Fredipedia: The Definitive Fred Thompson Reference
Please FReepmail jellybean if you want on/off this list. WARNING: This ping list is EXTREMELY active.
Posted on 05/16/2007 3:05:15 PM PDT by Squidpup
Those Who Cannot Remember the Past
If you went to college in the sixties, like I did, you might not know how much higher education has changed since then. Universities today are different places. At Vanderbilt, where I got my law degree, I hear you can take courses in third wave feminism or colonial governmentality.
Your guess is as good as mine.
On the other hand, some of the courses that we took for granted aren't around at all. One area of study that's almost disappeared from universities today is military history -- the history of warfare.
I was reminded of this recently, reading a piece in The New Republic by historian David Bell. He's certainly not the only person to mourn this change, though. One of my favorite historians, Victor Davis Hanson, wrote on the same subject several years ago in National Review.
There are a number of reasons that military history is no longer taught. Partly, it has to do with the ideological shift in university faculties over the past few decades. The post-Vietnam anti-war movement tends to see all wars as mutual mistakes -- with both sides in a conflict equally wrong. Some of these folks think war can be avoided by refusing to have anything to do with it.
Hansen thinks it also has something to do with the spread of nuclear weapons during the Cold War. In an age with intercontinental ballistic missiles, the old subjects of strategy and tactics can seem obsolete. The importance of battles at Valley Forge or the Alamo might not be evident if you're thinking of warfare in terms only of pushing big red buttons.
The enemies of civilization, though, have adapted -- as they always do. Nuclear deterrence won't protect you if the other side thinks they win if we all die together. Furthermore, they've learned to hide among the innocent. Iran's missiles, nestled among civilian neighborhoods and UN outposts in Lebanon, were fired into Israel -- but Iran was never hit back. The British and the Spanish have discovered, through terrorist attacks on bus and train lines, that the enemy is studying us daily. They learn our every weakness by living and working among us – but our schools have stopped offering courses that would help us meet their challenge.
All of this means that if there were ever a time to put our best minds to the study of warfare, it is now. I know that, for many people, it's an unpleasant topic they would just as soon avoid -- but history that ignores the importance of warfare is not history. There is a reason that both sides in the Civil War studied Sun Tzu’s “Art of War” – though it was written in the 5th or 6th Century BC.
Hansen writes, "The hundred years of talking about slavery was not as important as two days at Gettysburg. The success or failure of Normandy affected Hitler more in an hour than had years of pleading with him in the 1930s."
If for no other reason than that we want to avoid war whenever we can, universities should at least offer the option of studying it. We know that students would sign up for the classes, because books on the subject are always reliable sellers. Television programmers have also responded to the sizable hunger for military history.
These alternate sources of information are important, but they don't replace the need for serious scholarship in our universities. If you agree, I have a suggestion.
One thing we know for sure about colleges, they're better than bill collectors at tracking you down. If you ever took a single class, you'll be asked for contributions the rest of your life. Next time you get one of those calls, ask that student fundraiser to pass on the message that you'd probably give more money to the old alma mater if the school were offering more classes in military history. It's worth a try, anyway.
Man, ain't that the truth. I like the idea of a President who reads (and quotes) Victor Davis Hansen. Go Fred!
Lol, ain't that the truth!
Bookmark this: link to the "FRED" keyword list on FreeRepublic
Fantastic FRED!
What’s the quote? (paraphrasing):
“Those societies that fail to study military history will be destroyed by those that do.”
Thompson’s gotta run. I like what I read every time.
Every time I read or hear something from Fred, I am again reminded of the greatness of this nation...............
So, when’s the announcement? *ducking*
Congressman Billybob
Latest article: "Jeffrey Has Escaped, and Other Tales of Divorce"
Apparently Fred didn’t learn during his college days in the 60’s that folk songs are all that is needed for us to defend ourselves against those who wish us harm.
- Tom Lehrer
this is the same logic used for war games that the military engages in.
i have posted all the FDT websites that i can find on my profile page. Please let me know if i have missed some and i will add them.
Yup and
“We are the folk song Army
Everyone one of us cares
We all hate poverty war and injustice
Unlike the rest of you squares”
“There are innocuous folk songs yeah
But we regard them with scorn
The folks who write them have no social concience
Why they don’t even care if Jimmy Cracked Corn”
:)
Yea, those revolutionaries could have used some global warming back in the day.
Fredipedia: The Definitive Fred Thompson Reference
Please FReepmail jellybean if you want on/off this list. WARNING: This ping list is EXTREMELY active.
"Remember the war against Franco,
That's one where each one of us belongs.
They may have won all the battles
But we had all the good songs!"
Boy did ol' Tom ever hit the nail on the head.
My daughter's a freshman at college, and somebody was playing "Poisoning Pigeons in the Park", and she remarked, "I remember my parents playing that when I was little."
"That explains a lot," said somebody. < g >
there were 2 battles in the area of Valley Forge- June 28 at Monmouth Courthouse. Another At Germantown in OCT.
The history lesson is about leadership at Valley Forge
” Nuclear deterrence won’t protect you if the other side thinks they win if we all die together.’
Ger this man an Oval Office!
and a chasid too????
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.