Skip to comments.Obama Responds to Belmont Abbey Lawsuit. Epic Fail.
Posted on 02/20/2012 6:52:33 AM PST by marshmallow
The Obama administration today filed its first legal response to Belmont Abbey Colleges lawsuit challenging the controversial contraception mandate, according to The Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, which represents Belmont Abbey in this case.
The Obama administration had their first opportunity to explain to the court and the country why the mandate is not illegal and unconstitutional, and it seems like an epic fail.
You might have expected them to argue that we dont have a constitutional claim, Mark Rienzi of the Becket Fund told The Cardinal Newman Society. But instead they said hey, didnt you hear we may fix it someday?
Rienzi called it really cynical to have a law on the books but then argue that the court shouldnt look at the law, because the administration said theyd fix it some day in the future.
He said he suspected that the administration knew they were on shaky legal ground when the lawyers kept asking for extensions while the politicians kept holding press conferences. He said that the administrations promise to change the law in the future doesnt stand up to constitutional scrutiny.
Apparently, the administration has decided that the mandate, as written and finalized, is constitutionally indefensible, said Hannah Smith, senior counsel at The Becket Fund. Its only hope is to ask the court to look the other way based on an empty promise to possibly change the rules in the future.
The administrations legal filing is based on President Obama saying at a press conference last week that the rules may be changed in the future.
But the Becket Fund points out that whats said at a press conference is not legally binding and does nothing to change the law on the books.
(Excerpt) Read more at blog.cardinalnewmansociety.org ...
Why is the governemnt involved in contraception and murder?? The right to kill (Roe) should never have gotten to court.
A bigger question economically is why is the government involved in routine care? Why is a normal, expected out of pocket expense considered “insurance”, which by definition is a pooling of resources for coverage of improbable events?
Depends on the judge and the court. These days, it seams too many judges are just soldiers in the army of darkness (left). Decisions are not based upon the law, but on the desired outcome.
No wonder Obama had NO career in Law.
Right now, from what I can see, we're in a banana republic where the law is subjugated to the political left all because a black man is in the white house and no one wants to have the word "Racist" thrown at them.
Excellent point. Even more important is that covering all these routine maintenance expenses is very costly and jeopardizes any insurance plan's ability to provide affordable coverage for the really big, catastrophic expenses that few people earning much less than Rush Limbaugh can afford. Just look at auto insurance. If you want a $2,000,000 or $3,000,000 umbrella you can easily finance it by substantiallhy increasing your deductible, or you can go broke by keeping th low deductible and adding the umbrella.
I’m waiting for a plaintiff to arise from the business community.
Church-related institutions certainly have a beef, but those of us in the private sector are being forced to pay for these things that employees really haven’t demanded.
We’re accustomed to states mandating coverages, but not the Feds. The commerce clause could work in our favor here, because health insurance cannot be sold across state lines. A ruling in our favor would set back the commerce clause justification significantly.
While I’m ranting, allow me to say that I have first-hand experience to inform you that the psychiatric care mandated years ago in Virginia is much more egregious from a cost standpoint that the contraceptive mandate could ever be.
It is constantly and consistently abused for massive payments, and it is THE driver of recent increases in premiums in VA.
Curiously, you don't even have to allude to race in any way to be accused of racism. Any opposition to Obama's policies whatsoever will get you charged. On Facebook I have an aquaintance from another venue that is so rabidly leftist and illogical, that this was a recent exchange:
Me to another dude: "You are the problem. Forcing people to buy a product is nowhere to be found in the Constitution. Car insurance, I can understand, since you are using state-owned roads -- but you do not have to buy car insurance. You can t...ake a bus, or ask friends, or bike, or walk. This health-care mandate is not avoidable, unless you stop breathing. Your vision for what is right and proper, not to mention Constitutional, is more readily accepted in Cuba, or the former Soviet Union."
Rapid Vapid Leftist: "Having big business (corporate america) control the government and policy is Fascism...you people are picking scabs on a f-ing paper cut with all this re: healthcare...get a grip. You keep focusing on minor bullshit while the right moves in for the kill...geeze. And, as much as I will get grief from those affected...you don't like Obama because he is BLACK and you don't have the integrity to admit it!"
Me to Rabid Vapid Leftist: name omitted, you are the first person on this thread to mention anyone's race.
So, WHO is REALLY hung up about racial issues?
I de-friended you for a reason; looks like it was a good call."
What part of the Tenth amendment does Obama not understand?
The Tenth Amendment states the Constitution’s principle of federalism by providing that powers not granted to the federal government nor prohibited to the States by the Constitution are reserved to the States or the people.
Someone's constitutional theory is seriously behind the times. When a god speaks, is his word not law? And is it not sinful to question his words?
As I count the SC, we have four justices who will accept "Barack spaketh" as constitutionally binding, four who will not, and Justice Kennedy trying to make up his mind.
I started using Twitter a few weeks ago, and I have witnessed the ferocious attack on Andrew Breitbart, spearheaded by folks of the “Occupy” persuasion, and joined by such “luminaries” as Alec Baldwin himself. Almost without exception, I have noticed that the left generally tries to make its points by ad hominen attacks, liberally (pun intended) laced with scatological (rather than logical) references and profanity. Our side generally goes straight Jack Webb—sticking to “just the facts.” I see that your little contretemps followed the same script.
Delays??? Opposition research, corrupting a court, and finding the right mix of bribes to buy a Judge consumes many hours of work
Contraception ruling: Democrats accuse clergy of complicity with GOP at hearing
Catholic League on Sebeliuss admission before a Senate committee
Voris: Obama Able to Neutralize Catholic Resistance Thanks to Bishops Past Complicity
Abortion, Contraception and the Church Fathers (Catholic teaching unchanged for 2000 yrs)
Head of U.S. bishops: Obama compromise on mandate a hill of beans; opposition intensifies
USCCB President: 'Harder and Harder' to Accept Obama's Word
White House Criticizes Bishops, Trumpets Support from CHA, Catholic Charities
Political Science 101: how the White House snookered the USCCB on the 'compromise'
What Did CHA's Carol Keehan Know and When Did She Know It?
Pope Shares Remarks on American Culture with Bishops; Issues Call to Laity By: Msgr. Charles Pope
USCCB President says Obama offered next to nothing; expresses disappointment with Sr. Keehan
Evangelical Leaders Call for Civil Disobedience Against U.S. Government
Liberal Jews Speak Against HHS Mandate
Top nun who supported Obama mandate thanks pro-choice group in private e-mail
Catholic Health Association collaboration with Obama admin on mandate a scandal: Catholic leader
Obama's revised HHS mandate won't solve problems, USCCB president says
Fr. Frank Pavone: No compromise - the mandate has to go, period
Time To Admit It: The Church Has Always Been Right On Birth Control
Culture with Local Bishops and Issues a Call to the Laity [Ecumenical]
Bishops Reject Obama's 'Accommodation' - President's political hemorrhaging to continue.
HHS Mandate - Nothing Has Changed (Donald Cardinal Weurl)
Obama Chief of Staff: New Pro-Abortion Mandate Here to Stay
WH: We Are Done Negotiating With Catholics
Opponents launch new White House petition rejecting Obama rewrite of birth control mandate
Did the Leaders of the Catholic Church Make a Deal with the Redistributionist Devil?
Archbishop Chaput: HHS mandate insulting and dangerous
Cardinal-Designate Dolan no longer trusts Obama
American Catholicisms Pact With the Devil
Notre Dame Faculty to Obama: This Is a Grave Violation of Religious Freedom and Cannot Stand
White House: No More Compromise on Contraception
Obama's anti-religious implosion
Lew: Obama's latest stance on birth-control mandate final, puts issue to rest (CAPTION)
Pat Buchanan: 'Obama is trampling on God's turf' (Video)
W.H. official: Contraceptive rule stands
Obama chief of staff: No more compromise, contraceptive rule is done deal
Bishops Reject White Houses New Plan on Contraception (Obama continues his "War On Religion")
Faith/Pro-Life Leaders to Challenge Mandate by Praying and Risking Arrest in Front of the WH
Catholic Bishops: Don't Revise, Rescind
Obama's contempt for the Constitution
How the Catholic Church Became Cool Overnight
Chuck Colson Reacts to Obamas Compromise on Required Abortion Care for Church Employees
US Bishops: Obama's 'Compromise' Has No Clear Protection...(Needless Government Intrusion)
Protests Continue Over Insurance for Contraception, Abortifacients (Feds Under Increasing Pressure
Bishops to Obama: No dice
Paul VI: danger of this power passing into the hands of those public authorities ...
Michael Moore Goes On Anti-Catholic Twitter Rant, Distorts Contraception Debate
Religious controversy burns Obama again (the rookie Hussein is in WAY over his pay grade)
Another Catholic college vows it will not violate conscience on Obama mandate
Lutherans join chorus of voices slamming HHS contraceptive mandate
The Obama HHS 'Compromise' Switches the Tiger for the Lion (Not all Catholics buying Obama's bull)
Hannity on now with Priests, Pastors and Rabbis. Please watch
EDITORIAL: Obamas free abortion pills
U.S. bishops express concerns about Obama mandate accommodation
What Compromise? This Policy Leaves Religious Liberty in Peril and Planned Parenthood Smiling (Albert Mohler Opinion)
Bishops Renew Call To Legislative Action On Religious Liberty
Southern Baptist leader: Obama gave Christians the dismissive back of his hand
Obama's Act of Tyranny
Bishops Were Prepared for Battle Over Birth Control Coverage
'Accounting gimmick' -- Obama compromise still threatens religious liberty, leaders say
Bishops concerned over reworded mandate; other Catholic leaders slam as insult to injury
Obama Bows to Pressure, but His Religious 'Accommodation' Even Worse
Don't Be Deceived! Evil Obama Policy Now Even MORE Evil!
Obamas Contraceptive 'Compromise' Doesn't Pass the Smell Test ("It doesn't change a thing")
Compromise or Accommodation, its still unacceptable. (updated from Catholic Vote)
Pres. Obamas Plan B compromise, Sr. Keehan, and the Magisterium of Nuns
Land Says Obama Mandate Most Anti-Catholic Government Action in 150 Years
Motive, Means and Opportunity: Obamas Assault on Catholics
(Exempt Catholics) Joe Biden, Bill Daley warned of contraceptive backlash
(Tim) Thomas makes second political statement (Stands With Catholics)
Southern Baptist leader: If Obama mandate isnt changed, Christians will go to jail
Over 150 congressional leaders demand repeal of HHS mandate
Boehner vows to overturn Obamas birth control coverage rule
Boehner: Congress to overturn birth control policy if Obama does not reverse course
O'Brien says Archdiocese of Baltimore won't offer birth control coverage
Archbishop of San Francisco says Obama ruling strikes at religious freedom
How Obama Lost the Catholic Vote
I am going to stick with fellow Catholics in Pres. Obamas war on Catholics. Wherein Fr. Z rants.
Six Things Everyone Should Know about the HHS Mandate
Santorum: Obama Hostile to Christians
Understanding Oppostion to the HHS Mandate (Part 1): Why the Church Wont Pay for Contracept
The Bishops Chickens Coming Home to Roost.
65 Orthodox Church bishops call on Obama to rescind the unjust contraception mandate
Doug Kmiec Writes Obama: 'Friendship Will Not Permit Me to Disregard Duty to Faith and Country'
Catholic Outcry Over Obama Administration's Birth Control Decision Could Factor In Presidential Race
Standing with the Bishops [Catholic Caucus]
Updated: *167* Bishops (More Than 90% of Dioceses) Have Spoken Out Against Obama/HHS Mandate
Outrage! Military Tells Chaplains What They Can and Cant Say About HHS/ObamaAssault on Religion
Updated: *153* Bishops (Over 80% of Dioceses) Have Spoken Out Against Obama/HHS Mandate
An Affront Catholics Agree On [Liberal and Conservative Catholics Against Obama Mandate]
Army Silenced Chaplains Last Sunday
Catholic Military Archdiocese & Chaplains interfered with last Sunday by Pres. Obamas Admin
The Anti-Catholic President v. the Catholic Bishops
Sen. Rubio introduces bill to reverse Obama birth control mandate
Churches balk at birth control rule - Catholics wont comply, Bishop Kevin Rhoades says
Protestants and Jews declare to White House: We stand with Catholics
Checking the Air Outside [Bp. Zubik's follow up to Obama's To Hell with You]
Mohler [Southern Baptist] Says Insurance Mandate Not Just 'Catholic' Issue
An Open Letter to President Barack Obama Concerning Recent Tyranny (With Pictures!)
Lincoln bishop: prepare for 'suffering' under HHS mandate
Bishop David Zubik confronts Obama
Obamas war on the church
Pope hits out at 'radical secularism'
We Will Not Comply: Catholic Leaders Distribute Letter Slamming Obama Admin Contraceptive Mandate
We Will Not Comply: Catholic Leaders Distribute Letter Slamming Obama Admin Contraceptive Mandate
Bruskewitz: Fight Insurance Ruling [Sebelius a "bitter, fallen away Catholic"]
Letter from Archbishop John G. Vlazny on the matter of freedom of conscience and decisions by HHS
Bishop Olmsted's Letter to Catholics [Catholic Caucus]
Liberty for the Amish & Quakers but not Catholics. . .
Contraception mandate prompts Peoria bishop to instate St. Michael Prayer (Catholic Caucus)
Phoenix bishop (Olmstead): defy feds on birth control
A letter from Archbishop Dennis M. Schnurr concerning HHS edict
Speak honestly: abortion is the killing of tiny human beings in the womb Denver bishop
Bishop [Daniel Jenky] Blasts Secularist Intolerance, Calls For Assertive Action to Defend Church
(Pittsburgh Bishop Zubik comments:) HHS delays rule on contraceptive coverage
Dolan: Natural law, not religious preference, dictates all life sacred
Religious leaders blast HHS over contraception mandate
Mandated Contraception, Sterilization: Caesar Demands Church Violate Conscience
OBAMAS CONTEMPT FOR RELIGIOUS LIBERTY (mandates coverage of sterilization & contraception)
Implications of Obama Admin move to force Cath hospitals to provide contraception and sterilizations
Catholic doctors group launches petition against contraception mandate
Contraception mandate tramples religious freedom, US bishops say