Posted on 03/14/2014 8:44:40 PM PDT by PaulCruz2016
For the girl?
He shot am intruder messing with his minor daughter, I would vote to acquit, although I doubt this goes to trial
Hey Dave
You or your kid sneak around my daughter and end up in her bedroom you are going to get your ass blown away.
No relativist argument on my part. That’s absolutely what is going to happen..
Depends on the truth if I am on the jury. It’s 2:30 in the morning, the girl lied and said she didn’t know the boy. At that point, if the boy threatened the man and the testimony reveals beyond a reasonable doubt that the man felt his life was in danger then it’s justified.
There are consequences to our decisions, and sometimes the consequences are tragic.
Terrible tragedy all the way around.
yup. plus making quick moves while a guy holds a gun on him.
a 17 year old is not a 12 year old. physically probably stronger than the dad. lot faster and more endurance.
Sneaking in is an intrusion
Leotards want to keep dropping that age too
When they turn 18 and move out they can do what they like
Actually, there IS a law against having sex with a minor. While being close in age is a defense against prosecution, that doesn’t make it legal.
Bottom line, the situation sucks all around but I’d give the father benefit of doubt under castle doctrine. It IS the father’s castle and he did disrupt illegal activity in his home involving his minor daughter.
Not guilty.
And they should pay for the ammunition, too.
The daughter denied knowing him or why he was there. Not sure love was involved.
You or your kid sneak around my daughter and end up in her bedroom you are going to get your ass blown away.
No relativist argument on my part. Thats absolutely what is going to happen
Time was when that behavior was commendable.
But that was back when the world made sense.
When a dad has a gun on you and has called the cops, you should freeze and wait for them to show.
How do you know? The daughter denied knowing him.
Good enough reason for the father to defend himself and his family when the intruder made a threatening move.
Darwin Award.
I don’t disagree with you at all re: the kid’s actions. Or perceived actions. I wonder if the dad could have intimidated the boy with words along with using his gun and dialing the police. No doubt in my mind that my dad could have. There maybe more history here than we know.
I can well see how everyone in the situation was jumpy.
But...boys’ have been sneaking into girl’s room since the beginning of time. It’s not a new thing.
“But...boys have been sneaking into girls room since the beginning of time. Its not a new thing.”
Actually I used to sneak them into my room. Because I knew their dad would not do anything if we got caught.
My perspective on the issue would have been far different (never would have tried) if I knew her Dad was going to blow me away if caught..
imho, you are above average intelligence.
One of the stories my husband told me was about going to pick up the girl he was dating before me. The girl’s dad invited him to his study...that was filled with guns. The story made me lol. He never tried anything with her. (Or so he said, lol)
I guarantee you the father did not shoot this kid in cold blood.
What you really mean is that you do not believe that he believed his daughter.
The real question is did he really believe the kid was going for a weapon. On that I have no opinion. If it was an inner city neighborhood I would probably come down on believing he did.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.