Posted on 11/16/2001 9:32:40 PM PST by Alamo-Girl
The affirmative statements in the following profile are meant to convey that the majority view on the threads are thus and so. The conditional words, such as may be or in the alternative ... are used to convey alternative views where there is not an overwhelming consensus from prior posts. At the end are the significant competing theories presented so far. This is not meant to obtain an indictment or plead a case before a jury ... it is to show the consensus additional profile information based on research done by many contributing Freepers.
The perp is here on a student VISA. He is Islamic and Middle Eastern. He may be a member of Al Queda. English is not his primary language, he may be a proficient computer user or coder especially if Al Queda.
The alternative theory is that the perp is left handed.
The 'G' and '6' as handwritten on the letters and envelopes are peculiar and perhaps indicate an arabic cursive normal usage.
He was given anthrax and perhaps more biochems – of various grades. They may have been made in Iraq – they may have been made here. He did not develop them himself. He knows lab procedures.
He is fairly diligent in handling the anthrax, but he is not perfect. He knows Dr. Malik, chairman of the Islamic Society of NJ. He may work with him. He’s been to the doctor’s office at 1542 Kuser Road in Trenton NJ. While there he accidentally infected the accountant next door at Civale Silvestri & Alfieri CPA, 1540 Kuser Road.
The perp may be from Pakistan and may have sought out Dr. Malik’s help (because he is also from Pakistan) to get employment/access to a nearby university hospital, Robert Wood Johnson University Hospital at Hamilton. Dr Malik is on the staff there. The perp may have used lab facilities in the hospital (either at Hamilton or the main campus or one of its affiliates) to safely handle or prep the different batches of anthrax.
Dr. Malik has been in the U.S. since the 70's or so and is long established here. He is probably not a party to the terrorists. However, as head of the Islamic Center of Central NJ and being from Pakistan and having made it as a doctor here ... we wonder if a newcomer to the country living in that area, attending that mosque and wanting to become a doctor ... may have asked him for a job referral or such.
There probably are other people in his cell who may already be in custody - one with Florida license plates and others from Canada.
Several arrests of Pakistani nationals were made in Trenton/Hamilton two weeks ago --some in the Greenwood Village apartments, and some at 1001 N. Olden Street. The N. Olden Street arrests took place after a witness observed a man gingerly placing letters enclosed in a ziploc bag into his car. The car had Florida license plates.
Just after the events of September 11, the FBI arrested Mohammed Pervez, a naturalized U.S. citizen of Pakistani descent. Pervez was a Jersey City roommate of Ali Ayub Kahn and Mohammed Jazweeth Azmath, suspected of being hijackers whose plans were thwarted when their plane was grounded in St. Louis. Pervez, who worked in both Trenton and Newark train stations, was also a roommate of the potential anthrax suspects detained from the Greenwood village apartments in Hamilton.
Ali Ayub Khan also listed as one of his addresses the same Chicago apartment house as Sabash Gurung is staying in with his brother. Gurung is the Nepalese who was arrested at O'Hare Airport with a large stash of weapons (knives, a stun gun, etc.). The FBI said (or implied) that the Ali Khan who lives in the same apartment house as Gurung is a different Ali Khan, that it's a coincidence of names. But this seems not to be the case -- in fact, there is a newspaper article on Khan, dated well before Gurung was in the news, which gives that Chicago address for him.
There may be a chain of infection following the medical route – like there is following the mail route.
In DelRay Beach, Florida – a pharmacist (Gregg Chatterton at Huber Healthmart Drugs) claimed to have talked to Atta and another hijacker when they came into his pharmacy with ailments last August. Mostly, we heard about Atta, who had red hands. But the other hijacker, Marwan Al-Shehhi, had symptoms of inhalation anthrax (cough) that would have required him to visit a doctor in his area. The pharmacist said that a man resembling Al-Shehhi had returned to have a prescription filled, but his name was not found in their records – leading the investigators to think he had used an alias. The pharmacist said the red hands looked like a result from washing with bleach – that it did not look like cutaneous anthrax.
In Chester PA on 11/14/01 - teams of FBI agents complete with hazmat gear and tents, broke down door(s), swabbed and seized evidence at two homes and the city hall. One house was shared by City Health Commissioner Irshad Shaikh and his brother Masood. The other was the home of city accountant Asif Kazi. They are all from Pakistan. Kazi’s wife had a prescription for Cipro. Kazi had been seen dumping a cloudy liquid and handing a silver canister to someone.
Freepers wonder if this Could he be THE Asif Kazi, or is it a very common Pakistani name?
However, the dialogue on the discussion thread is troubling:
It has a single entry under "replies". If you click it, you see a reply consisting of the original message quoted with carets, and no new text. It seems most each reply is the same, with "mustafa's" original message quoted, but no new content. One reply had the same message "mustafa" entered, but this time not quoted (no carets, it appeared to be original content), and signed by "Bharathi Kumar". (BTW almost all the names seemed to be middle-eastern types.) The next message -- a reply to "Bharathi Kumar" -- (this one by a poster named "bluess") quoted the original message, again attributing it to "mustafa".
The next message after that one again had the text in quoted format, but attributed it to ">ASHISH BHARDWAJ" -- which happens to be the same name shown as the author of the post, although the Author: field showed it in lowercase. The reply to that message had "mustafa's" message, but this time once again formatted as caretless original text, and, missing the linebreaks that the previous messages had. It was signed by "Venkat", and the Author: field showed VENKAT in uppercase.
Conjecture, for discussion:
1. It could be a series of coded messages, with the "message" part being the email address, or the author name, or perhaps there's some subtle changes in the body of the text (an extra space here or there, etc.)
2. It could be a "recruiting station", with volunteers directed to post a followup message to that thread, so that they could be contacted via email. Why do something like that? So that the "recruiter" could see who "applies" without disclosing his own identity. The contributing Freeper has heard that "no footprint" communications like that happen on Usenet; and believes there's a newsgroup dedicated to such comms. There is no way for an observer to know who the recipient is, because the message is readable to the entire world, even though only the intended recipient will know how to decipher it.
Dr. Shaikh PhD. has been the Commissioner of Health since 1994. He received his undergrad and postgraduate diplomas in Community Medicine in Pakistan. He received his Masters and PhD in Public Health from Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore. He is fellow of the Public Health Leadership Institute (PHLI). PHLI is an executive leadership program of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), and the University of California at Berkeley. Dr. Shaikh also holds a faculty appointment at the Johns Hopkins School of Public Health.
Welcome to the Johns Hopkins University Center for Civilian Biodefense Studies"...Sponsored by The Alfred P. Sloan Foundation & The Robert Wood Johnson Foundation..."
The Hopkins School of Hygiene and public health is across the street from the hospital. They do not have any labs for microbes there. They have no anthrax and neither does the hospital. This guy may be on the faculty at the School of Hygiene but there is certainly no institutional support for terrorist activites. The former Dean of that school, Henderson, was the one who wiped out smallpox. It is a great school except for some departments that seem to attract all kinds of socialists, communists, etc. The Robert Wood Johnson foundation endows all kinds of activities including wings at Hopkins for peds. The former head of a department at Hopkins headed the RWJ foundation. They probably do not provide cover for terrorists either.
Tests are now being performed for Dr. Gerald Weisfogel who believes he may have had skin anthrax earlier than the mailings. There are three Gerald M. Weisfogel's listed in NJ - Franklin Park, Kendall Park and Metuchen. Dr. Gerald Weisfogel is chief of cardiology at the JFK Medical Center in New Jersey, which is in Edison, New Jersey. Edison is just across the river from New Brunswick.
Good Morning America (7:00 AM ET) – ABC November 12, 2001 Monday
…ROSS: (VO) Dr. Weisfogel says he diagnosed his black scab as a spider bite and now wonders if this is the same common misdiagnosis in other anthrax cases. What's more, he wonders if the bioterrorists might have been in his office.
Dr. WEISFOGEL: Have I come across patients from countries who might be doing this? Yes.
ROSS: You've treated people like that?
Dr. WEISFOGEL: Yes.
ROSS: In this time frame?
Dr. WEISFOGEL: Yes. But there's no proof that any of them have had any connection…
Kendall Park, Franklin Park, Edison, and Metuchen are all close to each other, going north on Rte. 1. So all the addresses are probably for the same guy: hospital in Edison, offices in Metuchen and either or Franklin Park or Kendall Park, and home in the fourth place
There are significant labs in Piscataway, across the river from New Brunswick, the main campus of RWJ. Robert Wood Johnson has two high-profile microbiology labs in Piscataway -- the CABM(Center forAdvanced Biotechnology and Medicine) and the Waksman Institute. The Waksman Institute is a "microbe farm," producing germ "products" for industry and research.
The Waksman fermentation facility is troubling, and contributing Freepers hope the FBI has included ALL reference labs that have fermentation specialties. Most solid state fermentation is done with fungal spores, but the same technique would apply to bacterial (anthrax) spores.
Metuchen is right up the road to the northeast. (And down the road about 12 miles along Route 1 is the Islamic Society and Franklin Park.)
The perp accidentally infected the lady in New York. He did not go there by subway – he drove in. He may have gone to New York to pick up or deliver the anthrax. The car he used is most likely still contaminated. He may have rolled down a window or opened a door at just the wrong time for Kathy. The perp, may be working for RWJ University Hospital and had a business contact with Kathy’s hospital.
A possible suspect in the Anthrax mailings is an Iraqi-American microbiologist who lives in Trenton, New Jersey (at last notice.) His name, or at least his alias, is "Waly Samar". In 1993, Mr. Samar was studying microbiology at Hunter College in NYC - less than a thousand feet from the Manhattan Eye, Ear and Throat Hospital where Kathy Nguyen worked - the latest victim of inhalation Anthrax. Waly Samar operated integrally with the Iraqi intelligence agents Abdul Rahman Yasin and Ramzi Yousef in planning, coordinating and executing the World Trade Center bombing on February 26th, 1993, the second anniversary of Kuwait's liberation from Iraqi occupation.
The perp is a member or attendee of The Islamic Society of Central Jersey. He has written many letters to them; he knows the zip code by heart. Although he gave a different town name on the return address (Franklin Park) – he automatically used the zip code he knew for that area. But the zip code does not go with Franklin Park.
The zip code on the return address from the Daschle letter is 08852, Monmouth Junction NJ – the location of the Islamic Society of Central NJ – headed by Dr. Malik, and including a mosque and a school.
There are probably canceled checks or correspondence at the Islamic Society of NJ that can be matched to his handwriting.
He is a member of Islamic student associations. He may have attended or be in association with a student at ETSU which is near an elementary school named "Greendale" in Abingdon, VA (a tri-state area.) He didn’t grab that name out of the air – neither brook nor dale would be common words to him.
In the alternative, he might have intentionally changed the name of a nearby school "Greenbrook" to "Greendale." The Greenbrook school only goes to the 4th grade.
Another possibility: Greendale and Franklin, WI are right next to each other. The NJ school is Greenbrook School, not Greendale. Could it be some Freudian slip? There are 15,000 Muslims in the area.
The block lettering may indicate that he is a tutor for elementary level students or has (or is undertaking) an engineering or architecture education.
The emphasis on the letters might have been intentional – pointing to ATTA.
If he is Al Queda, he may present himself secular – going to bars, joining clubs, protesting the terrorists, etc.
He may be dead or missing.
Medical anthrax trail - there should also be a star for New Brunswick!
| US |
Competing theories offered by contributing Freepers:
The perp is North Korean or possibly from China. English is not his primary language and neither is Arabic.
In the alternative, he is an operative for Cuba. Castro had a mole deep in the Department of Defense for years and has become close to Islamic fundamentalists. Cuba has advanced biochemical capabilities.
In the alternative, he is a white disgruntled American crackpot, keeping in mind all the anarchist websites and crackpot groups in this country.
In the alternative, he is an anti-Arab who is pretending to be an Arab.
In the alternative, the perp is has some connection with BioPort, which manufactures the anthrax vaccine. The biography of the Faud El-Hibri:
The sender does not appear to be an American. The date is written 09-11-01. Americans would have written 9/11/01, without the leading 0, and with slashes instead of dashes.
A telegrapher [commercial or railroad] or military communicator would have used the zero, but those trained since the 1970s routinely add a slash to the zero to differentiate it from the letter *O*. A European would follow the month/day/format of 11.09.01 and the similar US military format would routinely abbreviate the month to eliminate the confusion: 11 SEP 2001. Some computer-world oriented procedures also follow the logical day/month/year format, though since the Y2K panic, the year is most commonly written with all four digits.
Much has been made of the fact that the date is written in the American order of month-day-year, but most foreigners would be aware of that and, in fact, would have become accustomed to that order after a few years here -- they'd be repeatedly told by Americans that they were writing dates incorrectly if they used the day-month-year order. But nobody misunderstands a date written with dashes instead of slashes; nobody even comments on such a thing, so a foreigner could easily not realize that it looks foreign.
Note though that telegraphers [and some amateur radio operators] also sometimes send the quicker *dash* character [*----* in international Morse] rather than *slash* [-**-*] [or *stroke* in Brit/Euro parlance] and thereby routinely write that char as the seperator. And at least some air traffic controllers will use dashes, rather than slash/stroke.
The anthrax strain kept in Ames, Iowa is called 'Ames' though that is not exactly correct. It is a strain of the Ames group, 1 of 7 groups that exist for type A anthrax. Another group used by countries for weapons production is Vollum. Ames originates in the Middle East primarily. All type A anthrax eventually originates in Africa. The Ames substrain was found in Iowa 50 years ago and widely disseminated to many researchers. It is in fact the standard for vaccine testing worldwide.
In the alternative, the anthrax came from the former Soviet Union.
If the perp loaded the envelopes in a house or apartment, there should be some spilled or leaked anthrax that should infect other people in the vicinity sooner or later. But if he loaded the envelopes in a special science lab, there might not be any spilled anthrax at all.
And such equipment can't be had just anywhere. Neither are purchases for such equipment generally made with more or less untracable cash, so there'd likely be a paper trail back to the financial sources behind such an effort- in which case it wouldn't be *just one lone crazed gunman labman*.
KNF Neuberger, Inc. markets the necessary laboratory equipment. They are at Two Black Forest Road in Trenton NJ which is located very close to the Kuser Road, where the accountant was infected.
A Compilation of Evidence and Comments on the Source of the Mailed Anthrax
Barbara Hatch Rosenberg, 12 Nov 01
1. ANTHRAX STRAIN
--All letter samples are the same, and correspond to AMES in the N. Arizona State University database (which has been used for identification). That Ames sample was obtained from Porton Down (UK) in the mid-90's (the sample was marked "October 1932"); Porton had gotten it from USAMRIID.
--Many anthrax strains were isolated by labs in Ames, Iowa starting with one in 1928. There is much confusion about who has which sub-strain or which one is meant by "Ames."
--A 2000 paper by M. Hugh-Jones, PJ Jackson, P. Keim et al says that the Ames strain played a central role in the US BW program. Hugh-Jones says he learned that from David Huxsoll (Former Commander, USAMRIID). He also says Vollum 1B was the strain stockpiled.
--USAMRIID claims to have obtained the "Ames" strain around 1980 from the USDA lab in Ames, Iowa. They don't know when it was isolated. They did transfer the strain to Porton in the '80s. They claim have no information about the Ames strain prior to 1980.
--The Ames strain is highly virulent and is used now in the US biodefense program for testing vaccines etc.
--The Ames strain recurred in nature in 1997 on a Texas goat farm.
2. WEAPONIZATION
--The form in the senate letter: fine particles, very narrow size range (1.5-3 microns diameter), treated so it won't clump and will float.
--An ABC reporter who writes on anthrax vaccine has privately confirmed that four labs have told him that under the electron microscope the sample looks just like material obtained by UNSCOM in Iraq. The Iraqi material was spray-dried BT. I have been told that such particles are distinguishable from milled particles. The US process did not use milling.
--The senate sample contains silica, a drying agent used in the US process, and not bentonite (used by the Iraqis)
--The US weaponization process is secretBill Patrick, its inventor, says it involves a COMBINATION of chemicals. Therefore, further analysis should be able to determine whether or not the process used to make the letter anthrax was identical to the US secret process.
All the available information is consistent with a US government lab as the source, either of the anthrax itself or of the recipe for the US weaponization process.
3. TESTS IN PROGRESS?
--A study of genetic drift at certain locations in anthrax is said to be underway at Northern Arizona State Univ. This will give an idea of how many times the letter anthrax replicated, in comparison to the reference strainie, whether it was grown on a very large scale (as in a State program) or on a very small scale, as would be likely if recently made by a terrorist.
--Analysis of trace contaminants could be used to determine the method of production.
--Senator Bob Graham, Chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee, said that 30-40 labs in US and perhaps 100 worldwide could have produced the anthrax mailed Daschle. Investigators can identify with great certainty which lab produced the anthrax, Graham said, but it will be a laborious, time-consuming process. (Chicago Tribune, 27 Oct 01).
4. LETTER ANALYSIS
--Analysts believe the letters were not written by a Middle-Easterner. The FBI now conjectures that the perpetrator was a lone domestic terrorist (obviously one with a scientific background and lab experience who could handle hazardous materials).
5. TIMING
--There was only 1 week between 11 Sept and Sept. 18th, when the first two letters (and probably a letter, never found, to AMI) were postmarked. This suggests that the anthrax was already in hand before Sept 11.
--Did the perpetrator have advance knowledge of the Sept 11 attacks? Secretary of Defense Rumsfeld has said that he does not believe al Qaeda was responsible for the anthrax attack, and other public officials have increasingly indicated that the perpetrator was probably domestic.
6. PUBLIC STATEMENTS
-- AT FIRST, US officials provided miscellaneous bits of information, some conflicting; then denied some of the earlier information, then clammed up. Chances are they know more than they want to say. They are clearly concentrating on domestic investigations, however (the US even rejected a UN resolution condemning the anthrax attack, on the grounds that it might have been domestic terrorism).
--The Secretary of Health and Human Services said that some of the relevant information is classified, and some is restricted by the FBI.
7. SPECULATION
--The perpetrator was not only an American scientist but one with access to US weaponized anthrax or one who had been taught by an expert how to make it.
--An astute observer has pointed out that the letters warned of anthrax or the need to take antibiotics, making it possible for those who handled the letters to protect themselves; and that it seems unlikely that the perpetrator would have anticipated that the rough treatment of mail in letter sorters etc, would force anthrax spores through the pores of the envelopes (which were taped to keep the anthrax inside) and infect postal workers. It is therefore possible that the perpetrator's goal was not necessarily to kill but to create public fear, in order to raise the profile of BW for some reason, and that he simply took advantage of Sept 11 to throw suspicion elsewhere.
MORE DETAILED SPECULATION
1. The perpetrator was a microbiologist who had, or once had, access to weaponized anthrax in a US government lab. Perhaps he had a vial or two in his basement as a keepsake. He does not necessarily live in or near Trenton! Trenton is a stop on the Amtrack line that runs along the East coast. If he is smart enough to handle anthrax he is smart enough not to mail it from his home town.
2. The letter anthrax was made and weaponized in a US government lab, either before Nixon terminated the US BW program in 1969, or later, for biodefense purposes.
--If the sample was made before 1969, then the Ames reference strain in the N. Arizona collection (which matches the letter sample) would have to be an early Ames substrain, probably 1928. Although Vollum was the main strain stockpiled by the US, at least during WWII, it is not unlikely that the search continued for better strains, and that the US BW program later switched to Ames, which is considerably more virulent than Vollum.
--If the letter sample was made more recently it could be a later Ames substrain, eg, 1980. But weaponization of dry anthrax after 1972, when the BWC was signed, could be construed as a violation of the BWC.
--The confusion about Ames substrains might have been cleared up if Iowa State had not destroyed the original isolates recently; but now it is probably only USAMRIID that knows the key. When questioned, they were evasive. It seems probable that retired USAMRIID Commanders and consulting anthrax experts have also been asked to stop talking. Most likely USAMRIID has had both the 1928 and 1980 Ames substrains for a long time, and is not willing to say which one was transferred to Porton in the '80s (ie, which one is the N. Arizona reference strain, which came from Porton and matches the letter anthrax).
3. Clumping: All the letters may have contained the same material. The clumping of the anthrax in the two letters mailed on Sept 18 (to NBC and the NY Post) might have resulted from the letters getting wet in the course of mail processing or delivery, or the perpetrator might have deliberately caused it to clump. In addition, some filler might have been added to those two letters. Analysis has probably already answered these questions and more.
4. The motive of the perpetrator may have been to attract attention to biological weapons as a threat, either to push the US government toward retaliatory action against some enemy or to attract funding and recognition to some agency/company/program/etc. with which he has a connection. The choice of media and the Senate leader as targets fits these motives.
--The perpetrator may not even have intended to kill anyone. The postmark on the Daschle letter is difficult to read. It has been reported as Oct. 8 in one NY Times article and Oct 9 in another. On the FBI website it looks more like 3 or 5 Oct to some observers. It is possible that the perpetrator did not know of the first anthrax case (in Florida), which was first reported at about 4 pm on Oct. 4, when he mailed the last letter (to Daschle).
5. If the US government suspects or knows that the anthrax was an "inside" job, it would probably want to cover it up that politically embarrassing information for the time being and gradually suggest the truth, as seems to be happening.
Barbara Hatch Rosenberg, PhD
Natural Sciences
Today....
A Massachusetts Hazardous Material Worker cleans up a white powdery substance across the street from Boston University's Photonics Center on St. Mary's Street. According to the Brookline, Massachusetts, Fire Dept who responded to the call, the substance is currently being tested. ©AFP
Anyway.... not on the cover, but open up to the cover story, and just guess what the name of the author is?
KENAN MALIK - I found an online version of his article at his website, kenanmalik.com
I wonder if Malik/Malak are common names like Smith/Olson.
State says clerical error to blame for unaccounted anthrax
The Associated Press
Published: Friday, April 21, 2006
Updated: Friday, April 21, 2006
TRENTON, N.J. (AP) - New Jersey health officials on Friday said they cannot account for some anthrax once thought to be stored at a government laboratory, but said mistakes during previous inventories of the deadly bacteria may be to blame.
http://www.pressofatlanticcity.com/news/newjersey/story/6147721p-6145628c.html
Thanks for the cross-link!
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/news/1622444/posts
State Delays Report on Unaccounted Anthrax
Millennium Radio ^ | Thursday, April 27, 2006 | Joe Cutter
>>>The perp may be from Pakistan and may have sought out Dr. Malik’s help (because he is also from Pakistan) to get employment/access to a nearby university hospital, Robert Wood Johnson University Hospital at Hamilton. Dr Malik is on the staff there. The perp may have used lab facilities in the hospital (either at Hamilton or the main campus or one of its affiliates) to safely handle or prep the different batches of anthrax.
Dr. Malik has been in the U.S. since the 70's or so and is long established here. He is probably not a party to the terrorists. However, as head of the Islamic Center of Central NJ and being from Pakistan and having made it as a doctor here ... we wonder if a newcomer to the country living in that area, attending that mosque and wanting to become a doctor ... may have asked him for a job referral or such. <<<<<
Is the same Dr. Malik from here:
http://www.opednews.com/duncan_090504_njterrorism2.htm
New Jersey and Terrorism…Perfect Together
>>>Operation Diamondback which culminated with the arrests of two of the Jersey City men in June of 2001.
Diaa Moshen was sentenced to 30 months in prison and Mohamed Malik was freed and had his case sealed and purged of all references to Pakistan . Both men are now free and continue to walk the streets of New Jersey.<<<
Jeepers. Thanks for the ping!
Re: your post 131, interesting article, and by going to the author list, was able to find all 4 parts.
Could this have been the seller of the missile that took out Flight 800?
All these bad doctors, make me think about the muslim who was giving fake flu shots in the west and Las Vegas, about 4 years ago, he has been on my mind for several weeks.
Thanks for the alert and added info.
Good find, Cal.
I just ran across this old post through a series of links.
What are the odds that one of the anthrax attackers worked for KNF Nueberger? They were in the right place and they had the right equipment. Access to a lab that can process anthrax is very difficult. Access to a factory that produces lab equipment that can process anthrax is not so difficult.
Access to the equipment inside the factory may be positively easy once you are inside.
Hmmm ... interesting possibility, sig226!
Original thread:
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/571792/posts
Freeper Research on the Anthrax Perp
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.