retired], he used to visit Terri at the nursing home "once or twice a week" on his way home from work. He and Mary, he added, visited Terri together on the weekends. "We never saw him at the nursing home," Mary said, "and he was never listed on the sign-in sheet."

Nursing home staff complained to the Schindlers that they could never reach Michael. "They needed to talk to him about things concerning her care," Bob said. "But they'd leave messages and he didn't call back." The director of Terri's second nursing home, David Cross, testified in the 1996 guardianship hearing that he "had a difficult time" with Michael. The state, Bob explained to me, requires that nursing home administrators have monthly meetings with family representatives regarding patient care. Mr. Cross testified that Michael never asked for or came to such meetings, and that created problems for the nursing home's compliance with the law. Cross also testified that Michael never made arrangements for state-required annual physicals either, forcing the nursing home to arrange them itself.

Bob and Mary assert that since 2000, Michael has rarely visited Terri. "The only time he visits Terri," Bob said, "is when a hearing is coming up, and then Felos stages a visit so Michael can say in court that he visited her recently."

I wondered if Michael didn't visit Terri because he feels like he has "moved on" with his life. Larry King asked Michael why he didn't just move on, why he didn't just divorce Terri and marry his girlfriend. Michael said that he's "content with the way things are," with his girlfriend. He told Larry he had no plans to marry her.

"Right," Bob said. "He said under oath at the 2000 trial that as soon as Terri died, he would marry his girlfriend."



posted by Fr. Rob 10:53 AM

[fly_so_free]

Lots of good infromation on post 2106 bump

[TaxRelief]

The Schindler's side of the story!

Read Father Rob's conversation with Bob Schindler after
the Larry King Live interview of Michael Schiavo.

Ping for Terri!

If you have time, please help us get this out to message boards everywhere! Or email your friends. You can copy it from pc93's posts above or from the link.



(Please let me know if you want on or off my Terri ping list.)

[sweetliberty]

I am going to TRY and finish reading this thread today. Between interruptions, being tired much of the time and WORK (I hate when work intereferes with my FReeping), I'm not even halfway through it yet, and there are a lot of good posts here.

[cyn]

http://www.pinellascounty.org/PDF/HistOfBCC.pdf -- History Pinellas Cty Bd Cty comm -- p 95/109 of PDF

INFO ON GEORGE GREER as PC County Commissioner

-----(text:)-----
"George Greer was elected to the Board of County Commissioners in 1984 when he defeated Gabriel Cazares, a Democrat. In Greer’s announcement for the campaign, in a story by Howeard French in the Clearwater sun, June 28, 1984, Greer said, “We must make our beaches more acessible to our citizens. We do not need fencnes around public parks.” This was a project he found important to a growing number of leisure-time athletes, of which he was one.

A runner of marathons, Greer was responsible for planning a run by county officials and others to mark the end of Pinellas County’s 75th year Diamond Jubilee Celebration. He personally carried the torch for the first mile.

Greer was born in New York City in 1942, moving with his parents to Pinellas County in 1946. He received his law degree from the University of Floridy in 1966 and practiced law in Clearwater.

Very early in his term as commissioner, Greer recorded his anti-stadium stand. In a story by Kelly Carson in the Clearwater sun, Nov. 28, 1984, Greer said, “I would love to see a stadium, but not with public money . . .If we could find something that everyone [on the commission] supports, it would be a 5 - 0 vote, no question.” Greer served as chairman of the commission in 1987 and 1992. In 1992 he retired from his position as county commissioner. He successfully ran and won a seat on the Pinellas-Pasco Circuit Court Bench."
------(end)------

Note -- In most of these bios party affiliation must be inferred -- but here, we read that he defeated a (one-term w/longer bio, fwiw, p 93) Democrat.

Greer’s bio includes no info on his memberships or community involvement, rather takes space with two newspaper quotes. Note: He was elected to two terms.

I pray that Judge Greer does good for Terri now despite his very bad decisions over the years.
May he be blessed with godly, Solomon-like wisdom and the courage to do the right thing for Terri.
May Terri be finally get her advocate and be restored to her family.

Thanks and prayers for all who are working for Terri’s good.

[cyn]

from post 1092 Pt 1 Fr. Rob's http://www.thrownback.blogspot.com/ :

I would add that this was not the last of Michael's attempts to cause Terri's death by denying medication for perfectly treatable ailments. When Terri developed pneumonia earlier this year, Michael's attorney George Felos asked the judge if medication could be denied to Terri for the pneumonia. He wanted her to be removed from the hospital, returned to the hospice, and "allowed" to die "naturally".

Fortunately, even Judge Greer thought this beyond the pale and ordered her treatment continued.

[sweetliberty]

" to his hatred for the Schiavo's"

" to his hatred for the Schiavo's Schindlers

(I think that was what you meant to say ;-)

[sweetliberty]

" I was shocked at his lack of respect for her privacy!"

I think his only reason for mentioning it was to try and make Terri repugnant to listeners. I know that sounds awful, but I think it was part of the script and that was exactly the purpose for which it was designed. Felos is into mind games and psychological manipulation. I don't think the HINO came up with that on his own.

[Saundra Duffy]

Thanks for posting Part II of the report. VERY INTERESTING!!

[sweetliberty]

"Isn't "whattya think about living with a g-tube" the question everyone immediately asks after they propose?"

I was engaged at 25 as well. When I was first married, we would get these calls from funeral directors (?) trying to sell us cemetary plots. I used to tell them I was just married and thinking about having babies.....give me a break. I finally got where I'd just hang up on them. Never once did my husband and I discuss life support or feeding tubes or any thing like that. Even when my grandmother, who was living with us at the time, had her second stroke and a decision had to be made about life support, he left the decision completely with me.

You're right, this is NOT something young people think about or discuss. Yeah, perhaps in passing, as in watching a movie or TV show, but I hardly think that casual (and I might add, entirely emotional) remarks are legally binding...well, at least until Felos and Greer decided to take it upon themselves to make them so.

[sweetliberty]

"Wouldn't they be afraid that he might cause their deaths?"

"Wouldn't they be afraid that he might cause their deaths help them die?"

[sweetliberty]

"He's an old hat at removing sick people from his life."

His "wife" isn't sick....just inconvenient.

[sweetliberty]

"Has there been any serious confirmation of these rumors of spousal abuse on his part?"

It appears that corroborating testimony that Michael abused Terri was given at one of the hearings to dismiss Michael as guardian due to conflicts of interests. Judge Greer dismissed it as heasay, an interesting action especially given that Judge Greer's rulings in this case have been almost entirely based on the flimsy hearsay testimony of Michael's brother and sister-in-law which was allowed in at the last minute unbeknownst to and under the protests of the Schindlers' attorney.

EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW - Schindlers Respond to Michael Schiavo's Larry King Love-Fest - PART 2

[sweetliberty]

"Why did it give Michael power?!"

Because Judge Greer, no doubt under advisement of his death guru, Felos, SAID it did. Don't you know by now that judges are the self-appointed proxies for God these days?

[sweetliberty]

"Lets hope he does MSNBC and Fox, he will feel a very tight noose when he's through."

I have a hunch that after the HINO's abysmal performance on Larry King , that Felos will be seeing his career flash before his eyes and will be keeping Michael on a real short leash while trying to run damage control.