Skip to comments.Demsí Plan B disintegrates: Bill to reverse Hobby Lobby ruling canít clear filibuster
Posted on 07/16/2014 12:57:54 PM PDT by jazusamo
Senate Democrats effort to reverse the Supreme Courts Hobby Lobby ruling on birth control could not overcome a Republican filibuster Wednesday, exposing the partisan divide over how to balance womens health rights with religious liberty ahead of Novembers congressional contests.
The chambers 56-43 vote was not enough to green-light the Not My Boss Business Act for final consideration, even though Republicans Sens. Susan Collins of Maine, Mark Kirk of Illinois and Lisa Murkowski of Alaska broke party ranks and voted to put the bill on the floor.
Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, Nevada Democrat, changed his vote to no at the last minute so he could once more bring up the bill, which would require corporations to insure birth control or other legally mandated services when offering health plans.
Its an essential part of womens health and should be part of an employees package, and not something she has to go and add on later, Sen. Maria Cantwell, Washington Democrat, said.
The legislation authored by Democratic Sens. Patty Murray of Washington and Mark Udall of Colorado was more political than practical the Republican-led House would not have taken up the measure.
But it provided Democrats a way to woo women voters amid fears of poor turnout this fall.
The party says the bill is necessary because an all-male majority of the Supreme Court ruled owners of closely held corporations do not have to insure forms of birth control that violate their moral beliefs.
(Excerpt) Read more at washingtontimes.com ...
Collins, Kirk, Murkowski vote with Rats. Sigh
No fan of the RINOs but I suspect they voted yes to force the democrat’s hand at which point Hairy Roid voted NO.
Wasn’t Harry Reid able to invoke the “nuclear option”, to blow up the filibuster once and for all, making everything a simple majority?
Health rights? Abortion is very unhealthy for the baby.
>>>Collins, Kirk, Murkowski vote with Rats. Sigh <<<
Actually, Collinrat, Kirkrat and Murkowskirat voted with the other rats.
Nothing to be surprised at or sigh . . . these are all democrats wearing republican robes, or more correctly - wolves in sheep’s clothing.
AMEN to that.
He only did so for nominations, not for routine business.
That's why it was Plan B!
It worked perfectly. It will come up again in September after normal schedules return as an election time issue to stoke anger among the Sarah Flucke types and drive the angriest horn dogs to the polls.
Since they are discussing “Women’s Health”, how about this suggestion for preventative medicine. When you lay down cross your legs.
Harry . . . here is a simple solution, just invoke another nuclear option and make yourself and your party the sole decision making body in America . . . please, please do - and then come November, when WE are the majority we can impeach the whole lot of you including your halfrican boss. We won’t even drag it out!
Yep, doesn’t cost a cent and it’s 100% effective.
Well, not 100% effective. There was that one woman 2014 years ago.
But there are exceptions to every rule.
So true, and then in modern times there’s that dastardly toilet seat. :-)
All the RATS have anymore are stunts. Well lies and stunts.
The Religious Freedom Restoration Act, which passed the Senate 97-3 and the House unanimously, would be rendered irrelevant beyond individuals. I do not know how this would impact a privately owned business with a single owner. And who knows what would happen with state level religious freedom laws.
Avalanche of Awesome!
Now there is a big surprise with those 3. NOT!
Extremists, however, have the audacity to suggest that mothers and babies are not natural enemies.
Why do people in Washington State (and yes, it's "people", not just Cantwell) believe that executing children in their mothers' wombs is an essential part of "women's health"? I live in the state; what is about this state that makes people so... murderous?
I realize this is not - directly at least - an abortion-related measure, but it's along the same road with much the same rhetoric. Futhermore, a select few of these drugs are abortifacients and do, in fact, result in the death of a tiny human being, hence the Hobby Lobby case.
I moved here from CA (was in the military here, met a girl, and married her).
Speaking about Western Washington, from Olympia to the border: Never met meaner people anywhere. Never met more entitled and arrogant people. Silicon alley is worse, but not much worse. Between the feminists, the single parent families, the noveau-riche software and coffee plutocrats, the abortionists who are doing it all ‘for the kids’ - they are reprehensible people.
Openly anti-Semitic - they have speakers at church who talk about the brutality of the Israeli people toward Palestinians and they don’t invite anyone to counter it.
Eastern Washington? It’s the obverse of Western Washington. Good people, patriotic, and out to help each other. They will help you when you are down, but they can’t tolerate idiots.
Spokane is weird. They don’t know whether to be fish nor fowl. Gonzaga is in the heart of it, which makes for great basketball, but the social justice indoctrination will make you upchuck your Keds.
I hear you and also live here.
My only thought is that we have a large liberal population, state politics is basically run by them from King County, Seattle and Olympia.
Even though Murray and Cantwell are leftists I find it hard to believe they want abortion pills given to pro abortion baby killers along with already supplied birth control.
It’s almost like they WANT more dead babies, as though it’s a goal of theirs to kill as many human embryos as possible. It’s not good enough for them that the non-abortifacient drugs are just fine.
this is the big payback to planned parenthood. if you have to have plans that cover abortion, who does abortions? most hospitals don’t. most abortionists don’t work/have privileges at hospitals.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.